Ins & Outs for round 2

This unofficial St Kilda Saints fan forum is for people of all ages to chat Saints Footy and all posts must be respectful.

Moderators: Saintsational Administrators, Saintsational Moderators

loris
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 4669
Joined: Tue 22 Jan 2008 5:41pm
Has thanked: 425 times
Been thanked: 517 times

Re: Ins & Outs for round 2

Post: # 1655225Post loris »

[quote="WellardSaint"]
Lonie played like a freak in his first year, /quote]

I think a lot of supporters forget the Schneider impact WS. Schnieds was taking a lot of the heat off Lonie. so he got under the guard of most opposing teams. IMHO Schneiderman was the reason behind Lonies breakout year.
Lonnie said in an interview that Schneider used to coach him out on the ground during the game as were to position himself. And washis mentor that year.


SemperFidelis
SS Life Member
Posts: 3856
Joined: Fri 16 Sep 2011 2:41pm
Has thanked: 419 times
Been thanked: 237 times

Re: Ins & Outs for round 2

Post: # 1655231Post SemperFidelis »

Carlisle needs a few weeks to remember how to run, but I'll give him a break here because it was so freaking hot inside tonight everyone around us was almost in a dead bloody faint. I can't remember conditions so oppressive.

But drop Brown? Are you serious? I thought he was one of the few shining lights. No one expected him to be fast but I thought he was good in many contests and without him I reckon we'd have lost by another bagful.

Could have used Shinner tonight, though.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk


Always loyal
SemperFidelis
SS Life Member
Posts: 3856
Joined: Fri 16 Sep 2011 2:41pm
Has thanked: 419 times
Been thanked: 237 times

Re: Ins & Outs for round 2

Post: # 1655233Post SemperFidelis »

Ross will give himself a belting for that performance. Not the first to be dropped.


Always loyal
Toy Saint
SS Hall of Fame
Posts: 2203
Joined: Wed 19 Aug 2009 10:32pm
Location: Del Mar, California
Has thanked: 34 times
Been thanked: 237 times

Re: Ins & Outs for round 2

Post: # 1655237Post Toy Saint »

We were obliterated in the ruck, Hickey looked like an incompetent sloth against Gawn. Our midflelders were always on the back foot.

I'm not a Lonie fan, but he wasn't our worst. Carslile was adequate. And I'm not a big Savage fan, but he was OK too.

Not much from Bruce and Weller. Wright showed pace early.


User avatar
Linton Lodger
SS Hall of Fame
Posts: 2467
Joined: Mon 18 Aug 2014 2:07pm
Has thanked: 86 times
Been thanked: 256 times

Re: Ins & Outs for round 2

Post: # 1655250Post Linton Lodger »

Linton Lodger wrote:We don't know about Roo, Joey or Paddy yet, so on the assumption that Roo's right next week and that Montagna & Paddy won't be ready:

Out: Wright, Lonie, Ross

In: Acres, Sinclair, K Stevens
Incredibly, Mc Cartin is playing for Sandy tomorrow, so hopefully he'll be right, that means I'll change mine:

Out: Wright, Lonie, Ross

In: Acres, Sinclair, McCartin


User avatar
saintsRrising
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 30096
Joined: Mon 15 Mar 2004 11:07am
Location: Melbourne
Has thanked: 711 times
Been thanked: 1234 times

Re: Ins & Outs for round 2

Post: # 1655254Post saintsRrising »

dragit wrote:Here's a melt…

Lucky we have incredible depth because right now I have a few outs
We have depth, but also not enough elite cream. And tonight not even the depth players decided to put in. Based on effort today 75% deserved to be dropped.


Flying the World in comfort thanks to FF Points....
SemperFidelis
SS Life Member
Posts: 3856
Joined: Fri 16 Sep 2011 2:41pm
Has thanked: 419 times
Been thanked: 237 times

Re: Ins & Outs for round 2

Post: # 1655255Post SemperFidelis »

Toy Saint wrote:We were obliterated in the ruck, Hickey looked like an incompetent sloth against Gawn. Our midflelders were always on the back foot.

I'm not a Lonie fan, but he wasn't our worst. Carslile was adequate. And I'm not a big Savage fan, but he was OK too.

Not much from Bruce and Weller. Wright showed pace early.
Good assessment.


Always loyal
CURLY
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 10457
Joined: Fri 16 Feb 2007 3:24pm
Location: WARBURTON
Has thanked: 148 times
Been thanked: 1329 times

Re: Ins & Outs for round 2

Post: # 1655256Post CURLY »

Paddy replaces Roo Dempster for Brown McKenzie for Wright Sinclair for Lonnie and Acres for Dunston. Hickey gets one more chance or maybe not he cost us big time today.

Also FFS Billings was one of our best until he was played deep forward.


NO IFS OR BUTS HARVS IS KING OF THE AFL
realdeal
Club Player
Posts: 856
Joined: Tue 30 Mar 2004 5:44pm
Has thanked: 93 times
Been thanked: 117 times

Re: Ins & Outs for round 2

Post: # 1655282Post realdeal »

This loss starts and finishes with the midfield!
Some forwards missed gettable set shots and some defenders coughed it up under no pressure but the midfield has to take responsibility here. And the game plan.

What the he'll happened after qtr time!? They weren't that great, we were just that bad! In stkilda like from the past few years!


CQ SAINT
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 6080
Joined: Sat 12 Sep 2015 1:03pm
Has thanked: 337 times
Been thanked: 1568 times

Re: Ins & Outs for round 2

Post: # 1655304Post CQ SAINT »

Out: Geary, Gilbert, Dunstan, Lonie, Armitage, Savage and rest Rooey

In: Mackenzie, White, Acres, Sinclair, Stevens, Long and McCartin

If improvement is the measure for the season forget improving the first 5 outs. Let them earn their money teaching the kids at Sandy to win.

How the hell did we go from Riewoldt to Geary as Captain. I have never seen Jarryn at his best because I don't get to training much but I have seen him play too often. There was more inspiration today watching Melbourne drop marks and fumble the occasional handball. It is embarrassing.

Gilbert is finished and Dunstan belongs at Sandy. Lonie rarely picks up the ball cleanly and kicks terribly when he does. His first season was a fluke, same with Luke.

We need more pace and skill/ability not fumbling, kick and hope types. We have nothing to lose. Savage is a good kick (sometimes) but lacks the courage needed to play AFL.

I don't care about the loss today but it is time to bite the bullet and get some games into our kids now. Forget finals. Next year there will be no Dempster, Roo or Montagna.
Gilbert, Savage and Geary should join them. We need to prepare for this now.


McCartin needs to do something other than be sore or injured. I wont be surprised if Josh Battle overtakes him. I'm confident he will kick more goals at Sandy than McCartin will at St.Kilda but will gladly eat my hat if Paddy can kick 20 in his next 8 games.
Last edited by CQ SAINT on Sat 25 Mar 2017 10:17pm, edited 1 time in total.


User avatar
White Winmar
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 5014
Joined: Tue 02 Jun 2009 10:02pm

Re: Ins & Outs for round 2

Post: # 1655306Post White Winmar »

In : intensity and effort

Out : lethargy and lack of speed


I started with nothing and I've got most of it left!
User avatar
skeptic
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 17028
Joined: Wed 10 Mar 2004 7:10pm
Has thanked: 3647 times
Been thanked: 2918 times

Re: Ins & Outs for round 2

Post: # 1655335Post skeptic »

Country Kid wrote:
dragit wrote:
BigMart wrote:Carlisle

The statue

Stands at CHB and hopes the opposition kick it to him and not his opponent

If he is the great white hope, god help us

He is only of value if the opposition have a Kosi like fwd
Brown was worse than Carlisle IMO, he was meant to be the guy who could stop Hogan who was running rampant.

Carlisle's first game in 18 months.
The problem was that neither Carlisle or Brown were agile enough to go with Hogan. He covers a lot of ground. Did we miss Dempster? Possibly, but where I think we did miss him was that for the last few years he has been the organiser of the back line as well as the player prepared to leave his opponent to help a teammate. Players like Roberton look good when they are the free man but are under pressure when they have to defend/man up. This zone defence is good when your midfield is on top but when not, a defender should play man on man. The basic 'job' of a defender is to beat your opponent first and foremost and then attack. Maybe I am just old fashioned.
Really good post... backs were super disorganised


lefty
Club Player
Posts: 1307
Joined: Tue 28 Sep 2004 8:11pm
Been thanked: 40 times

Re: Ins & Outs for round 2

Post: # 1655337Post lefty »

Out - Midfield
That's where the game was lost, as per usual.

Ross terrible, did nothing and ran out of steam
Armatige terrible, did nothing and seems slow
Hickey terrible, but playing against the best ruckman in the league
Weller - terrible, needs to practice kicking straight

Would also be nice if the backline actually played man on man from a center bounce.

I thought Wright was OK, least he runs, saw him get someone from 50+m away holding the ball.

I also think Newness hurt his shoulder again? Didn't look right.

I also think we are simply not fit enough, or we'd done too much work during the week and had tired ourselves out.
Last edited by lefty on Sat 25 Mar 2017 11:43pm, edited 1 time in total.


coopergrech
Club Player
Posts: 247
Joined: Sun 01 Apr 2012 12:15pm

Re: Ins & Outs for round 2

Post: # 1655338Post coopergrech »

In: Montagna, ACRES, DEMPSTER, Minchington & McCartin
Out: Wright, Lonie,Gilbert,Dunstan & WELLER/ROSS (Make a statement)

Weller/Ross will survive if Roo doesn't play. But they need to make a statement and drop players like them that think they'll just stay in the team week in week out, because of previous form..

I'm a Hickey fan, but gee he looked really lazy today. If Koby Stevens is available maybe bring him in also for Webster..

Savage survives at this stage...


To the top
SS Life Member
Posts: 3266
Joined: Fri 16 Mar 2007 4:05pm
Been thanked: 390 times

Re: Ins & Outs for round 2

Post: # 1655343Post To the top »

There is talent on our List.

BUT, as long as we have Geary as Captain we will be the joke of the competition.

Then you can add Savage, Webster and Lonie.

There are 4 players just not at AFL level, and never will be.

Brown looked very suspect - but what is our alternative?

And don't tell me Dempster!

We are talking about someone playing full back - and Kennedy looms next week.

Simply, the likes of Acres and White need to be in the side and why they have not been managed to that status is a blight on the Football Department.

We play a zone defence of witches hats because we have the likes of Geary, Webster and Savage running round in our back 6.

Sorry, did I say running?

That should read "standing"

You can now see why the progress of Freeman is so vital to our chances.

And the question on Membrey remains - who did he kick his bags of 5 on and what did he do otherwise?

Weller was also very poor - as was Wright.

I would have taken Geary off and thrown Wright into defence - to man up and negate.

In fact, Carlisle tried, Gresham tried and looked classy at times and Roo tried.

But that was the end of the penny section.


saintbob
SS Life Member
Posts: 3636
Joined: Wed 21 May 2008 8:51pm
Location: Tassie
Has thanked: 492 times
Been thanked: 316 times

Re: Ins & Outs for round 2

Post: # 1655353Post saintbob »

Lonie is NO where near AFL standard and I'm not sure what Richo sees in him.

Brown played like an absolute spud.

Mav kicked very poorly, 4 very gettable shots on goal and didn't look like slotting one.

Richo and co were the most disappointing on the night

Ins: Acres, Dempster, McCartin and Sinclair

Outs: Brown, Wright, Riewoldt and Lonie


Jacks Back
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 6607
Joined: Sat 11 Jun 2011 4:52pm
Location: Here
Has thanked: 1324 times
Been thanked: 467 times

Re: Ins & Outs for round 2

Post: # 1655453Post Jacks Back »

We can't be serious if players like Webster (who can't keep his feet), Wright (who runs around like a headless chook, had only 8 possessions and 1 tackle) and Lonie (too small and no good at AFL level) are in our "best 22".

Also Brown is not best 22 but we currently don't have a tall full back apart from him.

And before some one jumps up and down about Lonie - I'm not saying small players are no good (look at Caleb Daniel) I'm saying Lonie is currently not up to AFL level.

Out: Lonie, Wright, Webster, Ross, Rooey (if injured)
IN: 8cres, McKenzie, Sinclair, Minchington, McCartin (if Rooey is injured)


As ex-president Peter Summers said:
“If we are going to be a contender, we may as well plan to win the bloody thing.”


St Kilda - At least we have a Crest!
User avatar
White Winmar
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 5014
Joined: Tue 02 Jun 2009 10:02pm

Re: Ins & Outs for round 2

Post: # 1655460Post White Winmar »

Jacks Back wrote:We can't be serious if players like Webster (who can't keep his feet), Wright (who runs around like a headless chook, had only 8 possessions and 1 tackle) and Lonie (too small and no good at AFL level) are in our "best 22".

Also Brown is not best 22 but we currently don't have a tall full back apart from him.

And before some one jumps up and down about Lonie - I'm not saying small players are no good (look at Caleb Daniel) I'm saying Lonie is currently not up to AFL level.

Out: Lonie, Wright, Webster, Ross, Rooey (if injured)
IN: 8cres, McKenzie, Sinclair, Minchington, McCartin (if Rooey is injured)
We need to persist with Ross. He is the future. No Minch for me. Otherwise, hard to disagree, JB.


I started with nothing and I've got most of it left!
User avatar
dragit
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 13047
Joined: Tue 29 Jun 2010 11:56am
Has thanked: 605 times
Been thanked: 315 times

Re: Ins & Outs for round 2

Post: # 1655502Post dragit »

Alright I've calmed down now…

Actually feel for Lonie, he didn't pick the team, nor was he responsible for our midfield woes… I think he tried really hard, think he'd probably trying too hard at present. He had a team high 6 tackles, 3 clearances but coughed it up a few times… not our worst though IMO.

I honestly don't know why we were so out-worked, they had 120 more disposals yet still had 8 more tackles.

Our ball use was very ordinary,

For us to win
Savage has to have more than 8 kicks
Bruce has to take more than 2 marks
Wright is in the side to tackle and had 1 - he has to go this week.
Who was worse out of Dunstan, Ross & Armitage… tough call - Probably Ross with 4 clangers and only 1 tackle.

Next week is going to be tough with any combination but I'm thinking something like

Out
Lonie, Ross, Wright, Riewoldt

In
Stevens, Acres, Montagna, McCartin

Left field: we could throw Long in the deep end to apply some forward pressure, he seemed to love a tackle.

No chance Richo will drop Ross though.


User avatar
shrodes
SS Life Member
Posts: 3091
Joined: Tue 12 Aug 2014 2:34pm
Location: Melbourne
Has thanked: 791 times
Been thanked: 436 times

Re: Ins & Outs for round 2

Post: # 1655505Post shrodes »

dragit wrote:Left field: we could throw Long in the deep end to apply some forward pressure, he seemed to love a tackle.
Still suspended for round 2 and eligible to be picked from round 3


Vazelos
Club Player
Posts: 1265
Joined: Sun 12 Sep 2010 1:17am
Has thanked: 12 times
Been thanked: 319 times

Re: Ins & Outs for round 2

Post: # 1655523Post Vazelos »

I thought Lonie did Ok but long term there are better candidates to come in.

Long to come in Round 3 I just think we need to have a real good look at this kid.

In for Round 2: Montagna, Acres, Mc Cartin, K Stevens
Out: Wright, Lonie, Dunstan Riewoldt

It will be fast game out there, need better midfielders.


terry smith rules
SS Life Member
Posts: 2537
Joined: Mon 27 Jun 2005 1:27pm
Location: Abiding
Has thanked: 171 times
Been thanked: 384 times

Re: Ins & Outs for round 2

Post: # 1655544Post terry smith rules »

CQ SAINT wrote:Out: Geary, Gilbert, Dunstan, Lonie, Armitage, Savage and rest Rooey

In: Mackenzie, White, Acres, Sinclair, Stevens, Long and McCartin

If improvement is the measure for the season forget improving the first 5 outs. Let them earn their money teaching the kids at Sandy to win.

How the hell did we go from Riewoldt to Geary as Captain. I have never seen Jarryn at his best because I don't get to training much but I have seen him play too often. There was more inspiration today watching Melbourne drop marks and fumble the occasional handball. It is embarrassing.



.
He dropped one mark and one hanball was not timed, but sure if you can point out the others then go ahead.

One game in and we get "supporters" like you and To the Top quickly back on your hobby horse

I tell you this if we make the 8 this year and #14 leads us out, I will be reminding you of this post

fqf


" A few will never give up on you. When you go back out on the field, those are the people I want in your minds. Those are the people I want in your hearts."

— Coach Eric Taylor - Friday Night Lights
CQ SAINT
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 6080
Joined: Sat 12 Sep 2015 1:03pm
Has thanked: 337 times
Been thanked: 1568 times

Re: Ins & Outs for round 2

Post: # 1655626Post CQ SAINT »

terry smith rules wrote:
CQ SAINT wrote:Out: Geary, Gilbert, Dunstan, Lonie, Armitage, Savage and rest Rooey

In: Mackenzie, White, Acres, Sinclair, Stevens, Long and McCartin

If improvement is the measure for the season forget improving the first 5 outs. Let them earn their money teaching the kids at Sandy to win.

How the hell did we go from Riewoldt to Geary as Captain. I have never seen Jarryn at his best because I don't get to training much but I have seen him play too often. There was more inspiration today watching Melbourne drop marks and fumble the occasional handball. It is embarrassing.



.
He dropped one mark and one hanball was not timed, but sure if you can point out the others then go ahead.

One game in and we get "supporters" like you and To the Top quickly back on your hobby horse

I tell you this if we make the 8 this year and #14 leads us out, I will be reminding you of this post

fqf
Really. Ok. Chaleenge accepted. I want to apologise to Jarryn and the coaching staff in advance but clearly this needs to be pointed out for 'barrackers' like you.

His stats are unremarkable when you track them. He has made a career out of running hard, back and forward and being very average when he gets it,with his very average 15 or 16 possessions and 2 tackles a game, in sides where the ball has spent a lot of time in defence and while he 'regularly beats the best small forwards in the comps'. What a load of shite.

00:30 retrieved ball after point, passed it to Savage and asked for a short one as he returned. jogged 15 metres to the pocket sideways alone, knowing he was going to get it, dropped the mark, hand balled to pressure a position for a scrappy defensive 50 rebound. Easy stat, very little thought in it. Billings ended up with a stunning goal after a turnover from Melbourne, after a turnover from us.

1:15 Dropped easy over head mark under pressure. Out of position when ball turned over 10 seconds later in the middle - Hogan in one on one no one to cut off the space.

3.24 Back of pack easy receive standing still, stupid hand ball backwards to Armitage under pressure and in congestion, turnover 1 possession later. Geary watched Gartlett run in and kick an easy goal, in an open forward line, from 40 meter square.

6.49 Out of position behind Hogan who gets an easy mark. Not smart.

8.25 Ineffective tackle being rag dolled as he clings onto Watts.

10:00 Alone, across halve back reading play, easy mark intercept and clean 15 meter pass. 1st effective possession in six attempts. the ball goes around in a big circle backwards.

10:25 Geary receives easy mark alone, in the same place he kicked the ball to 20 seconds earlier, and chips a s*** kick 15 metres along the boundary which would have gone out on the full, if Steven didn't get to it just in time. 2nd effective disposal but just.

10:53 Geary lurking behind play alone again, gets handball receive and gets caught, kick smothered ineffective, he gets another chance after picking up his own scraps and the same s*** happens again. 2 effective disposals quickly countered by 2 fumbling errors, poor judgement, poor awareness and very average composure under pressure in 1:53 of football. So Geary gets near the ball (close enough to touch it or spoil it) 8 times in 10 minutes and has 2 effective possessions. Then Geary runs away pointing his finger and telling others where to go. FFS. A true leader.

Do you really want me to go on. Its no problem but I'm pretty sure someone at the club is paid to do this, Somehow this guy is our captain. At this point our stats are outweighing Melbourne's remarkably (at about 50% efficiency) and we are running hard and applying heaps of pressure, getting turn overs and banging it forward heaps but alas, we are behind.

13:33 Centre bounce, ball tapped forward by Melbourne, a short kick goes to Geary's running path, he is quick and in the right spot, he takes an easy mark with time and space, in his usual style he pounds it on his boot because he senses pressure. The commentary is "Geary mark, boots it clear and wide, sets Gresham a task", Gresh is 5 metres ahead of his opponent on the true hf flank. Gresh eventually chases down Geary's kick a meter in from the boundary but cant keep it in. Geary virtually kicked it from the centre circle. A straight 40 metre neat kick in front of Gresh was all that was required. Geary cant handle pressure. Then he runs around pointing his finger and yelling instructions. He is a professional trier.

Are you getting the picture yet Terry? Sure, Geary wasn't alone yesterday and he has been under the pump his whole career and there is no one else, blah blah blah. Did you get inspired, excited and go home thinking gee, what a Captain we have. He is a scapegoat for poor strategies and a role model for poor execution in my humble opinion. I'm entitled to it too. I didn't really want to run down Geary but you asked.

I respect your defence of Jarryn, it is noble, loyal and all that jazz, but in my opinion it is abhorrent that a guy who tries hard and runs hard and does very little other than stop the best small forward from getting the ball, (while our midfielders and forwards chase his errant disposals and apply heaps of pressure and tackles, restricting the delivery of the ball to those opposing best small forward), gets to be our Captain moving forward. He is leading us to a top 5 draft pick is about all.

After 140+ games of this type of mediocrity, he wont improve and if he does lead us to the finals it wont be because he got better.

End of rant.


User avatar
Con Gorozidis
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 23532
Joined: Thu 19 Jun 2008 4:04pm
Has thanked: 100 times
Been thanked: 78 times

Re: Ins & Outs for round 2

Post: # 1655643Post Con Gorozidis »

Minch is miles better than Lonie.

What is it with Lonie? The choir boy hair-cut? So what if he tries like Scrappy do. He is very slow, gets caught a heck of a lot and most of his tackles are easily broken. Every now and then he lays a tackle because he sneaks up and noon sees him coming cos he is so small.


CQ SAINT
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 6080
Joined: Sat 12 Sep 2015 1:03pm
Has thanked: 337 times
Been thanked: 1568 times

Re: Ins & Outs for round 2

Post: # 1655650Post CQ SAINT »

Con Gorozidis wrote:Minch is miles better than Lonie.

What is it with Lonie? The choir boy hair-cut? So what if he tries like Scrappy do. He is very slow, gets caught a heck of a lot and most of his tackles are easily broken. Every now and then he lays a tackle because he sneaks up and noon sees him coming cos he is so small.
Sinclair is better than them both. Long will be too. They are both more suited to the midfield as well.


Post Reply