Maguire IN - And why?

BelfastSaint · Fri 11 Apr 2008 7:15pm

The simple question is ...Will Goose do a better job than R Clarke and will Dempster do a better job than Geary ........

maverick · Post: # 546077Post **maverick** » Fri 11 Apr 2008 10:31pm

This thread gives me no confidence.
So basically the club and some on here think that Goose is good enough for the 1's without form...fitness is his only issue....
I simply don't agree....hope I am wrong...
I just think Goose gives away far too many frees, will find out tomorrow I suppose....

ace · Post: # 546084Post **ace** » Fri 11 Apr 2008 10:44pm

McGuire will never play - all Eddie can do is talk, talk, talk.
Now Maguire, he is the real deal when it comes to football.

bigcarl · Post: # 546102Post **bigcarl** » Fri 11 Apr 2008 11:03pm

maverick wrote:I just think Goose gives away far too many frees

well they changed the rules on him while he was out with that horrible broken leg.

the other issue is the gameplan. i think he responded to gt's style a bit better and has struggled to adapt to the more accountable brand demanded by the new regime.

goose never has been and probably never will be the dour, defensive, close-checking type.

at his best he's a strong, aggressive chb who can dominate the air across half back. at his worst he's ... well we saw a bit of it last year.