The ULTIMATE trivia post!!!

[St Fidelius]

Kevin O'Halloran....... R9, 1939
Graham Croft........... R14, 1966
Chris Stone..............R10, 1978 (two goals from first two kicks)
Rod Owen................R1, 1983
Tony Lockett............R4, 1983
Stewart Loewe.........R9, 1986 (two goals from first two kicks)
Peter Everitt.............R1, 1993

The other two players got them when they played for another club


Jason Heatley...........R4, 1995 (WCE)
Aaron Fiora...............R7, 2000 (Richmond)

The AFL site does not mention Murray...

http://afl.com.au/default.asp?pg=aflrec ... leid=89915

[St Fidelius]

Don't forget that Alan Murray played one match for Port Adelaide, before coming to us and in that match, Murray had just the one kick for no goals...

[jed]

I've seen two different sets of stats from the game Murray played for Port. One says he got a kick, the other says he didn't.

I asked him at one of the family days and he said he never got a kick in his game for Port Adelaide, which means his first kick for the Saints and his first kick in AFL was a goal.

Capuano kicked a goal with his first kick for the Saints.

[St Fidelius]

Well I only really go by two sites for stats…


http://stats.rleague.com/afl/stats/play ... urray.html

http://www.finalsiren.com/PlayerStats.asp?PlayerID=904

both of them state that he had one kick for Port…

and the AFL site does not mention that he is a player to kick a goal with his first kick…

[SaintBot]

murray was kickless in his first AFL match for port adelaide. and we are looking for players who kicked a goal with their first kick in a stkilda jumper. so fiora and heatly dont count nor does cappulano because he played for the roos before coming to the saints.
so their is still 2 more players...

[St Fidelius]

murray was kickless in his first AFL match for port adelaide. and we are looking for players who kicked a goal with their first kick in a stkilda jumper. so fiora and heatly dont count nor does cappulano because he played for the roos before coming to the saints.
so their is still 2 more players...

Sorry, but I still don't understand...

You want players that have kicked a goal with their first kick in a Saints jumper, but then you say that Capuano doesn't count because he played for the Roos before coming to us...

Also the AFL and two stats sites say that Murray had 1 kick when he played his only game for Port...

[SaintBot]

i mean their first ever afl goal with their first ever afl kick but their first kick must have been at stkilda.
where i got my stats...it is the offical stats and it said murray was kickless in his first afl match.

[jed]

What is your source SaintBot?

If St. Fid quotes the AFL site and you say it is not complete then what is your source that contradicts it?

I'm not saying that the AFL site is always 100% accurate (I think they are wrong about Allan Murray and John Stephens) but unless you watch every game ever played it is difficult to come up with a definitive list.

[St Fidelius]

The last player the AFL have was Leigh Harding in 2001, maybe it just hasn't been updated...

[SaintBot]

i got it out of a book which is updated this year!!

[St Fidelius]

I know BJ kicked a goal in his first match, not too sure if it was his first kick

and also Leigh Fisher kicked a goal in his first match...

so I'll go for those two..

[SaintBot]

nope


player 1 Graham Croft
player 2 Peter Everitt
player 3 S**** L*****
player 4 Tony Lockett
player 5 Stewie Loewe
player 6 Allan Murray
player 7 A*** O*****
player 8 Kevin O'Halloran
player 9 Rod Owen
player 10 Chris Stone

some little clues there...

[St Fidelius]

Alby Oatway in 1913??

[SaintBot]

YES
player 1 Graham Croft
player 2 Peter Everitt
player 3 S**** L*****
player 4 Tony Lockett
player 5 Stewie Loewe
player 6 Allan Murray
player 7 Alby Oatway
player 8 Kevin O'Halloran
player 9 Rod Owen
player 10 Chris Stone

one more player to go...

[St Fidelius]

Has this player got 5 letters starting with S for his first name and...

6 Letters starting with L for a surname???

I have looked over my list and can't find anyone that matches that...

[SaintBot]

yeah sorry

player 1 Graham Croft
player 2 Peter Everitt
player 3 S***** L*****
player 4 Tony Lockett
player 5 Stewie Loewe
player 6 Allan Murray
player 7 Alby Oatway
player 8 Kevin O'Halloran
player 9 Rod Owen
player 10 Chris Stone

one more player to go...

[St Fidelius]

Stuart LENNIE in 1955??

[SaintBot]

yess at last all 10 named

[St Fidelius]

yess at last all 10 named

It just shows everyone what crap is on the AFL site....

Gee a multi million dollar business and their site is crap...

[SaintBot]

hernie the second: Kevin O'Halloran, Graham Croft, Chris Stone, Rod Owen-4
HarveysDeciples: Tony Lockett, Peter Everitt-2
St Fidelius: Alby Oatway, Stuart Lennie-2
N1CK: Stewie Loewe-1
Mad Saint Guy: Allan Murray-1
so the winner is hernie the second

[herni the second]

Cheers

No idea about any further questions, Next person to post can make one up for me.

[SaintBot]

ok another hard one since you instisted.
7 players have played 100 games or more at st kilda (either part of their career or all of their career was played at st kilda) but never kicked a single goal.
who were they??

[mad saint guy]

Jamie Shanahan is one.

[SaintBot]

yep he was one
1/7 6 to go...

[saint66au]

Saintbot, your questions tend to be a little ambigous

The players who played with others, does "never scored a goal" apply to their whole career or just their time at St Kilda?

If people answer correctly in dribs and drabs, what does someone have to do to earn the honour of asking the next question??