Quick Poll: Who Should We Take at 1?

bergholt · Post: # 1518899Post **bergholt** » Thu 27 Nov 2014 1:49pm

The recruiting team will be coming on here at about 6pm to find out who they should pick. Let's decide.

bergholt · Post: # 1518917Post **bergholt** » Thu 27 Nov 2014 2:34pm

11 - 8 in Paddy's favour at this point! That's a bit surprising.

SainterK · Post: # 1518930Post **SainterK** » Thu 27 Nov 2014 3:18pm

P-trac for me, only cause of the stats that show mids a much safer bet.

Won't lose sleep though.

Sainternist · Thu 27 Nov 2014 3:29pm

bergholt wrote:The recruiting team will be coming on here at about 6pm to find out who they should pick. Let's decide.

Rumours of the leak are all proven false. All confirmed that Saintsational will be deciding for them.

Choose wisely, fellow forumites!

bigballs · Post: # 1518949Post **bigballs** » Thu 27 Nov 2014 4:14pm

The Tractor for me - because you can never have enough mids!!

bergholt · Post: # 1518954Post **bergholt** » Thu 27 Nov 2014 4:33pm

17 all! It's line ball with only an hour or so to go. Vote now!

gringo · Post: # 1518956Post **gringo** » Thu 27 Nov 2014 4:35pm

I'm swayed. Go the tall....Paddy melon.

plugger66 · Post: # 1518975Post **plugger66** » Thu 27 Nov 2014 5:09pm

Petracca because I rate mids ahead of talls.

MCG-Unit · Post: # 1518978Post **MCG-Unit** » Thu 27 Nov 2014 5:13pm

Voted Petracca, would rather a mid than a KP forward.

desertsaint · Thu 27 Nov 2014 5:24pm

hurry up and votes - the recruitment team needs a bigger sample before tonights decision!

bergholt · Post: # 1518981Post **bergholt** » Thu 27 Nov 2014 5:27pm

desertsaint wrote:hurry up and votes - the recruitment team needs a bigger sample before tonights decision!

23-22 Petracca! I hope we don't end up with a draw, I suppose that would mean we just pass on pick 1.

BakesFan · Post: # 1518989Post **BakesFan** » Thu 27 Nov 2014 5:44pm

Inside mids with goal-kicking ability...Games are won in the engine room... Petracca for me.

Old Mate · Post: # 1519000Post **Old Mate** » Thu 27 Nov 2014 6:27pm

I've swung in McCartin's favour. I just think we get mids at 21/22 and cash in on the big forward with 1. No doubt the quality of Petracca vs mids at 21/22 is a significant gap but not to the extent of Paddy vs next best big forward at 21 onwards which is far more significant IMO.

remboy · Post: # 1519002Post **remboy** » Thu 27 Nov 2014 6:29pm

Sainternist wrote:
bergholt wrote:The recruiting team will be coming on here at about 6pm to find out who they should pick. Let's decide.
Rumours of the leak are all proven false. All confirmed that Saintsational will be deciding for them.

Choose wisely, fellow forumites!

That's my mail apparently the Saints brains trust will take a look at this poll just before they have to decide. If they ask for more time it will be because we have a tied vote!

plugger66 · Post: # 1519004Post **plugger66** » Thu 27 Nov 2014 6:30pm

Imagine this poll one week ago. We do really trust our club and fair enough because they have seen them all play many many games. I reckon if it hadn't been mentioned we may take Petracca it would be 2 for McCartin and 49 for Petracca.

Wrote for Luck · Thu 27 Nov 2014 6:37pm

I think there are mids there too such as Ellis, Weller, Ahern and then later Neal-Bullen, and Caleb Daniel to satisfy.
Additionally pinch a second tall with Lamb, McKenzie or if the gods permit Durdin.
I've swung a lot toward McCartin and will be happy enough when we pick him, but I would still go Petracca all considered.

remboy · Post: # 1519008Post **remboy** » Thu 27 Nov 2014 6:44pm

I'm just going to wait until the decision is made and then tell everyone they got it wrong.