I can’t see anyone putting forward a reason for choosing Harvey over Rattan beyond good bloke and champion of the club. Both true but not the main criteria I’d be looking at for choosing a coach. Perhaps you missed the OP Robert Harvey is more thorough in his preparation than anyone in the known un...

St Kilda and the Messiah syndrome Hence one (1) Premiership, that way back in 1966 The person who will be elevated to Messiah status will be the Coach who delivers a second premiership to St Kilda Small minded garbage. Absolutely nothing to do with Messiah status. Why the club has been shyte for al...

Every premiership coach except Malthouse on the last 15 years learnt on the job Every premiership coach including Malthouse in the last 15 years has learnt on the job. Always learning regardless to tenure and even in the example of Malthouse he learnt how to implement Ross Lyon's game plan while le...

I truly hope and pray Robert Harvey is announced as St.kilda's new senior coach. I see him as being St.kilda's Jock McHale for want of a better analogy. Robert Harvey is more thorough in preparation than anyone in the known universe bar none. With the right assistants around him and Lenny Hayes for...

Richo MKII
Watters MKIII

Very pissed

No vision

Ratten is a massive mistake.

Banger came very close. Had three interviews F ..... typical Corporate clownsuits? With Matt gender neutral toilets Finnis responsible for Richardson's contract extension and Simon Lethlean whose clearly demonstrated his ability to make extremely poor decisions... how did he come to land at St.kild...

Robert Harvey is my favourite player of all time, best I’ve seen in the RWB and I reckon he would be a better coach than a lot of ignorant people think... they mistake his introverted humbleness as an inability to lead. Robert is articulate and intelligent and knows more about the game than almost ...

Rob is one of those guys who don’t have say a lot, but when he does, people listen. A good communicator doesn’t necessarily mean a person who waffles on all the time, or speaks the loudest. It’s what they have to say, and when they say it... and there’s also the listening component. Many coaches do...

Maybe but I still think that it would be a very big risk. Hence, I think the club should go for the safe bet and appoint Ratten. Please do explain how Robert Harvey is a big risk and Brett Ratten is a safe bet? Based on what? I personally think Robert Harvey is the safe bet and Brett Ratten is a hu...

I fully expect Brett Ratten to be announced senior coach on probably Tuesday of next week. With Matt gender neutral toilets Finnis, responsible for Richardson's contract extension and Simon Lethlean, whose shown he's very capable of making extremely poor decisions... how did he land at St.kilda in t...

I truly hope and pray Robert Harvey is announced as St.kilda's new senior coach. I see him as being St.kilda's Jock McHale for want of a better analogy. Robert Harvey is more thorough in preparation than anyone in the known universe bar none. With the right assistants around him and Lenny Hayes for ...

Probably announced towards the end of next week. They need to dot every i and cross every t. And there’s a reason there are no substantial leaks, it’s called betting. I hope either Robert Harvey or Sam Mitchell get appointed senior coach. Has the comprehensive exhaustive process even bothered to so...

Did anyone just hear Crawford speaking of Sam Mitchell and enthusiastically endorsing him as a coach READY TO GO. According to Crawford it’s all about timing, and if the right approach was made right now, he’d jump at it. This is our moment St Kilda, if we want to set a new course for this club, MI...

As for Sexton, seriously no one has a clue what he does but he obviously does it very well behind the scenes which doesn't affect what happens on the field. If you have no idea as to what he does, how can you possibly critique it by saying he does it very well when you have no idea as to what it is...

Teflon wrote: ↑Sat 03 Aug 2019 4:40pm

Myron Gaines wrote: ↑Wed 31 Jul 2019 9:52pm McKenzie 3 years
Joyce 2 years
Hanneberry 4 years
Offer Dunstan only 1 year?

Jesus

That’s a debarcle who is making these decisions??

Simon Lethlean

B.M wrote: ↑Sat 03 Aug 2019 10:45am If he was as good as he’s claimed to be, he’d be in the side.

Or perhaps the club is as per usual chock full of incompetent buffoons who wouldn't get the drum even if they had a brass band up them.

tedtheodorelogan2018 wrote: ↑Fri 02 Aug 2019 2:07pm Deflection, deflection, deflection...

WHY DID YOU START ANOTHER THREAD ON THE VERY SAME SUBJECT ?

Stop deflecting and answer the question.

WHY did you start another thread on the very same subject ?

YTF would you start another thread on the very same subject when you're clearly aware of another thread existing ??????????

tedtheodorelogan2018 wrote: ↑Fri 02 Aug 2019 12:38pm What drivel is that Barksy?

All 2,287 posts of it to this point and not forgetting the spam from all your other accounts!

McKenzie has come in for Paton in the small defender role, and Parker has come in for Newnes in the defensive forward role. I don't know if White plays either of those roles does he? He's a swap for Coffield, Clark or Savage I would have thought - but until either of them do something to get themse...

McKenzie comes in for Paton

Brandon White is a better footballer than both of them.

More garbage dished up from the coaches, match committee and football department.

tedtheodorelogan2018 wrote: ↑Thu 01 Aug 2019 7:15pm Facenovel is about as reliable as Barrett's BS.

Damien Barrett looks like Nostradamus when compared to the drivel you dish up!

FAIR F****** DINKUM Has he slept with all the coaches partners and been caught ? What on earth does he need to do to get a game ? White is in the best players almost every game he has played for Sandringham this year. IMHO he is easily a better footballer than McKenzie who just scored a three year c...

tedtheodorelogan2018 wrote: ↑Wed 31 Jul 2019 8:10pm Yeah and Neil Armstrong never landed on the moon!

Speaking of moon landings in a thread about Gastro is quite apposite.

https://soundcloud.com/aeroplanejellyfi ... -jellyfish