IN'S & OUT'S for round 14

[mohannair]

Lets move on & think about the changes for next week.

Melbourne is coming of a bad loss so we should be focused & not be over confident from our fantastic win last week.

I think Gram will come in for Bakes.

[realdeal]

I'm thinking Gram might be rested 1 more week..

In- Eddy

Out- Baker

[SainterK]

In Roo Gram

Out Stanley Baker

[saintly]

I'm thinking Gram might be rested 1 more week..

In- Eddy

Out- Baker

Eddy is injured, you will need to pick someone else

Gram, needs time still and maybe even a game in the VFL

[dcstkfc]

In Zac
Out Bakes

If Roo is ready he comes in for Stanley

[saintnick12]

In Zac
Out Bakes

If Roo is ready he comes in for Stanley

Agree. But I hope they hold Roo back a bit longer.

[Bernard Shakey]

I was at Sandy last week and Zac is not coming in for Bakes.

[saint66au]

Saintly do you know for sure Eddy is injured..or are you just basing that on his late withdrawal from tyhe side on Friday night?

[Bernard Shakey]

In Raph
Out Bakes

[realdeal]

I'm thinking Gram might be rested 1 more week..

In- Eddy

Out- Baker

Eddy is injured, you will need to pick someone else

Gram, needs time still and maybe even a game in the VFL

I thought he was withdrawn with illness or the flu? In which case he should be fine..

Otherwise, maybe a Miles or Smith?

[AlpineStars]

Bakes out, Walsh in (give him a run) he's been playing backline and J.Smith on the long term injury list.

Maybe Mac for Kingy as well.

[AlpineStars]

Bakes out, Walsh in (give him a run) he's been playing backline and J.Smith on the long term injury list.

Maybe Mac for Kingy as well.

I meant A.Smith

Yeah I wasn't having a go at that, but I think we can promote a rookie if J.Smith is on Long Term injury list and I think Walsh is a rookie?

[realdeal]

Bakes out, Walsh in (give him a run) he's been playing backline and J.Smith on the long term injury list.

Maybe Mac for Kingy as well.

I meant A.Smith

Yeah I wasn't having a go at that, but I think we can promote a rookie if J.Smith is on Long Term injury list and I think Walsh is a rookie?

Yeah i realised, i obviously didnt delete the post in time..

[Bernard Shakey]

Bakes out, Walsh in (give him a run) he's been playing backline and J.Smith on the long term injury list.

Maybe Mac for Kingy as well.

I meant A.Smith

Yeah I wasn't having a go at that, but I think we can promote a rookie if J.Smith is on Long Term injury list and I think Walsh is a rookie?

Walsh is a rookie, but don't expect him to be elevated this year. He will be good, but we are after a premiership this year.

[bobmurray]

In Roo Gram

Out Stanley Baker

I thought it said ...

In... Lou Gramm
Out.. Ginger Baker

[Bernard Shakey]

In Roo Gram

Out Stanley Baker

I thought it said ...

In... Lou Gramm
Out.. Ginger Baker

A singer for a drummer. I don't think so.

[saintly]

Saintly do you know for sure Eddy is injured..or are you just basing that on his late withdrawal from tyhe side on Friday night?

it was mentioned in the st kilda bigfooty site regarding sandringham . there is a guy there that goes to amost if not all games. i'll try and find the link

here tis
http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showthrea ... 07&page=31

Originally Posted by Squizzy1970
B10 might like to confirm Heyney has an injury (I'd wondered why his stats were a bit lower than I'd expected). Didn't see him go off the ground.

A shame, as he looked a handy replacement if Bakes gets screwed over by the MRP again (although depends on what Eddy's injury is - he'd be an obvious choice if fit).

Maybe if Roo comes back, this will be the only change (Roo for Bakes with Gilbo taking a small forward along with Gears)?

The clash with the St. Kilda game is a bit of a s***, as I quite like watching the VFL games - much more like going to watch a Saints game at Moorabbin.

I think Heyney was getting xrays today but saw him after the game and his hand was very swollen and black. Not much better news on Eddy either who may miss a few weeks with a knee I think. But the Saints have a bit of an easier run and Rooey back, all looking good

[jays]

In Roo Gram

Out Stanley Baker

this^^^^ and how about those ins im getting excited

[stkildathunda]

Saintly do you know for sure Eddy is injured..or are you just basing that on his late withdrawal from tyhe side on Friday night?

He's listed on our injury list

Robert Eddy (knee) TBC

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/r ... 5885860128


IN: Gram & Riewoldt
OUT: Bakes & Stanley

[older saint]

In: Miles
Out : Baker

IF Roo fit then add him in and Stanley out.

R Clarke is the other one but if hammy shoudl still be at least a week away perhaps 2 with his history

[Ghost Like]

[quote="older saint"]In: Miles
Out : Baker

I like this and think it's a good fit for the side.

[degruch]

In: Miles
Out : Baker

I like this and think it's a good fit for the side.

Could be worth a try at this stage, it was a shame Miles was injured at the start of the year, as I thought he would have had a chance much sooner.

Would prefer to see Raph back, but me thinks caution would be better.

As for Gram getting a run in the VFL first, well, we're playing Melbourne...

[OneEyedSainter77]

So no chance of Roo being back then?

Would've thought if he was a chance, there'ed be a bit more noise about it - hard to keep this sort of tihng quiet.

Not that I want him back necessarily - no need to rush him back in. Wait until he is 100% ready which I have no doubt the club will do.

[jonesy]

So no chance of Roo being back then?

Would've thought if he was a chance, there'ed be a bit more noise about it - hard to keep this sort of tihng quiet.

Not that I want him back necessarily - no need to rush him back in. Wait until he is 100% ready which I have no doubt the club will do.

Would of thought he's near an absolute certainty

[bergholt]

In Zac
Out Bakes

melbourne aren't exactly the tallest forward line so i'd be surprised if zac came back this week, especially given how good last week's back line was. dempster looked good replacing bakes back there during the game, so i'd suggest the real in is for dempster, hopefully gram.