" With the Saints now expecting to receive a second-round selection, it is understood both parties are on the same page in the Saints paying a portion of his wage for 2020." Supposedly pick 33 Watch him tear us a new A-hole in 2020 while we pay for the privilege. Why on earth are we even ...

Dan Butler FACEPALM Seriously, the football department are incompetent, clueless and completely out of their depth. Signed McKenzie for three years which is mind boggling stupidity. St.kilda already have a genuine star in the making in Ben Long and a plethora of small forwards to choose from. Recrui...

Tony 74

please explain

asiu wrote: ↑Sun 29 Sep 2019 11:16am i thought it was a bit odd
with their ... 6 Saints to watch , upload

white didn’t get a mention

Brandon White wins Sandringham's B & F and it's still nothing to see here.

Unsure of the meaning of the WTFU acronym, but the rest of your post is certainly quite emotive for a person who was not upset and I would think that <edited by mods>& Chump references are boardering on personal, but each to their own. Anyone who donates their own money to a major political par...

I would love some explanation from the club for his constant non-selection over the past few years when he has shown so much potential when given a chance. Surely this year with all the injuries to our half backs it was the time to give him a go. Instead he is given one game when he acquitted himse...

I apologize for the comment re your post barks4eva. I detect about as much sincerity from you as what you'd get from a snake oil salesman. I would not have written that had I known it would have upset you to this level inciting such an emotive, vitriolic and personal based response. It did NOT upse...

https://www.saints.com.au/news/2019-09-14/vfl-white-wins-neil-bencraft-best-fairest FAIR DINKUM What a joke. IMHO Brandon White is a better footballer than Jake Lever And this is where I stopped reading. Better than Jake Lever? LMAO 😂 LOL I stopped taking anything you say seriously after you wrote ...

https://www.saints.com.au/news/2019-09-14/vfl-white-wins-neil-bencraft-best-fairest FAIR DINKUM What a joke. IMHO Brandon White is a better footballer than Jake Lever. Alan Richardson, what an absolute buffoon. Melbourne are an absolute joke. Rowan Marshall was not selected in round one this year w...

Linton Lodger wrote: ↑Sat 21 Sep 2019 12:45pm Is that a gut feel or have you heard something?

Very strong intuitive feeling.

Have not heard anything from anyone.

Geelong needs to come to the table on this. It can't be just we win, you lose. If not, they are just being opportunistic pricks. In other words being their normal selves. I took great delight in watching Richmond smash my most hated team last night. I would not trade Steven to Geelong as I would ra...

I'm thinking and hopeful that once the Giants season is done, Lenny Hayes will be announced as a new St.kilda assistant coach.

In fact I'd be surprised if this didn't happen.

Anyone else thinking this has a feel of inevitability ?

Did Richardson potentially cost Marshall the B&F by not selecting him in round 1 ?

What voting system do St.kilda use for their B&F ?

Shocking news, hard to believe

Very sad and echo the sentiments already expressed here

Absolute legend

Sympathies and condolences to his family and friends

One more Saint in heaven

RIP Danny

Hero worshipping at its finest and most cringeworthy. [/glow] What absolute garbage and small mindedness. Very sheep like perception by some in their disregard of those who wanted Robert Harvey and echoed by many on here. This thought pattern and assessment is sadly lacking in perspicacity and pers...

Barks, calling people sheep because they disagree with you doesn’t make your argument any stronger. Neither does a nice bit of alliterative wordsmithing. Seems to me like your argument is pretty much based around the emotion of the return of a favourite son. Harves is no more or less qualified than...

Hero worshipping at its finest and most cringeworthy. What absolute garbage and small mindedness. Very sheep like perception by some in their disregard of those who wanted Robert Harvey and echoed by many on here. This thought pattern and assessment is sadly lacking in perspicacity and perspicuity.

My apologies to Robert Harvey. You are a champion of St Kilda and you have earned the opportunity to coach our club. Instead the club has appointed an inferior player with a mediocre coaching record because they lacked the courage to make a brave decision. This was the right time, and we have misse...

My apologies to Robert Harvey. You are a champion of St Kilda and you have earned the opportunity to coach our club. Instead the club has appointed an inferior player with a mediocre coaching record because they lacked the courage to make a brave decision. This was the right time, and we have misse...

Barks banged on about Banger - but his lack of public presence is a real issue and probably the reason he will never be a senior AFL coach anywhere. Have a look at Richo - he spoke with a bag of marbles in his mouth constantly and could never talk the walk (he also couldn’t coach but that’s another...

Richo MKII Watters MKIII Very pissed No vision Ratten is a massive mistake. He says he will do everything within his power to make all Saints fans proud. Are you saying you doubt his sincerity? How can you possibly say he has no vision? He's been coaching the Saints for less than five minutes, rela...

For Harvey, despite Buckleys endorsement, hasn't manage to impress St.Kilda enough to get the job. Who was on the coaching selection committee ? Matt Finnis who ridiculously made the decision to renew Richardson's contract and implemented a gender neutral toilet policy at a St.kilda home game. FAIR...

Pretty standard stuff for a coach talking about his assistant. Yes, it's true you will always hear these types of ringing endorsements... thanks for being captain obvious. The key point is this “ Tactically, I lean on him heavily for his knowledge of the game, but underpinning that is his work rate...

Quoting BM does not exactly lend credibility Rob is one of those guys who don’t have say a lot, but when he does, people listen. A good communicator doesn’t necessarily mean a person who waffles on all the time, or speaks the loudest. It’s what they have to say, and when they say it... and there’s ...

I can’t see anyone putting forward a reason for choosing Harvey over Rattan beyond good bloke and champion of the club. Both true but not the main criteria I’d be looking at for choosing a coach. Perhaps you missed the OP Robert Harvey is more thorough in his preparation than anyone in the known un...