reincarnated wrote:Zac has defensive issues that will be continued to be masked should we win and continue to

An average player lucky to be drafted into a good team . Will be found wanting in the coming weeks

Why should I give two figs about second rate players from a VFL team I never supported? Either CS or Sandy? I have ALWAYS been a Williamstown supporter and even when they were witht he filth, althought I wouldn't go to watch them, I sort of supported them, now they are free of the filth I will supp...

joffaboy wrote:Couldn't care less about non Saints players.

With that attitude thats why we at Casey Scorpions are so happy that the alignment with St. Kilda has ended.

LTN16 wrote:Who would we rather out of Alex Silvagni or Zac Dawson ??

The last time the met Dawson was held goaless by Silvagni and was taken off him and sent down the field . Silvagni by 2 miles.

Silvagni: Sergio Silvagni, a ruckman defender who played many games for Carlton; Steve Silvagni, Serge's son, a defender (who could kick a goal) played many games for Carlton and was named AFL Full Back of the last century. Alex Silvagni, a defender who plays for Casey Scorpions and has done nothin...

now that we havent recruited him i am all for the idea yes, he would have been a perfect depth player but he also would have taken the spot that a kid can play the best thing about our list at the moment is that we are forced to play kids, even if it costs us a game, it is better for the future our...

please be SERIOUS!!!!!!!!!!! Totally agree Alex. Silvagni the better option Silvagni was massacred in the final for Casey Scorpions. Totally destroyed by a VFL full forward who could not even get drafted or rookied into the AFL. How would he fare against a top flight AFL full forward. Please be ser...

ralphysaints35 wrote:please be SERIOUS!!!!!!!!!!!

Totally agree Alex. Silvagni the better option

Burgo's Phantom draft is up now. http://www.afl.com.au/News/NEWSARTICLE/tabid/208/Default.aspx?newsId=70169 Not particularly happy with his Saints' selections- #13 Sam Blease #47 Steven Gaertner #48 Matt DeBoer #62 Taylor Hunt #74 Luke Lowden #83 Nathan Carroll Alex. Silvagni for Carroll anyday

ralphysaints35 wrote:Stupid Stupid Decision Stkilda

Totally agree

Very good selections Saintbot. Only player I would put in front of Yarran for us is Swift. L.Jones, son of ex saint Bob Jones, another good choice. I still cant see the value in Carrol, maybe a youngster who could fill the fullback position in time may be better value. I suggest Alex Silvagni 92 kg...

I've been thinking we need another player up forward, since our midfield kick very little goals we really need some guys up front. And i don't really think Allen is going to make it, from what i saw this year (not much) he didn't look that great and he was a pick in the 50's so i guess that does no...

B: baker , hudgton , gilbert HB: s fisher , maguire , gram C: montagna , hayes , ray HF: goddard , riewoldt , dalsanto F: milne , allen , koschitzke FOLL: king , cousins , ball INT: armitage , schneider , r clarke , blake looks an awsome proposition with hope a number of things go our way. - we dra...

Check out WWW.sportingpulse.com.au and statistics and see who had the better stats out of Carroll ,Dawson and Silvagni you see it was Silvagni. Was leading the clubs best and fairest until injured for 4 weeks. Won the clubs most consitent.Held Dawson goaless when he played on him. Can Watts Naitanui...

So in regards to our rookie draft - we're retaining Khan, promoting Eddy, bringing in McGrath & the Irishman - which means we have 3 spots left to fill? Or are the scholarship holders & international rookies separate to the 6 "local" rookies? well how about Alex Silvagni and kyle ...

[quote="Animal Enclosure"]I totally agree on Zac Dawson. We are very light on for key defenders, especially ones that are 6'4, athletic & have a few years of development already in them. While Dawson was roundly criticised after Clarkson threw him to the wolves, he definitely did show ...

Maguire and Baker both struggled in VFL this year due to injury will not be up to AFL standard next year and Gilbert will make a good VFL player but lacks AFL skills. Rest of team looks ok. quote="S.A Saint"]If everything goes according to plan with no new injuries and discounting any new ...

saintbrat wrote:has anyone got a contact that may be able to provide a result- I heard that several Saintrs were right up there in suggested voting.

1st James Wall 2nd Shane Birss 3rd. Michael Rix.Most Consistent Alex. Silvagni

Hey homie here, does anyone know any info on a Backman we should draft or a pacey ball magnet midfielder? Cousins, O'Keefe, Silvagni :D If your talking about that silvagni from the scorps his piss weak :x[/quote Your kidding voted one of the best 15 out of 18 times while playing for Casey Scorpions...

the likely team (hopefully round 1) B: Baker Hudghton Gilbert HB: R Clarke S Fisher Maguire C: Goddard Hayes Gram HF: Eddy Riewoldt Schneider F: Milne (Key Forward Drafted this year) Jones Foll: King Ball Dal Santo I/C: Kossie Gwilt McEvoy Steven thoughts? Forget Baker and Maguire both struggled wi...

Are Ball,Baker and Michael Gardiner eligible to play? If St Kilda loose and we play Nth. Ballarat what players are eligible to play against them? Where will this game be played? How many AFL players can we play when we play Port Melb in the finals? Thanks Best arrangement for Casey Scorpions - Saint...

My theory is that you need to produce/find 2 new players per year. The last 4 years (since BJ) we have only produced/found 2 good players. That leaves us 6 players short of the 8 we needed. We need to somehow draft/recruit/beg/borrow/steal 8 good players to be any good next year - Given that findin...

Consistency and an injury free run; you have proven to be a valued back up for the saints and finally found a plce to settle after you years of roaming. The Scorpions will also celebrate Michael Rix’s 100 VFL game. Rix has been a fantastic contributor for the Scorpions and hopefully his run of ga...

Most VFL pundits had Casey just about inked in as a bottom 4 spot this year, instead they were fighting for top 4 in the final round. Full credit to the following people. James Wall Alex Silvagni Greg Hutchison David Armitage (B&F) And all other players who played in the Casey wins this season....

The scheduling of the Casey game on Saturday will do one of two things: 1. Disadvantage Casey if the Saints keep a couple of extras on ice (which they should). 2. Disadvantage the Saints if all emergencies, or even most, play on Saturday. Thats why the VFL is a lottery when you are aligned with an ...