Harvey 65% Winmar 35%

[kosifantutti]

Who is your favourite Saint out of:

Robert Harvey or Nicky Winmar?

[fugazi]

This one hurts!
My two all time favourites, Lenny, Roo and Maxy filling out the top 5.
Like many a UN vote....I'll abstain

[skeptic]

Winmar more exciting

[St Lenny]

Harvey by a mile. Carried the team on many occasions and never gave the club or the supporters an ounce of grief.

[Teflon]

I can not believe Winmar is in the same league - all round package Harvey by a street
Ask any opposition fan who they and the game rates better and I think this one is dusted

Winmar possibly top 5 at best

[8856brother]

FAVOURITE people. Relax. Winmar easily for me.

[MCG-Unit]

Winmar - my Favourite Saint ever, even over Hayes, then Harvey & Riewoldt.

Shivers folks, it's Favourite not necessarily best.....

[BakesFan]

My two favourite Saints got through...... I can't split them... so I abstain as well.

[Playon]

One of the things I've been voting on is how much I've enjoyed watching a player.; I remember calling out Winmars name more than Harveys.
So for those that don't think he deserves to be in the elite class, perhaps you can tell me of any other midfielder that has kicked NINE goals in one match, from any club, Sure he was playing FF that day but so what.

Mark of the year 1992 here it is

I've been basing my voting on favorite not best, We each have our reasons as to why. The Gtrain was another Fav but didn't see if he was included. Hamill. Lowe, Max many more.

I voted for Winmar but certainly no disgrace to come second to R Harvey, many did

[kosifantutti]

Final scores
Harvey 30 Winmar 16

[BakesFan]

I didn't vote.......but if I was forced to....it would have been for Banger....

..has there been a greater, more loyal, more humble, servant of the club?

These days people talk about opposition players not being able to keep up with Rooey........ I don't know that anyone ever kept up with Harvs (Shane Crawford tells a good story about his 1st match-up on Harvs).....he was just a machine...

..I just wish he'd been just a little more selfish on the paddock......would have easily kicked 500+.....(but 215 goals at AFL level is nothing to sneeze at)

...2 Brownlows says it all.... absolute Superstar.

[BakesFan]

Would love to know how many goals Harvs and Nicky gave Plugger by hitting him square on the tit.

[saintbob]

#35, by the proverbial street.

[Teflon]

Favourite can also be determined to mean best (if that's the individual's criteria )