can someone tell me why...

This unofficial St Kilda Saints fan forum is for people of all ages to chat Saints Footy and all posts must be respectful.

Moderators: Saintsational Administrators, Saintsational Moderators

Post Reply
User avatar
stinger
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 38126
Joined: Tue 09 Mar 2004 9:06pm
Location: Australia.

can someone tell me why...

Post: # 1343180Post stinger »

...why the saints have been crucified by the umpires all year......in every game ...

....i am sure there has been a thread on this but i was out of the country for over three weeks.......just watched the dullbogs game.......flower me......i have never witnessed more attrocious umpiring......roo was robbed of three certain kicks on goal early in the match by dogs players using illegal tactics......front on kicks to his legs, chopping of the arms...pushes in the back and whacks to the head......in the last two minutes he clearly marks the ball before copping a whack to the jaw by picken......no mark or free paid even though roo was clearly hit in the head and knocked out......what do the maggots do???....pay a mark to the dog son of a dog....you have got to be flowering kidding...but they aren't...are they...they are for flowering real...to the detriment of a fair game imhfo.......there were many other blatant errors that even the sick making commentary team ....who were rooting for the dogs.....highlighted.....

....put that together with a couple of other games...the swine game in nz for example and it is no wonder the saints players are dispirited....i know i am......


i would be of some comfort if we had a club leader with some balls who prepared to go into bat for us...seems we don't though......right??


.everybody still loves lenny....and we always will

"Freedom of expression is the cornerstone of a free society,"

However, freedom of expression is not encouraged in certain forums.
plugger66
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 50626
Joined: Mon 26 Feb 2007 8:15pm
Location: oakleigh

Re: can someone tell me why...

Post: # 1343188Post plugger66 »

Ask Curly. He has every decision on tape.


CURLY
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 10457
Joined: Fri 16 Feb 2007 3:24pm
Location: WARBURTON
Has thanked: 148 times
Been thanked: 1329 times

Re: can someone tell me why...

Post: # 1343199Post CURLY »

The umpires have been fine. The have been consistent with their decsions and to date.


NO IFS OR BUTS HARVS IS KING OF THE AFL
User avatar
SaintPav
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 19099
Joined: Wed 16 Jun 2010 9:24pm
Location: Alma Road
Has thanked: 1603 times
Been thanked: 2018 times

Re: can someone tell me why...

Post: # 1343201Post SaintPav »

We're only noticing the umpiring because we are so shyte.

In years we dominated like 04, 09 and even 10, the umpiring didn't even enter the frame. Desicions tend to go your way when you have control of the ball.

Different story now I'm afraid.


Holder of unacceptable views and other thought crimes.
User avatar
stinger
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 38126
Joined: Tue 09 Mar 2004 9:06pm
Location: Australia.

Re: can someone tell me why...

Post: # 1343210Post stinger »

SaintPav wrote:We're only noticing the umpiring because we are so shyte.

In years we dominated like 04, 09 and even 10, the umpiring didn't even enter the frame. Desicions tend to go your way when you have control of the ball.

Different story now I'm afraid.
no...i'm mentioning the umpiring in this game because my eldest son asked me to watch the match with specific regard to the umpiring which he believed cost us the match..... ......i have watched football for over 60 years and this year is the worst ..from a saints perspective ...that i can remember....


after watching the match, i would have to agree with my son, although....three posters and maister's inability to mark a dry ball didn't help


.everybody still loves lenny....and we always will

"Freedom of expression is the cornerstone of a free society,"

However, freedom of expression is not encouraged in certain forums.
spert
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 9142
Joined: Wed 29 Jun 2005 10:39pm
Location: A distant beach
Has thanked: 1 time
Been thanked: 437 times

Re: can someone tell me why...

Post: # 1343220Post spert »

The best team usually wins the match, and in our case, we are running second to the ball, giving away dumb frees and all the good or bad umpiring in the world won't change that. I thought we were lucky against North to get away with a few which probably should have gone against us. The umpiring is never so obvious when you are a winning team.


User avatar
kosifantutti
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 8583
Joined: Fri 21 Jan 2005 9:06am
Location: Back in town
Has thanked: 527 times
Been thanked: 1532 times

Re: can someone tell me why...

Post: # 1343234Post kosifantutti »

The umpires didn't pay the mark to Picken.


Macquarie Dictionary Word of the Year for 2023 "Kosi Lives"
User avatar
Waltzing St Kilda
SS Hall of Fame
Posts: 2171
Joined: Sun 14 Mar 2010 5:20am
Location: Melbourne
Has thanked: 2 times
Been thanked: 361 times

Re: can someone tell me why...

Post: # 1343242Post Waltzing St Kilda »

We've been treated poorly by the umpires for about three years now. That's not perception, it's reality. It's not paranoia, it's the truth. This year we're statistically the worst off, and it's not just because we have a few young players.

The reason? I put it down to all the negative cloud of publicity that descended upon St Kida since 2009 -- Lovett, Duthy, the reopened Milne case, Lyon's defection, even Ricky Nixon. The Saints were hung out to dry by the media and the whole team has been painted as a sacrificial lamb. To deny that such thinking has an influence on the umpire's whistle is to deny human nature.

A few years ago Dermott Brereton, who has a habit of issuing half-baked statements with the air of a mighty sage, declared that "umpiring had never been responsible for the result of a game." It was arrant nonsense but other commentators then started parroting it. The truth is that umpiring has influenced MANY results, and St Kilda in the last couple of years has suffered the worst. I can't see it getting better for a while.


plugger66
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 50626
Joined: Mon 26 Feb 2007 8:15pm
Location: oakleigh

Re: can someone tell me why...

Post: # 1343243Post plugger66 »

Waltzing St Kilda wrote:We've been treated poorly by the umpires for about three years now. That's not perception, it's reality. It's not paranoia, it's the truth. This year we're statistically the worst off, and it's not just because we have a few young players.

The reason? I put it down to all the negative cloud of publicity that descended upon St Kida since 2009 -- Lovett, Duthy, the reopened Milne case, Lyon's defection, even Ricky Nixon. The Saints were hung out to dry by the media and the whole team has been painted as a sacrificial lamb. To deny that such thinking has an influence on the umpire's whistle is to deny human nature.

A few years ago Dermott Brereton, who has a habit of issuing half-baked statements with the air of a mighty sage, declared that "umpiring had never been responsible for the result of a game." It was arrant nonsense but other commentators then started parroting it. The truth is that umpiring has influenced MANY results, and St Kilda in the last couple of years has suffered the worst. I can't see it getting better for a while.

You cant honestly think the umpires give us less frees or the opposition more because of bad publicity 3 years ago?


User avatar
bigred
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 11463
Joined: Tue 09 Mar 2004 7:39am
Has thanked: 25 times
Been thanked: 609 times

Re: can someone tell me why...

Post: # 1343251Post bigred »

Grant Thomas legacy.


"Now the ball is loose, it gives St. Kilda a rough chance. Black. Good handpass. Voss. Schwarze now, the defender, can run and from a long way".....
User avatar
GrumpyOne
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 8163
Joined: Wed 17 Mar 2010 9:25am
Location: Kicked out of the Coffee Shop, Settlement Pub, Cranbourne

Re: can someone tell me why...

Post: # 1343257Post GrumpyOne »

Can't honestly say that I have perceived any bias from the umpires. Been some shocking decisions, and we have been lucky on other occasions, but overall, impartiality has been evident.


Australia...... Live it like we stole it....... Because we did.
User avatar
hungry for a premiership
Club Player
Posts: 856
Joined: Fri 08 Oct 2010 2:01am

Re: can someone tell me why...

Post: # 1343259Post hungry for a premiership »

This argument has happened a million times at every single club and i hereby give you

THE TRUTH


It's not that the umpires deliberately pick on any one team, it's that they're part-time amateurs who work a day job during the week and umpire on weekends. This, in fact, is the reason milne was punished with a free kick that wasn't there against collingwood last year costing us a draw - because the umpires were amateurs and they got caught up in the vitriol spewing forth over the fence from the rancid filth.

The AFL likes to consider itself a world-class sport, but it will never be an elite game until it sorts out the mess it has made of the adjudication of said game. What it's done is, it's gone in there and tinkered too much, made too many rules, and over-saturated the umpires minds, when it should be giving them less to think about.

For example. the holding the ball rule. I think we'd all agree that the interpretation of this rule was far, far more advanced in the 90's than it is today. The holding the ball rule should be thus:

If the player has NO PRIOR, is tackled and the ball spills free, its PLAY ON.
If the player has NO PRIOR, is tackled and the ball is locked in, its a BALL UP - but no, the AFL have to tinker with the rules because they don't want so many stoppages, so now we see players get pinged for holding the ball on a regular basis in this situation.
If the player HAS PRIOR, is tackled and the ball spills free / is incorrectly disposed of, it's a FREE KICK for DROPPING THE BALL (By the way, HOLDING THE BALL and DROPPING THE BALL should have different umpire signals and be considered as separate rules rather than being blanketed together) - but no, again, the AFL don't like stoppages, so we see this kind of situation called PLAY ON all the time.

The AFL have absolutely no right to bastardize the game by trying to force it in certain directions. The game will evolve without the AFL's intervention, it always has, new tactics and game styles have always come about from within the game itself, and its turned into I believe the greatest ball game in the world, but the blight on the game that is the standard of umpiring is threatening to permanently stain it, forever.

FFS just pay them full time and get a group of about 20 master umpires to go on the rotation, who work full-time at the art of umpiring....


"Too big, too strong, too whatever."
Freebird
Club Player
Posts: 919
Joined: Sun 29 Jan 2012 12:37pm
Has thanked: 3 times
Been thanked: 94 times

Re: can someone tell me why...

Post: # 1343262Post Freebird »

Umpires historically all over the world do not cheat....home town decisions favourite players / teams etc etc is all a figment of your imagination.

Basketball/cricket/soccer etc - makes no difference if you have hometown/neutral/international umpires..honestly they're wasting their money bringing them in from afar to do what the locals can do. Who would ever think that a WA umpire would give a clutch 50/50 to westcoast if the rules interpret it correct giving it or not.


satchmo
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 6656
Joined: Tue 09 Mar 2004 12:24pm
Location: Hotel Bastardos
Has thanked: 198 times
Been thanked: 166 times
Contact:

Re: can someone tell me why...

Post: # 1343268Post satchmo »

The umpire pays a free kick and 50k boo. The umpire feels bad.
The umpire pays a free kick and 50k cheer. The umpire feels good.
Which do you think he will do more often?

We need huge crowds if we want a piece of that action.


* of course doesn't explain the dogs game.


*Allegedly.

Bring back Lucky Burgers, and nobody gets hurt.

You can't un-fry things.


Last Post
User avatar
Waltzing St Kilda
SS Hall of Fame
Posts: 2171
Joined: Sun 14 Mar 2010 5:20am
Location: Melbourne
Has thanked: 2 times
Been thanked: 361 times

Re: can someone tell me why...

Post: # 1343269Post Waltzing St Kilda »

plugger66 wrote:
Waltzing St Kilda wrote:We've been treated poorly by the umpires for about three years now. That's not perception, it's reality. It's not paranoia, it's the truth. This year we're statistically the worst off, and it's not just because we have a few young players.

The reason? I put it down to all the negative cloud of publicity that descended upon St Kida since 2009 -- Lovett, Duthy, the reopened Milne case, Lyon's defection, even Ricky Nixon. The Saints were hung out to dry by the media and the whole team has been painted as a sacrificial lamb. To deny that such thinking has an influence on the umpire's whistle is to deny human nature.

A few years ago Dermott Brereton, who has a habit of issuing half-baked statements with the air of a mighty sage, declared that "umpiring had never been responsible for the result of a game." It was arrant nonsense but other commentators then started parroting it. The truth is that umpiring has influenced MANY results, and St Kilda in the last couple of years has suffered the worst. I can't see it getting better for a while.

You cant honestly think the umpires give us less frees or the opposition more because of bad publicity 3 years ago?
I'm saying that in 50/50 decisions, of which there are dozens in a game -- was that a mark? was that holding the ball? -- there will be a small but appreciable trend towards rewarding the fashionable and punishing the unfashionable. That's what fashion is -- an often inaccurate perception of reality that lingers for a long time, and has a heavy influence on impressionable minds. St Kilda is currently unfashionable and won't recover until Milne retires, a big fish comes our way, and (though I'm no Westaway-hater) we get a more outspoken president.


gringo
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 12421
Joined: Tue 24 Mar 2009 11:05pm
Location: St Kilda
Has thanked: 296 times
Been thanked: 55 times

Re: can someone tell me why...

Post: # 1343272Post gringo »

One of my tigers mates said we copped it because the umps hated our negative footy under Lyon. A melbourne mate has a theory on assumed shitness. Mine is on bookmakers buying them off.


realdeal
Club Player
Posts: 856
Joined: Tue 30 Mar 2004 5:44pm
Has thanked: 93 times
Been thanked: 117 times

Re: can someone tell me why...

Post: # 1343298Post realdeal »

GrumpyOne wrote:Can't honestly say that I have perceived any bias from the umpires. Been some shocking decisions, and we have been lucky on other occasions, but overall, impartiality has been evident.
J. Reiwoldt getting 4-5 shots on goal from free's for the tigers in a close one, bulldogs getting 50m penalties for no reason, the 30-40 point diff on ump decisions against the bulldogs that worked against us that game. or Nick getting belted but Petrie getting soft ones.. How about the non existent ones to Nth in the 1st to help them out (on top of us playing atrocious)

We haven't always helped ourselves but geez, we've had the rough end if the stick.


User avatar
Hurricane
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 4038
Joined: Wed 10 Mar 2004 9:24pm
Location: The isle of Besaid, Spira

Re: can someone tell me why...

Post: # 1343301Post Hurricane »

I turned the Kangaroos game off in rage when Gwilt was clearly blocked by Harvey (who had no eyes for the ball) from making a contest at the ball and Petrie marked easily 20 meters out. The commentators even remarked on it and that waste of oxygen King said it was "good play". I always thought that blocking a defender was a free kick.

There were more in that game 15 free kicks to 4 at one stage and it was 8-0 until about 8 minutes into the second quarter. Norths first 3 goals happened because of free kicks or directly because of them. It makes the game impossible to watch.

BANG BANG


Mitsuharu Misawa 1962 - 2009.

I am vengeance....I am the night...I....AM.....BATMAN

I have come here to chew bubblegum and kick ass and im all out of bubblegum
ROLS-LEE
Club Player
Posts: 1210
Joined: Tue 25 Sep 2007 3:45am
Has thanked: 32 times
Been thanked: 40 times

Re: can someone tell me why...

Post: # 1343302Post ROLS-LEE »

What about the whispers in the sky saga then that got quickly swept under the carpet

If that was not a vendetta against our club then what is.

Also, every time Bakes got suspended. That was a farce as well.


plugger66
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 50626
Joined: Mon 26 Feb 2007 8:15pm
Location: oakleigh

Re: can someone tell me why...

Post: # 1343310Post plugger66 »

gringo wrote:One of my tigers mates said we copped it because the umps hated our negative footy under Lyon. A melbourne mate has a theory on assumed shitness. Mine is on bookmakers buying them off.

Yours is clearly the most ridiculous of the all the ridiculous comments put up on these sort of threads. Hands down.


CURLY
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 10457
Joined: Fri 16 Feb 2007 3:24pm
Location: WARBURTON
Has thanked: 148 times
Been thanked: 1329 times

Re: can someone tell me why...

Post: # 1343315Post CURLY »

Of course umpires favour the better players and big name clubs its in their best interest to do so. Happens in all leagues.


NO IFS OR BUTS HARVS IS KING OF THE AFL
Beno88
SS Hall of Fame
Posts: 2381
Joined: Tue 10 Jul 2007 11:14am
Location: Bentleigh East
Has thanked: 273 times
Been thanked: 628 times

Re: can someone tell me why...

Post: # 1343320Post Beno88 »

We are a distant last in free kick differential, almost double the next worst..

NM +51
WCE +39
GEEL +26
MELB +12
ESS +7
ADEL +6
GC +6
WB 0
COLL -1
PORT -4
BRIS -5
FREM -7
HAW -10
SYD -10
RICH -12
CAR -19
GWS -20
STK -37

-37 is the worst free kick differential after only 10 Rounds since champion data began.


User avatar
stinger
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 38126
Joined: Tue 09 Mar 2004 9:06pm
Location: Australia.

Re: can someone tell me why...

Post: # 1343321Post stinger »

kosifantutti wrote:The umpires didn't pay the mark to Picken.

he stood there for a couple of seconds then kicked the ball......i'd say that he thought he marked it...and the maggots didn't object.....it was either a mark or a free to roo....


.everybody still loves lenny....and we always will

"Freedom of expression is the cornerstone of a free society,"

However, freedom of expression is not encouraged in certain forums.
User avatar
stinger
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 38126
Joined: Tue 09 Mar 2004 9:06pm
Location: Australia.

Re: can someone tell me why...

Post: # 1343324Post stinger »

Hurricane wrote:I turned the Kangaroos game off in rage when Gwilt was clearly blocked by Harvey (who had no eyes for the ball) from making a contest at the ball and Petrie marked easily 20 meters out. The commentators even remarked on it and that waste of oxygen King said it was "good play". I always thought that blocking a defender was a free kick.

There were more in that game 15 free kicks to 4 at one stage and it was 8-0 until about 8 minutes into the second quarter. Norths first 3 goals happened because of free kicks or directly because of them. It makes the game impossible to watch.

BANG BANG

well...a blocking free kick was paid against us in the bulldogs game.....commentators also thought that was the right decision.....milne was basically infringed upon about four times in that game too for zilch free kicks......up until a few years ago i had regular contact with umpires in an affiliated league....found one or two to be okay...but there was something different about them......didn't like to be proven wrong or have someone doubt their word.....on the whole....little s***s i thought...paying the world back for not being picked in lunch time scratch matches maybe......anyway you will never convince me that we aren't being rodgered at the moment.......


.everybody still loves lenny....and we always will

"Freedom of expression is the cornerstone of a free society,"

However, freedom of expression is not encouraged in certain forums.
User avatar
stinger
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 38126
Joined: Tue 09 Mar 2004 9:06pm
Location: Australia.

Re: can someone tell me why...

Post: # 1343326Post stinger »

realdeal wrote: J. Reiwoldt getting 4-5 shots on goal from free's for the tigers in a close one, bulldogs getting 50m penalties for no reason, the 30-40 point diff on ump decisions against the bulldogs that worked against us that game. or Nick getting belted but Petrie getting soft ones.. How about the non existent ones to Nth in the 1st to help them out (on top of us playing atrocious)

We haven't always helped ourselves but geez, we've had the rough end if the stick.

that's for sure.....


.everybody still loves lenny....and we always will

"Freedom of expression is the cornerstone of a free society,"

However, freedom of expression is not encouraged in certain forums.
Post Reply