It is certainly a move to a fairer draw and coupled with the extra handouts it seems like the AFL is doing more to say give a Bulldogs or Kangaroos a great shot at winning the comp when they have the players to do so. If we all have to travel 5 times during the year so be it. I don't care who we pla...

Batnoe wrote:He was midfield coach, look at out midfield stats!!

I'm looking...now what?

Whilst I'm not saying that Harvey should have been appointed coach, I do believe he was treated shabbily...why on earth did St Kilda appoint him caretaker coach and raise his hopes? This was an unnecessary (and arguably foolish) move. We simply didn't need to have a caretaker coach... THIS! Bit of ...

One of the main reasons he did not play is because the coach had no faith in him. Probably the only reason. So when sydney showed him some love he jumped at it. Ross lyon was quite open about the fact he did not think tommy could read the oval ball well enough to play at afl level. This became a bi...

A few reasons He did take a while to develop; probably wasn't ready in 2010 Lyon made him learn the game as a defender, which meant that he was behind a long list of backmen until he finally moved forward late this year When he did finally get a chance up forward, we had hit some form and Lyon has ...

he is just a really unintelligent footballer. the anti-footballers footballer and seemingly takes half a game to get up to speed.

skeptic wrote:seems a poor response from Harvey

He is only human however his response (if as reported) was/is almost childish.

Burkey 1 wrote:Anyone know why this 200cm rookie ruckman at the Lions was delisted, what about him as another ruck option, he is still only young & will no doubt develop, should come very cheap ???

He was on the senior list then delisted. Rookied and now nothing.

Surely that says something?

With the acquisition of Saad and Milera, our post Roo/Kosi/Milne is starting to take shape. Obviously those guys still have some footy left in them (I'd love to see Roo hit the gym and finish his days at FF), but it's good to see some planning for the future. We might also see Schneids make use of ...

Just go Raph.

Love him. Love him long time.

I watched him in a foxtel cup match early in the year when he was playing for the Bullants. He looked good.

I like Pelchin. I like complete pricks of human beings and he is one of them.

plugger66 wrote:Lets stop with threads on players that want over a 100K a year. Remember we have no money on the salary cap.

basically yeah.

He could be a great pickup considering he is crap?

Wow! Reading this from the coast in central Italy. Want to keep Gram. Cant keep me away from Saintsational though. ;) Wow! You are reading this from the coast in central Italy, and you can't keep away :shock: :wink: Berlin. Happy days after a 10 hour train. I would rather Fazza Razza stay however G...

Dr Spaceman wrote:

SaintSimmo wrote:

Old Mate wrote:Pelchin enquiring on Sam Sheldon from the Lions....

sorry but did i just travel back in time a year??

We'll get him one of these days

But why? he is a below average nothing player?

I read the Saints might be competing with Richmond for Adelaide's Ivan Maric .... http://www.afl.com.au/news/newsarticle/tabid/208/newsid/124892/default.aspx St Kilda head of football Chris Pelchen had said the Saints were interested in snaring a ruckman at the trade table but Noble would not confi...

Watters and Richardson. Anyone could work that out. Is this the same source as you had when RL signed for 4 years. Lets face it, its a guess and a pretty good one. were you born a c*** or just became one as your life dragged on and st kilda wore away at you? I have a feeling he was born that way. I...

Tom Lynch barracked for St.Kilda as a kid. Has family and friends here doubt he would want to go to SA when he has a fresh start with a new coach coming along. I think Tom wants opportunity. If Zac gets traded then I think Tom will stay & get a chance as a key defender. Good old Ross Lyon defin...

Collingwood definitely won the trade :evil: Let's not go nuts here. Marty Clarke is pretty average and gets more attention due to being Irish. I call this the 'Tommy Walsh effect'. Yes I am aware of who has played football more and earlier however I am sticking to this theory. I expect Saintsationa...

Geez this blokes a disease that managed to eek some form of AFL credibility off the back of coaching our club. Poor Grant reckons we have "indecision" cause......guess what.....he aint running the show!! What a disgrace to come out publicly, constantly just bagging the club - we ALL know ...

Gary Ayres is all of a sudden so incredibly gifted as a coach that his failures at Cats and Crows is ignored??? IF Gary Ayres is such a fricken coaching gurur - why the ferk hasnt he been hounded for the last 4 coaching jobs that have been appointed? - he wasnt even in the mix for them................

I'd be happy to see Ayres as a senior assistant to a younger coach. A team of Watters, Ayres and Harvey would be a solid base for the coaching group. Please not Ayres for the senior coach though; he had his chances and never got to the top Goodbye membership if so. Don't let the door hit you on the...

mad saint guy wrote:I'd be happy to see Ayres as a senior assistant to a younger coach. A team of Watters, Ayres and Harvey would be a solid base for the coaching group.

Please not Ayres for the senior coach though; he had his chances and never got to the top

Goodbye membership if so.

I do not doubt what Plugger14 'heard' but I know people very close to the previous mediation process. Lovett signed away any right to further action against pretty much anyone when he accepted his settlement. There is nothing. He has nothing. He is nothing. Anything else is nonsensical and ill-info...