Can we please stay on topic rather than try to provoke old feuds. Who put you in charge...I thought Saynta's comment relevant The clear and unnecessary swipe at a particular forumite that he’s feuding with was not relevant to the discussion Not hard to feud with this particular forumite as his love...

skeptic wrote: ↑Sun 17 Oct 2021 6:27pm Can we please stay on topic rather than try to provoke old feuds.

Who put you in charge...I thought Saynta's comment relevant

Many detractors here criticizing the club for not trying to entice Talia to St Kilda. Does anyone know if they have or if there are circumstantial reasons why not? maybe his wife is a rocket scientist and won't move or Talia has his own successful business and not worth anything to him to move??????...

Did not Richo's kids go to the same school as Petracca and Richo knew Petracca and his parents aside from football
Because we had 1st pick I was following everything draft news/phantom etc at the time but age is catching up and my memory is slipping

Well said Saynta. Lyon is a dog of a person and cared little about st kilda, did not draft for future, squeezed everything out of the group ensembled by others and then bolted as planned in demand.

An exodus of destruction - how any saint supporter has any affection for this lowlife is inconceivable

saynta wrote: ↑Tue 31 Aug 2021 8:02pm

SaintPav wrote: ↑Tue 31 Aug 2021 7:38pm And Sheedy!!

Yeah, well we all knew Sheedy was a lying prick.

I met him once. Took an instant dislike to him. Arrogant prick.

It's because wherever he is people swarm around him like flies to s***

Happy to see Essendon lose….yey….done go the Bombers in flames…hip hip hooray. But no doubt, that Bulldogs forward milked the umps to a tee, and kicked four goals, at least three from ill deserved but sneakily gotten frees. Tackled? Easy. Duck into the corner of the armpit of the tackler raising th...

I wish just one day perhaps in a couple of finals, we’d get a run from the umpires like the dogs. Last year at the Gabba I believe 7 of their 10 goals against us came from a free kick. It was funny that today it was Essendon though Ask Doggies supporters about the 09 prelim final! Yep, 17 frees api...

Can we put this to bed now- the dogs/bombers game, one I care little about shows clearly how poor umpiring can decide a game. Are we surprised that 5 of the first 7 goals to the dogs came from free kicks? The raised arm high frees have been a blight on the game - yet the umps still fall for it and ...

Petracca was always the best talent and all other clubs recognized this but us - On drafting McCartin we (supporters) hoped our recruiters seen something that everyone else did not. Recruiting is not exact science but we appear to take more left fielders than any other club. I'm still pissed with th...

Seb Ross is better than Higgins WTF are you on about? One is a small forward/half forward who’s played 60 games, averages 15ppg, 2.3 tackles and 0.87 goals The other is an inside/outside mid Played 160 games, averages 23.5, 3.75 tackles has won 2 B&Fs and made the AA squad. Has Captained StK an...

They keep topping their list up with free agents every year. I think that we'll may run dry for them and they have 10 players who are 30+. Surely it's coming to an end. Sounds like us...we have to give ourselves a chance to recruit youth and develop into a grade players. The alternative is not cond...

How would kennett get his commission if he left it to sporting clubs?

The_Dud wrote: ↑Fri 27 Aug 2021 8:14pm There’s not many sadder places on Earth than the pokies lounge!

Maybe a funeral parlor...
Bur yeah, they're very insociable

The_Dud wrote: ↑Thu 26 Aug 2021 12:28pm I think Dunstan's "poor kicking" ability is almost the biggest myth going around here atm. Totally overblown.

Says more about you than dunstan

We don't want to win - would gain 2 places on the ladder may hurt draft prospect

Lyon squeezed all the energy out of the group never developed any new players for future and was always going to depart enhancing his own glory but leaving saints underdeveloped with years of misery.
Lyon was all about lyon not st kilda....prick of a person

There is a notion that the midfield has no quality Not sure I fully agree, for a starters I believe we have the best two-way midfielder in the AFL. Will finish top 5 in coaches votes and Brownlow again, will be AA again. Jack Steele - A gun midfielder! Brad Crouch - Contested ball winner, possessio...

Billing must keep - when fit is easily in our top 5-8 Others we need better to be top 4 team Strange how our B&F never reflects that Refer below 2019 - last time Billings was fit for the full season...has been playing injured the last two years and also when drafted. Sure injuries are a problem...

Billing must keep - when fit is easily in our top 5-8
Others we need better to be top 4 team

I don’t even want to read about it The AFL can get f***ed and Gillan McLaughlin is a c***!!! And if I ever get anywhere near him, I’ll call the prick out!!! Show some balls and do the right thing They manage to prop a basket case up, yer won’t consider a viable option F*** off!!! Showing your true ...

His clangers stand out because some look for them Had three clangers against Sydney Steele 6 Marshall 8 I think 2 or 3 clangers in 20 possessions is normal. He is clearly maligned, for whatever reason?! It's only when he kicks forward that he comes up with clangers...normally holds up play and chip...

Lets fill up our list with fringe players - why have we not thought of this before?

Should we take mids first as we need A Grade in the middle where games are won?
KP players take longer to mature and somewhat riskier

Got to say, I feel sorry for the kid... Got his pants pulled down last night but for a while now he’s being treated like a player that is viewed as being able to do it all himself He’s not. Max Hudghton had this legacy of being an incredible defender that was rarely beaten but the reality is that i...