Guess this weeks ins and outs

[plugger66]

Out
Shenton
Sinclair
Lonie
Rooy


In
Acres
Minch
Joey
Membery

[#gosaintas]

Out
Sinclair
Roo
Lonie
Shenton

In
Acres
Membrey
Lee
Saad

[Jacks Back]

Out
Sinclair
Roo
Lonie
Shenton

In
Acres
Membrey
Lee
Saad

If we have hardly any injuries then imho we shouldn't really be playing any rookies (unless they have been outstanding). So Saad (and reluctantly even Schneider) shouldn't be in the team.

I like P66's changes and I will second them as I would like to see Acres and Minchy in the team.

[CURLY]

I think Lee has to come in his form has been good and has looked to be doing what has been asked of him.

[bergholt]

OUT: Lonie, Riewoldt, Sinclair
IN: Curren, Membrey, Montagna

[saintspremiers]

IN: Lee, Ray, Minch
Out: Roo, Shenton, Eli

Lonie had only mild concussion....I really hope he plays, we need him with his bro Sinclair out.

[Beno88]

In : Membrey, Montagna, Acres

Out : Riewoldt, Lonie, Dunstan

[gringo]

Out: Sinkers, Riewoldt and Lonie

In: Ray, Montagna and Saad

[jonesy]

The clubs trying to give away a squillion tickets this week, therefore play the kids, interstate side,on our turf. Give us another look at Paddy,Goddard it's time,Acres can't do any more. Give us a look at them

[stjay]

Out: Roo, Lonie, Sinks, Shenton
In: Membrey, Acres, Minch & Curren

Can't get a sense if Joey will play.
Shenton didn't lay 1 tackle which is bad enough but for a guy who plays defensive roles this shows a total lack of intent.
I actually thought he used the ball a little better but how much pressure is he really applying if you don't tackle?

[Beno88]

The clubs trying to give away a squillion tickets this week, therefore play the kids, interstate side,on our turf. Give us another look at Paddy,Goddard it's time,Acres can't do any more. Give us a look at them

Neither McCartin or Goddard played VFL last weekend, it's unlikely they'd come straight in to the senior side. Acres must come in though.

[S.A Saint]

Out
Roo
Sinclair
Lonie

In
Acres
Membrey
Saad

What id like to see
Out
Roo
Sinclair
Lonie (con)
Shenton
Templeton

In
Acres
Membrey
Minchington
Goddard
Curren (inside mid only)

[RW&B]

Out
Shenton
Sinclair
Lonie
Rooy


In
Acres
Minch
Joey
Membery

+1

[bigballs]

Out: Rooey, Lonie, Sinclair, Shenton
In: Acres, Goddard, Saad, Minchington

[terry smith rules]

Not one mention of Geary , surely he comes in if fit
In Membrey Geary Joey Acres Out Roo Lonie, Sinclair, Shenton

[saintsRrising]

Not one mention of Geary , surely he comes in if fit

The goss is that he is not fit as he is not over his corkie yet.
So that is why no one is picking him.

[terry smith rules]

Not one mention of Geary , surely he comes in if fit

The goss is that he is not fit as he is not over his corkie yet.
So that is why no one is picking him.

fair enough not following the injury updates 100%

so if that is the case in Ray out Shenton as well as the other I mentioned

[Armoooo]

Out: Roo, Lonie, Sinclair, Shenton
In: Membrey, Joey, Acres, Minchington

Would love to reward Curren and Lee's form but feel that they play roles we already seem to have covered.

Roberton and Dunstan just ahead of those two at this stage for mine So there's a lot of good competition for spots.

[Armoooo]

Oops just realised I posted the same as p66, could have just quoted :p

[SainterK]

Sinc gets to play yay...

change of heart by AFL

[saintspremiers]

Sinc gets to play yay...

change of heart by AFL

Link?

Here's an article but doesn't mention Sinclair.
Says Lonie out

http://m.afl.com.au/news/2015-05-21/joe ... other-week

[Beno88]

Sinclair can play.

http://www.theage.com.au/afl/afl-news/a ... h6m2b.html

Ray to stay in the VFL for another week too.

[Saint wagga]

Out: Rooey (inj), Lonie (inj), Geary (inj), Dunstan (omit), Shenton (omit)
In: Membrey, Minchi, Acres, Curren, Joey

[longtimesaint]

Out: Rooey (inj), Lonie (inj), Geary (inj), Dunstan (omit), Shenton (omit)
In: Membrey, Minchi, Acres, Curren, Joey

Geary is not in the side so can't be an out.
Cannot see why Dunstan should be omitted -he had a quiet day last week but wasn't alone.
Been solid for most of the year and our midfield would be weakened without him.
People forget the huge gap between VFL and AFL and performances against teams like Frankston needs to be discounted to some extent

[Saint wagga]

Out: Rooey (inj), Lonie (inj), Geary (inj), Dunstan (omit), Shenton (omit)
In: Membrey, Minchi, Acres, Curren, Joey

Geary is not in the side so can't be an out.
Cannot see why Dunstan should be omitted -he had a quiet day last week but wasn't alone.
Been solid for most of the year and our midfield would be weakened without him.
People forget the huge gap between VFL and AFL and performances against teams like Frankston needs to be discounted to some extent

just my opinion