I would rather pay him overs in cash and secure him in PSD rather than use a first or second round pick for him.

If we miss out on him in the PSD because another team wants to also pay him overs...BOO HOO...life goes on, we'll average 4 less ruck hit outs than we expected.

Good luck to him if he comes to the Saints but he'll be coming with some fair expectation at a reasonable cost. Personally I am not sure he's worth it. I would rather see Geelong squirm fitting all three in their cap and appease each on their list than pay above price and hence reward Geelong in wha...

A mate just told me that on SEN they were talking that Blake to the Saints is looking likely.

Say it ain't so or at least tell me we will not give up our first two picks.

Not bad Curly, a very unimpressive list but I would take Seaby and Griffin ahead of the much maligned one.

I'm in, regardless of who.

For what it's worth, here's my thoughts. Footy has obviously changed a bit, especially with structures so here's how I see the Saints lining up: BACKS: Max, Sam, Goose, Raph MIDS (all with defensive resposibilities): BJ, Gilbo, Dal, Harves, Lenny, Bally, Roo, Joey, Grammy RUCK: Gardiner (Rix if G no...

I'd give up a 3rd round pick for Hadley. He's had a year now to get over his knee troubles and can find a lot of the ball as well as carry it.

Certainly agree on Mattner, a hard at it, hard tackling half back flanker with a raking left foot. Would free Gram into the midfield and add hardness and acountability to our backline. Much better than 'Yosemite' Carroll, a more p@ss weak cartoon character of a defender I've never seen. I still vivi...

Apologies to Boyle, being a little facetious.

I'm surprised the Dawks would put him up for trade and not try him as that big defender they are after. I thought his background was that of a defender.

Armoooo wrote:What do you guys think about Boyle from hawks?
Do you think he would be worth anything, I think I read that he scored something like 30 goals this season....

Box Hill's loss will be Williamstown's gain.

Goddard and Maguire should be added. I think Goddard is a natural leader and Maguire needs the responsibility, take his mind off attending letter openings. I think the great man, Sir Robert, should head a junior leadership group of three players who are in their first three years of AFL and develop ...

I heard of some ripper trades, but I've been sworn to secrecy until 3.00pm on Friday. I'll tell you all then :wink: !! Unfortunately I do not know enough about websites etc but would it be possible to incorporate a "VAULT" into this site so when people do have information like this they c...

I'll be there and can get you both a guernsey if you like?

Interesting read. I am not sure how they would do it but I would think each club would rate their top 10 mids, their top 10 backs...forwards...rucks. Maybe even top 20 of each and simply take whoever is next depending on their needs and who they have already chosen. Although it sounds like we may no...

do people think blake would be worth our no 9 pick? I haven't seen him play much so don't really know, but a good ruckman would be worth it IMO. No. As another poster said, it is time to boost our base of young guns. We should use picks 9 and 26 to do this. However if Geelong were willing to take o...

Quite true, what ever youngsters we get we must give them a go. At least give them a taste, see how they handle and let them know how hard they have to work to reach the standard required. We cannot afford to keep mid size players on our list for 4 seasons, ala Houlihan, and not at least see what th...

A) I hope you're right

B) We can add that option

I like the idea of Roo and Ball.

Lenny's a gun and players will always follow him but I have a feeling that involving these two in the top position will ease pressure of each and no one will question what they have to say.

When will St Kilda win the flag?

2008
2009
2010
2011-2020
Not in my life time

Nice Iceman, thanks for the memories!

He's a first rate tosser, very full of himself and continues to put out these lists to reinforce how biased and ill informed he is... Fletcher??? The last time he picked up an opponent he was playing school boy footy and even then he was moved off him at quarter time. Franklin??? The Hype is amazing...

Regardless of what we / all of you (yes all of you) / have said on here over the past few years regarding Brooks he has slipped through, survived and remains on our list. The only reason can be Insurance, maybe only Travelling Insurance at best and we all know how dodgy that is especially when tryin...

Very good news. Get ready to sook up again Juddy, your rash is back!

Heard a whisper Scott Welsh may be on the market after after an indiscretion during Mad Monday...any interest to us? I think he's a 50+ goal smallish forward.

I liken a rookie to finding change down the back of the couch. It's that hidden bit of coin that could become valuable down the track, especially when you've ordered that late night pizza and you're trying to pay for it!