There will always be the black sheep of any group, but as you stated the majority of them were FOR the (suggested) appointment.

Wonder if he can bring with him any inside info...he should know you guys inside/out after 21 years.

BTW, is his book out yet?

:-D I know how highly reguarded Sir Robert is held around here (just look at the avatars) and i know how much you guys hate Carlton, so this must be a huge punch in the guts for ya. Having said that, i think most people have handled it pretty well. You wont find many Carlton people complaining about...

is fev constant? lol most of his goals came from slaughtering bottom 8 sides. consistant, biggest lie out, he chokes against anyone with a decent defender on him, a criticism of gehrig at the END of his career, and fevola is supposed to be at his peak, so thats one lie put to rest. accurate? well w...

ts not ME overrating the value of fevola its your recruiting guys (or whoever got this rumour to the stage it was mentioned on channel 10!) So this is not MY personal opinion, but rather the StK FC's opinion . If you guys really think you deserve fev+ a player for pick 9 as picks are THAT valueable...

I dont think you have a hope in hell of getting without offering pick 9 TBH. Unless you wanna offload kosi. We want the pick so we can deal with wce for juddy. You can want that pick all you want, but I believe you to be either overrating the value of Fevola, or underrating that of draft pick no. 9...

Liam_G wrote:

TheBabyBlues wrote:Shane O'Sullivan is the ex-recruiting manager.

Was about to say that. He hasn't been there for 2 or so years now.

Yeah he was responsible for some famous 1st round recruits such as...
Trent Sporn
Simon Wiggins
Luke Livingston


So yes, we kindly sent him packing.

Was just reported on channel 10 that saints are chasing Fevola. Rumoured to be offering pick 9 and player(s). Seem to be VERY keen to get him by those reports. You may have a fight on your hands to get him over the dogs. Interesting. Shane O'Sullivan, carlton recruitment manager. was having coffee ...

I dont think you have a hope in hell of getting without offering pick 9 TBH. Unless you wanna offload kosi.

We want the pick so we can deal with wce for juddy.

Was just reported on channel 10 that saints are chasing Fevola.

Rumoured to be offering pick 9 and player(s). Seem to be VERY keen to get him by those reports.

You may have a fight on your hands to get him over the dogs.

I found out this rumour through a friend who got an email from someone at aflvic.com I'm not sure if thats where that guy you were talking about is from, but its come from within the AFL somewhere. Not surprising to see the AFL deny it though. :roll: "We dont have a drug problem" "We ...

Read in the Sun today its looking more and more likely Judd will be coming back to Vic. Although its irrelevant to the Saints I was just wondering what team you think will snap him up and how? This is my guess.... Bulldogs Receive - Brendan Fevola Eagles Receive - Kennedy, Pick 3 (Carlton) , Pick 6...

Judd would also command a salary of $1.2Mill in the 1st of a 3 or 4 yr deal increasing up to about $1.6Mill in the final yr. That's a fair whack out of any salary cap. If he was to go to Carlton, how are they going to fit him, Kruezer, Gibbs, Murphy, Walker and all their other early picks under the...

Read in the Sun today its looking more and more likely Judd will be coming back to Vic. Although its irrelevant to the Saints I was just wondering what team you think will snap him up and how? This is my guess.... Bulldogs Receive - Brendan Fevola Eagles Receive - Kennedy, Pick 3 (Carlton) , Pick 6...

Read in the Sun today its looking more and more likely Judd will be coming back to Vic. Although its irrelevant to the Saints I was just wondering what team you think will snap him up and how? This is my guess.... Bulldogs Receive - Brendan Fevola Eagles Receive - Kennedy, Pick 3 (Carlton) , Pick 6...

Read in the Sun today its looking more and more likely Judd will be coming back to Vic. Although its irrelevant to the Saints I was just wondering what team you think will snap him up and how? This is my guess.... Bulldogs Receive - Brendan Fevola Eagles Receive - Kennedy, Pick 3 (Carlton) , Pick 6...

Are Optus and Vodafone competitors? If so do Carlton have a conflict brewing? Do Carlton have a deal with Optus anymore? The oval is called MC Labour Park (pathetic name). Can't remember what's on their jumpers. Dan Murphys? We have 'yes' optus on the back of our jumpers (at least half the time - a...

Such large numbers of de-listings 8, 8 & 9 suggest that these clubs are thinking that they might pick up a gem or two with their picks 4 & 5 Note: 8 De-Listings = 5 Picks (at least 3 in ND & then 2 in PSD). The other 3 spots would be for rookie list players. 9 De-Listings = 6 picks unde...

I understand that posters do not want to perpetuate this hysteria that appears to be creeping in, but to say you are not in turmoil is a bit much. - You current president and ex coach have been in a bitter court battle. - You are recovering from an unpopular sacking of the head coach which has memb...

I understand that posters do not want to perpetuate this hysteria that appears to be creeping in, but to say you are not in turmoil is a bit much. - You current president and ex coach have been in a bitter court battle. - You are recovering from an unpopular sacking of the head coach which has membe...

Actually the only thing that players do not need approval on is boot sponsorship. They can have their own. This was negotiated in players contracts a few years ago. Probably because of the boot fiasco started with Kouta. Adidas vs Nike meant that Kouta was possibly going to be missing games! :shock...

Natham Burke apparantly just said on SEN that Bill express and Vodafone have left St. Kilda and gone to Carlton.

I guess that just about confirms it you'd say.

EDIT: Possible lost in translation here...i dont think Bill Express is coming to carlton as well...just that they have left you guys.

I dont know how much of this is a Luke Ball thing and how much of this can be attributed to Pratts offer to Vodafone... Carlton is looming as the frontrunner to win the Vodafone sponsorship, after billionaire president Richard Pratt made the company a "hard-to-refuse offer". Carlton will o...

Adam Hartlett signed on again for next season, so try again.
You can have Lance though.

Results for the Carlton 2007 B+F are in..."Who cares!" I hear you all say in unison well probably a few of you as it will provide many of you with a good laugh. Just stay with me for a minute... Carlton awards 5,4,3,2,1 from 5 members of the match committee for each game. A total of 75 vot...

Carl Mynott wrote:McLaren is only 196 cm tall,he's not tall enough or good enough at this level to be a ruckman.

We need to draft for need and we don't need duds.....

He also 'retired' from AFL. He has had back problems for a while now and he knows he is shot so its a half deliting/retiring with him.