Guess this weeks ins and outs

[plugger66]

Nothing to say this week

[saintspremiers]

Nothing to say this week

Surely Wilkes deserves a go.

What about Gram, why does he always get a game?

And Kosi, he should be fired immediately.

And it's BJ's 200th, but he may want to go, so should be dropped also.

And don't get me started on Ledger.

[bakes]

No change.

[SMS]

Out: kosi
In: wilkes


Deadset kosi not doing enoigh

[#gosaintas]

Out: Kosi, Gram
In: Archer, Ray

[Life Long Saint]

Out: kosi
In: wilkes

Deadset kosi not doing enoigh

Agree with the last statement but there is nobody else in that team who can give McEvoy a break in the ruck.

And Wilkes is just as much a liability when the ball hits the ground inside 50 than Kosi is...The chasing is just as ineffective too.

Kosi is a better mark than Wilkes, too.

Kosi will play at least until Stanley is available.

If anyone will be dropped this week, it is most likely to be Siposs as he wasn't effective before he was subbed off. I hope that is not the case, but it wouldn't surprise me.

I'd like to see Dunell get a full game this week (or at least start the game).

[Beno88]

Out : Gwilt
In : Markworth

Gwilt badly needs a rest, he has struggled since coming back from injury. This week is a good chance given Sandy have the bye and the Dogs lack key forwards.

[dragit]

Out:
Armo and Jack need a rest, Mac is the worst tap ruckman in the league, Gilbert, Geary, Jones, Gwilt can't kick, Kosi can't get one, Roo's knee is completely stuffed, Saad didn't kick 4 again last week, Schneider doesn't put in, Gram is soft as butter, Milne is hot & cold, Joey is more interested in his TV career, NDS can't shake a tag, Fisher has lost his pizazz, Dunell looks like a teenager, BJ looks sad, Simpkin is too short and Siposs doesn't get enough of it.

That only leaves Lenny who is seemingly beyond criticism… though he was ordinary last week by his standards

In: The guys that were playing in Bendigo last week.

[bergholt]

Out:
Armo and Jack need a rest, Mac is the worst tap ruckman in the league, Gilbert, Geary, Jones, Gwilt can't kick, Kosi can't get one, Roo's knee is completely stuffed, Saad didn't kick 4 again last week, Schneider doesn't put in, Gram is soft as butter, Milne is hot & cold, Joey is more interested in his TV career, NDS can't shake a tag, Fisher has lost his pizazz, Dunell looks like a teenager, BJ looks sad, Simpkin is too short and Siposs doesn't get enough of it.

That only leaves Lenny who is seemingly beyond criticism… though he was ordinary last week by his standards

In: The guys that were playing in Bendigo last week.

summed up beautifully.

[Cairnsman]

No change.

Let them roll again and see if they can get some consistency.

Although the younger bodies will be starting to tire so we might start to see a few older players coming back like Ray and Polo over the next few weeks.

[older saint]

Thought Ray was extremely stiff to be dropped last week so should be next cab off the rank with a change.

Expect no changes

[Kernal75]

Out : Saad
In : Markworth (Sub)

Time to give the kid a game, start him as a sub and see how Dunnell goes for a half or 3/4.

[St DAC]

In Ray
Out Dunell

Ray has to come in ... too good for VFL, and has been pretty good in his recent AFL games. Wouldn't mind seeing Dunell play a full game, but not sure who else shpould come out. Jack & BJ need a follow up game to show some form.

[Eastern]

From what I've read; Peake NOT considered this week !!

[Teflon]

In Ray
Out Gram

No chance though cause apparently Gram does " special" jobs where his main purpose is to go unnoticed... Odd.

[SainterK]

Extended squad

In Ray Markworth Wilkes

Final: No change.

[Dave McNamara]

In Ray
Out Gram

No chance though cause apparently Gram does " special" jobs where his main purpose is to go unnoticed... Odd.

This.

I also wouldn't mind Wilkes in for Kosi. I reckon if Wilkes was given half the run of extended chances that Kosi has, then he'd prove to be more than handy. He just needs a few games to settle in. As for second rucking, he couldn't do worse than Kosi - remember that LRT ruck free and subsequent goal anyone...?

I realise Ledger can't play this week. We will win, so there's no way Milney wants the competition for his role in the singing of the song.

200th game or not, BJ must be put on notice to improve not only his output, but his on field demeanour... please BJ.

Oh yeah... expect.. no change...

[spert]

In: Wilkes, Ray
Out: Siposs, Schneider

[borderbarry]

Out.. Saad. Gwilt.

In... Markworth. Raph.

[WellardSaint]

Out: Gram
In: Ray

[Eastern]

My guess is that Raph Clarke will be named on the extended bench tonight. Whether he is in the final 22 would be doubtful. For mine; NO CHANGE !!

[70s sainter]

In. Ray
Out. Dunnell
Sub. Gram

[bergsone]

In Ray

Out Gram

But i dont think it will happen

[The Redeemer]

Nothing to say this week

Siposs out someone young in.

[desertsaint]

Nothing to say this week

me too - I've given up - Scotty obviously not listening to me.