Easily makes our 22 so why not.

Not a bad 22 from TheRoar B: Jarryn Geary, Jake Carlisle, Callum Wilkie HB: Dylan Roberton, Dougal Howard, Hunter Clark C: Dan Hannebery, Seb Ross, Bradley Hill HF: Jade Gresham, Tim Membrey, Jack Lonie F: Dan Butler, Max King, Jack Billings Foll: Rowan Marshall, Jack Steele, Luke Dunstan Interchan...

Not a bad 22 from TheRoar B: Jarryn Geary, Jake Carlisle, Callum Wilkie HB: Dylan Roberton, Dougal Howard, Hunter Clark C: Dan Hannebery, Seb Ross, Bradley Hill HF: Jade Gresham, Tim Membrey, Jack Lonie F: Dan Butler, Max King, Jack Billings Foll: Rowan Marshall, Jack Steele, Luke Dunstan Interchan...

Harves Man wrote: ↑Sat 11 Jan 2020 12:02am I would much rather think of Zac Jones taking on the great Nathan Burke's number, than that of TT (oh, you know - Tubby Turncoat).

Do you mean Steven?

B.M wrote: ↑Thu 09 Jan 2020 7:33am Chances

Nick Coffield
Doulton Langlands
Max King
Ben Long
Jack Bytel
Logan Austin
Ed Phillips
Ben Paton
Matty Parker
Daniel McKenzie
Ryan Byrnes
Darragh Joyce
Oscar Clavarino

Next time tell us who isn’t a chance...

I don’t know BFUSA, Kind of feel like what ur saying is kind of a perpetuation of a bizarre way of thinking that has crept into the game over the last decade or so which is to describe intangibles, use stats (speaking more broadly on that point) to justify a view that is just not evident. I’ve hear...

Coffield has to start back for mine. Has talent and before injured started to get some confidence and open the game up with precision attacking kicks rather than the usual crap 20m sideways stuff. Geary shouldn’t be a lock as back pocket anymore. How many AA or premiership backs can’t kick? Geary i...

saintspremiers wrote: ↑Wed 11 Dec 2019 8:10pm We should have a number 32.

All numbers up to 40 should be filled.

Yep reckon this will be the reason we miss finals...

Look good.

Don’t like the dare sponsor position but whatever.

Wish we were sponsored by Nike or Adidas or something

It’s a bit unbalanced... to tall, not enough, run. Geary, Howard, Wilkie Roberton Carlisle Coff Hill Ross Jones Billings Battle Hind Gresh Ryder Membrey Marshall Steele Hannebery Int - Clarke, Bytel, Webster, Long/Lonie, Coff’s done nothing to deserve a game and be considered best 22. Bytel’s barel...

Trev from the Bush wrote: ↑Sat 07 Dec 2019 2:13pm Gotta respect the opinion of Sarah Black, one of the all time great players of the AFL.

Who is she?

What’s wrong with the lineup?

No other journalists at afl.com.au have played AFL so you just look like a tossbag with that comment. Well done.

The players we have weren’t working...

Do you honestly think it’s not worth a try?

I know it is a business but he is also very happy being the highest paid player at the club. Should he not be the highest paid player? Walks in one of our best players, and you need to pay more to persuade a trade especially when you’re not a big club that hasn’t played finals for 8 years. Not sure...

Welcome to Byrnes.

Had a sharp looking profile pic on the draft tracker which is good.

What a load of s*** this is. Should have stopped where you stated Ryder was the better player trying to justified the outrage. So you believe that Abbott is a better player than Ryder. Interesting view. IMO Ryder is yes a better player than Abbott. + Ryders trade cost was next to nothing. Ryder was...

We obviously didn’t think he was worth more than a rookie but posters still don’t understand why we would pass ? List spots and the fact that there are other kids available are some of the (very important) reasons that come to mind...

Weird.

So don't we have to take 3 picks?

Where’s the outrage that followed the addition of Ryder? It is chalk and cheese. Ryder has been taken to play first 22 and is older (though better). There is also the argument of whether it is better to play a ruck and true KF or two rucks (who are handy forward). ie Marshal/Bruce or Marshall/Ryder...

Where’s the outrage that followed the addition of Ryder?

Trev from the Bush wrote: ↑Tue 19 Nov 2019 7:11pm Hmmm, don't know who Sarah Black is but she needs to do her homework. Ranked 15th only because it is St Kilda, the bias is ingrained.

Wow - we had picks 1, 21 and 22 who have done jack all and you think we should be ranked higher.

Bias? Look in the mirror...

Langlands...wow...40 seconds knocked off his previous best. Maybe this is Howard's plan. He'll knock 40 seconds off this year's time next season and we'll be raving about how far he's come. Up here for thinking! Could it be Nathan Brown has been using this tactic for the last 12 years? Just happens...

Why would Marshall be worried anyways? He has 10 years left at AFL... Ryder has 1-2.

One of the biggest beat ups on this site I can remember.

AA, a magnificent tap ruckman, and some experience in a position we are lacking. Cheap too.

+1 !

Does being a drug addict make one a bad character? How did a bad character Captain an AFL club for 5 years? Is it possible for a drug addict to stop using, either for periods of time or for good? Was Ben Cousins a bad person when not under the influence of drugs? Did Ben Cousins use drugs when at R...

I think the club did the right thing by not recruiting Cousins in 2009. He was injury-prone for starters. He would have kept someone out which may have also held back the development of players like Montagna who really came into his own that season. I think I may have read in Dave Mission’s ”The Bu...