There’s some weird stuff going on on this forum - I don’t really know the curly agenda other than he gets pissed when the frees for and against are bad - which unfortunately is most weeks I’m pretty sure most recent years back him up re the stats of our ‘frees for’ Does he think there’s an afl consp...

I have been reluctant to get involved in the debate about the free kick against Hayes last week. However, as I saw it, the player was brought to ground with his arms completely pinned, which is always a dangerous tackle (albeit nothing bad happened on this occasion), and certainly should be against...

Put us out of our misery and f#ck off

They are full of top 10 draft picks , we are full of mature age South Australian state league players - and as good as those guys have been we probably can’t expect to be a top team this year

Kent, owens, Byrnes out
Sharman, long & ? In

Long has lost confidence due to tribunal treatment which I think has bern harsh - saints need to tell him to play his natural game - even if he is just adding pressure and tackling he’s better than Kent

Kent, owens, Byrnes out
Sharman, long & ? In

Long has lost confidence due to tribunal treatment which I think has bern harsh - saints need to tell him to play his natural game - even if he is just adding pressure and tackling he’s better than Kent

Rubber chested hack - it makes no sense to pick him - how was he picked ?

Was easily the best player on the ground for the third quarter and probably our best for the night

Was leaning forward reaching for the ball and didn't bring his arm in quickly enough to brace for impact. Was hit slightly from behind while his arm was not in the correct position. This left the joint exposed. If his arm was by his side and properly tensed he would have got up up and kept playing....

Was leaning forward reaching for the ball and didn't bring his arm in quickly enough to brace for impact. Was hit slightly from behind while his arm was not in the correct position. This left the joint exposed. If his arm was by his side and properly tensed he would have got up up and kept playing....

Clark has a poor technique in protecting himself... Contributed to this latest injury I agree with this - can’t fault his bravery - but he needs to protect himself for impacts a little more - leaves himself open I think If he doesn’t address this I’m concerned he is going to spend a lot of time on ...

I can see what the league is aiming for - but as already discussed above this is way too subjective and open to umpire error if it is to be 100% zero tolerance - which is what seemed to be the case last night The umpires will have way too much influence on the outcome of a game if this goes wrong wh...

I just want to know how Carlton can keep bringing in big dollar recruits each year ? Saad , Williams,Cerra maybe a few lesser likes on top of that - plus with their previous run of poor seasons they are stacked with top 10 draft picks who must demand some kind of decent $$

How does it add up ?

I think he spent a fair bit of his time at Geelong training as a defender - but has been utilised forward and back on game day for who ever he has played for the last few years ? Cant say I'm an expert on him - but have wondered more than once why haven't had a crack at him over the last year or so ...

I'm willing to admit that Corey Enright might know a bit more about Blake Schlensog than I do - but I dont know why we arent having him train ?

I cant see why we would consider Naish given who we already have on the list

How old is he ?
How big ?
Can he play ?

Well, if we haven't already, all clubs could now snap him up, as of back on the 10th up until the 9th of March. If another club approached him, you would think he would pay us the courtesy of giving us a chance to make him an offer. Gives him some bargaining power. But I suspect it is only us inter...

I don’t want to see him for the saints for another 18 months or so I’m a perfect world Ryder & Marshall have a good run this year with injuries and rest periods and Campbell surpasses expectations in the handful of games he plays when either of those guys are rested or otherwise unavailable Give...

Time to drop the 'Co' from his title

saintly wrote: ↑Sun 12 Dec 2021 7:12pm Saints won't be bringing anyone in till after Xmas

Im not sure of the logic behind that - any ideas ?

Have we not invited anyone to train ? we have 2 spare spots and a GLARING need for a ready to go KPD - so it surprises me no one ‘speculative’ is training We have ( seemingly) done very well in the mid season draft but we’ve also done very well I think with the ‘train with ‘ and draft and we in my o...

Here are some mature age KPD that got delisted Michael Hartley 28 years old 199cm 100kg 49 games I know Collingwood has him to play for there VFL side for 2022 but I am unsure if he is tied to them I don't think so. Jarrod Leinart got Delisted from Port 27 year old 195cm 95 kg 23 games and the last...

I’m more keen to see if we can unearth a mature kpd from somewhere to be invited to train

I like seeing Jaxons posting and agree with him that there have been some great rookie rucks and there are probably some good players out there waiting to be discovered BUT I don’t agree that Campbell is a disaster and lazy recruiting I would think if you are going to have 4 rucks on the list the mi...