Votes v Cats

[George27]

5. Seb Ross . Fatherhood seems to suit him. Part of an excellent midfield tonight.

4. Jack Steele . Another captain’s game.

3. Brad Crouch . At bottom of every pack.

1. Paddy Ryder . Huge workload for the big bloke.

1. Brad Hill. Best user of the ball.

1. Jack Sinclair. As with Hill, makes good decisions.

Also well done Bytel and Clark, amongst others .

[bergsone]

Hill
Sinclair
Crouch
Steele
Ryder

[Ghost Like]

5 Sinclair
4 Hill
3 Ryder
2 Crouch
1 King (he would get 10 if he could kick straight)

[CURLY]

Crouch
Frawley
Howard
Ryder
Billing’s

[B.M]

5-Sinclair
4-Ross
3-Crouch (would’ve been 5 if not for concussion test)
2-Steele
1-Billings

[skeptic]

Boy Sinclair!!!! Really. Was watching him closely because I had him as part of a multi to get 15 touches for the match

Had 6 touches to half time... a big third quarter and didn’t touch the ball for close to 15min on the last quarter before getting 4 cheap touches once the game was over

I’m glad he got the touches but he was almost a complete non-factor in the game I thought. The love for the performance has shocked me

[skeptic]

4. Crouch
4. Steele
3. Ryder
2. Billings
1. Howard
1. Ross

[sks023]

5 Crouch
4 Steele
3 Hill
2 Ross
1 Billings

[saintbob]

5 Sinclair
4 Crouch
3 Steele
2 Billings
1 Hill

[Ghost Like]

Boy Sinclair!!!! Really. Was watching him closely because I had him as part of a multi to get 15 touches for the match

Had 6 touches to half time... a big third quarter and didn’t touch the ball for close to 15min on the last quarter before getting 4 cheap touches once the game was over

I’m glad he got the touches but he was almost a complete non-factor in the game I thought. The love for the performance has shocked me

It's not all about the number of touches but how he used them, how he positioned his body and attacked the contest.

[desertsaint]

thought our backs were excellent tonight.
our mids were second to the ball but our pressure, led by steele and crouch was first rate.

steele
crouch
ryder
howard
wilkie

hill very good as well. heck a lot were good tonight. kicking into fifty was excellent, leading was excellent. then of course there was that final bit we kept stuffing up.

[bangaulegend]

Way too soon still punching the wall . When my hand gets better I will give it my best shot sorry sainterdad just had to vent my spleen

[B.M]

Don’t count possessions

Make possessions count

Thought Sinclair was very good, clean, creative and good defensively

[avid]

3 Ross
3 Crouch
2 Steele
2 Billings
2 Ryder
2 Hill
1 Sinclair

[minneapolis]

3 Steele
2 Crouch
2 Bytel
2 Howard
2 Sinclair
2 Ryder
2 Wilkie

[saynta]

5. Crouch
4. Steele
3. Ross
2. Sinclair
1. Howard.

[freely]

Sinclair
Hill
Howard
Bytel
Ryder

[skeptic]

To suggest that Sinclair was better than Steele, Crouch and Ross is fantasy IMO

Make your possessions count... we’re his 6 touches to half time all goal assists!? I am really miffed by this. Not suggesting he was terrible but at best he was in the game for a 1/4

[B.M]

Of course Mids are going to win more footy

It’s their job

How many possessions did Cam Guthrie get? Mitch Duncan?

Maybe look that up?!

[spert]

Crouch
Howard
Wilke
Sinclair
Steele

[Joffa Burns]

3. Crouch
2. Ross
1. Hill
1. Ryder
1. Sinclair
1. Howard
1. Steele

[aaron82]

Loved Sinclair’s game, rarely wastes a disposal & often parked himself in front of hawkins in the first half. For a small bloke I was pleasantly surprised with that part of his game.

[skeptic]

Of course Mids are going to win more footy

It’s their job

How many possessions did Cam Guthrie get? Mitch Duncan?

Maybe look that up?!

He ran around the middle all night off the contest.

Got 4 touches in the first
2 in the second

Turned up to play in the third quarter with 7...

Was completely absent in the first 10-15 minutes of the last quarter when Geelong stepped up and we didn’t... with doughnuts. Did not touch the ball... then got four touches in junk time time

Stewart for them who also had 6 to half time finished the match with 23 really turning it on after 1/2 time

Valuing performances like Sinclair’s last night is a call back to the Tim Watson days when Trianedes, Plapp, Brown, Mitchell etc would do one or two nice things a match that stood out and were heaped in praise.

Can’t carry a player of SInclair’s talent and experience if he fades in and out of games like this

[Ghost Like]

I thought Sinclair ran off the half back line, picking up their smaller forwards. I don't think any of their small forwards got off the chain, so defensively he did a job. Offensively, he ran, created options and used his possessions. I thought his game was excellent.

[saynta]

I see the Ross haters are alive and well.