He was good last year but has been terrible this year ,needs to work harder !

Agree!

Him and Ablett senior you would change ends for!

Luv Eddie and the way he goes about things but he has certainly put his foot in it here!

Thank god someone has the courage to speak up,if not the game will go further down the plug hole!

Gram and Dawson played well in a good side and both have been a loss!

Agree with WW!

It's not about feeling warm and fuzzy about Kosi ,Lee and White are no where near ready for AFL and gifting them a couple of games to "get games into them" could wreck their future careers ,it's about time we looked after the young kids coming through instead of gifting them games.Let them...

Agreed,but I would give Kossy 2 games and see how he goes ,at the moment Lee and White are not ready for AFL and Sippos's confidence is down.Maister will always get a couple against weak sides but good sides expose him.Roo enjoys Kosi being there and it takes the pressure of 2 or 3 back men belting ...

Love it!

Sometimes what you have done in the past counts.Look at how many people wrote Roo off last year and now he is in all Australian form !

Chips lives in Beaumaris!

Be a great pick up and can play!

Agree with the good Dr and BigCarl ,the guy has never been played forward of the centre ,I hope he finds a club and I wish him well!

As a player I would rather be at the westpac centre than down at seaford. What were we thinking when we left moors bin!

The way Lyon left was insulting to the Stkilda Football Club and it's supporters ,no matter which way you sugarcoat things,there is a right way and a wrong way and he chose the wrong way$!

Someone with some balls at our football club needs to stand up for Milney ,its time for the coach to show some leadership and go into bat for his players,like brad Scott does.

Winmar was a beautiful footballer,his skills were as good as any player I have seen in 45 years of football,great mark,beautiful kick, extraordinary talent!

Sick of the raph bashing gents, he hasn't been great, but by geez he's had some mates,gwilt,dal,Goddard,montagna

G.Fode played for black rock,top bloke round the club!

Thanks !!

Does anyone know if there are any practice games this weekend at Beach Road Oval??

Definately dissapointing that a club won't take a punt on football talent and try and take him on ,might be the way football is heading .Its going to get a bit sterile if thats the case!

John Mcintosh was an absolute star 6'3 could kick either foot and was a brilliant mark ,i often wonder why he's isn't brought up in discussion even though he did only play 50 odd games ,was cut down by injury.