Well, somebody's got to do it. The fact that I'm picking it up now is testament to how dismal that performance was. (Forgive me if a votes post has already started and I couldn't find it.) 4 Wilkie -- Franklin only kicked one. Obviously he could have easily kicked more, but I think Wilkie took it up...

5 null. no one came close to 'best'. 4 Ross -- worked hard and went flat-out. Nothing to criticise in his game -- unlike just about everyone else (except Windhager) 3 Gresham -- despite setting the tone right from the start, of running around in circles until coming a stupid cropper. Did more good t...

5 Sinclair
4 Crouch
3 Higgins
2 Webster
1 Battle

sinclair
hill
wilkie
gresham
owens

Sainter Dad,
I think you missed Marshall's goal at the end.

Thank you for all your work -- my favourite part of Saintsational.

hill
king
wilkie
crouch
gresham

We should all wish him the best - he is doing everything he possibly can Sometimes s*** happens Look at McCartin, now a first choice at Sydney Where there is life there is hope I know that first hand, missing all but 2 years, returning for finals and a premiership then playing another 4 years inclu...

5 Sinclair
4 Ryder
3 Gresham
3 Crouch

there were about a dozen Saints who deserved the last vote. Crouch clearly deserved it more.

4 Crouch
3 Steele
3 Sinclair
2 Membrey
1 Wilkie
1 Howard
1 Hill

Wasn't it two or three years ago that he took one of the most courageous marks of all time?
It's pretty easy to call someone "soft" from the sidelines.

terry smith rules wrote: ↑Mon 02 May 2022 8:00pm

avid wrote: ↑Sun 01 May 2022 1:11am 5 Ross
4 Steele
3 Sinclair
2 Wanganeen-Milera
1 Hill

These are my votes too

Fist time anyone's ever done that to me.
Thanks TSR -- makes me feel like I know something.

5 Ross
4 Steele
3 Sinclair
2 Wanganeen-Milera
1 Hill

5 Higgins
4 Battle
3 Steele
1 Gresham
1 Howard
1 Sinclair

Waltzing St Kilda wrote: ↑Sun 17 Apr 2022 6:47am Btw, I'm giving five votes to the seagull. A stalwart performance in the centre if ever there was one.

Rock solid performance, all day.

3 Higgins
3 McKenzie
2 Sinclair
2 Ross
2 Marshall
2 Steele
1 Membrey (I watched him up close up all day and he worked his arse off brilliantly every quarter.)

When was the last time we had four players kicking 4 (or more)?
I reckon it'd be quite a rarity.

5 sinclair
3 steele
2 hill
2 ross
2 butler
1 gresham

and several others who deserved votes

Really liked Jiath's game too.

Edit: I've watched the replay, and upgraded my Butler vote from 1 to 2

It's a very long time since we had someone near the top like that.
Who was the last?

I agree with skeptic

3: Crouch, Steele, Gresham
2: Ross, Sinclair, Ryder
= 15

Such a great team effort -- almost impossible to separate any of them
Ryder wan't in the top half, except for his tapwork -- which may have been where we started to win the game. Amazing to watch.
King played a superb quarter, that's for sure.

5 Battle
2 Sinclair
2 Crouch
2 Hill
2 Higgins
2 King

McKenzie did a lot of good things on the wing. Lienert I thought looked pretty good, and will stay in the side.

Wood shouldn't be under any pressure -- he was one of our better players. Kent did two brilliant things -- and then, apparently, nothing -- or worse, Byrnes had a terrible night. Half way through I thought he must have been a late omission -- then I saw him make a mistake. Owens -- well it was fanta...

5 sinclair
4 hayes
2marshall
1 gresham
1 Hill
1 steel
1 king

Wayne42 wrote: ↑Wed 16 Mar 2022 11:34pm 2nd Innings
Lyon 4 for 103
Swepson 0 for 152

Swepson must have been woeful in this game.

Swepson didn't show a lot, but he DID have three crucial catches dropped off him late in the game.
If they'd been held, he'd now be the hero of Australia's great victory.

He also took some of the most majestic towering pack marks I've seen.

For a while there it was only George Young, Robbie Muir and Barks that kept me going.