Coaches Votes 2013

[saintbrat]

Round 1
Gold Coast v St Kilda
10 Gary Ablett (GC)
5 David Armitage (St K)
4 Rory Thompson (GC)
3 Greg Broughton (GC)
3 Jarryn Geary (St K)
2 Jarrod Harbrow (GC)
2 Jack Steven (St K)
1 David Swallow (GC)


well done Armo for getting votes from both coaches. - and Jarryn and Jack.

[BigMart]

There is one player in there who is pretty lucky IMO

Armitage.... Good player

[plugger66]

.....

[CURLY]

There is one player in there who is pretty lucky IMO

Armitage.... Good player

Yeah I was thinking Ablett was to.

[BigMart]

Exactly.

[perfectionist]

Perhaps:

Coach 1

5. G Ablett
4. R Thompson
3. G Broughton
2. J Harbrow
1. D Armitage

Coach 2

5. G Ablett
4. D Armitage
3. J Geary
2. J Steven
1. D Swallow

[bergholt]

Round 2

10 Riewoldt (Rich)
6 Conca (Rich)
4 McEvoy (St K)
4 Riewoldt (St K)
3 Cotchin (Rich)
2 Deledio (Rich)
1 Dal Santo (St K)

Saint Totals

5 Armitage (1)
4 McEvoy (1), Riewoldt (1)
3 Geary (1)
2 Steven (1)
1 Dal Santo (1)

[creepypolar]

COACH 1
5 - Jack
4 - McEvoy
3 - Conca
2 - Cotchin
1 - Dal Santo

COACH 2
5 - Jack
4 - Nick
3 - Conca
2 - Deledio
1 - Cotchin

[bergholt]

Round 3

10 Armitage
4 McEvoy, Steven
3 Montagna, Stanley
2 Milera, Roberton, Ward

Saint Totals

15 Armitage (2)
8 McEvoy (2)
6 Steven (2)
4 Riewoldt (1)
3 Geary (1), Montagna (1), Stanley (1)
2 Milera (1), Roberton(1)
1 Dal Santo (1)

Armo, McEvoy and Steven the top three is a good result, as well as Geary, Stanley, Milera and Roberton already in the votes.

[saintbrat]

Armo is just in the Top 10 for all teams
Round 3 Leaderboard
20 Jarrad McVeigh (Syd)
19 Trent Cotchin (Rich)
18 Travis Boak (Port)
18 Kieren Jack (Syd)
18 Justin Westhoff (Port)
17 Nathan Fyfe (Fre)
17 Pearce Hanley (Bris)
17 Jobe Watson (Ess)
16 Grant Birchall (Haw)
15 David Armitage (St K)

http://aflca.com.au/index.php?id=14&tx_ ... 66aa8233c4

[plugger66]

Round 3

10 Armitage
4 McEvoy, Steven
3 Montagna, Stanley
2 Milera, Roberton, Ward

Saint Totals

15 Armitage (2)
8 McEvoy (2)
6 Steven (2)
4 Riewoldt (1)
3 Geary (1), Montagna (1), Stanley (1)
2 Milera (1), Roberton(1)
1 Dal Santo (1)

Armo, McEvoy and Steven the top three is a good result, as well as Geary, Stanley, Milera and Roberton already in the votes.

Strange voting this week. Except for Armo and one of the two voters, neither coach thought Steven, Joey, Stanley or 2 of the 2 voters were good enough to get a voye from the other coach.

[Cairnsman]

Round 3

10 Armitage
4 McEvoy, Steven
3 Montagna, Stanley
2 Milera, Roberton, Ward

Saint Totals

15 Armitage (2)
8 McEvoy (2)
6 Steven (2)
4 Riewoldt (1)
3 Geary (1), Montagna (1), Stanley (1)
2 Milera (1), Roberton(1)
1 Dal Santo (1)

Armo, McEvoy and Steven the top three is a good result, as well as Geary, Stanley, Milera and Roberton already in the votes.

This is just my opinion but I don't think Geary and Steven would be rated outside our club and wouldn't attract much attention from oppo coaches, i.e. don't think Steve will ever have to worry about a tag becuase he just can't hurt the opposition when he has the pill. Geary is a worry also. I just wonder how many bad disposers of the ball can the new Saints carry. Got a feeling Pelchen and co are working on that.


Strange voting this week. Except for Armo and one of the two voters, neither coach thought Steven, Joey, Stanley or 2 of the 2 voters were good enough to get a voye from the other coach.

[saintbrat]

Round 5

St. Kilda vs Sydney

10 Hannebery (Syd)

5 Hayes (St K)

5 Riewoldt (St K)

4 Parker (Syd)

3 Jack (Syd)

3 Kennedy (Syd)

http://aflca.com.au/index.php?id=14&tx_ ... e797431c4a

[bergholt]

Saint Totals

15 Armitage (2)
9 Riewoldt (2)
8 McEvoy (2)
6 Steven (2)
5 Hayes (1)
3 Geary (1), Montagna (1), Stanley (1)
2 Milera (1), Roberton(1)
1 Dal Santo (1)

[saintbrat]

Collingwood vs St. Kilda

8 Pendlebury (Coll)

7 Thomas (Coll)

4 Cloke (Coll)

4 Shaw (Coll)

3 Riewoldt (St K)

2 Geary (St K)

1 Macaffer (Coll)

1 O'Brien (Coll)

http://aflca.com.au/index.php?id=14&tx_ ... d92394785d

Despite the media talking Nick up he only got a few votes this week- but a much wider spread

[CURLY]

Cloke more votes than Riewoldt????? Fair to say Waters gave him 3 Buckles 0.

[plugger66]

Cloke more votes than Riewoldt????? Fair to say Waters gave him 3 Buckles 0.

Scott Watters could have given Cloke 4 as well. More likely than Shaw getting 4 IMO.

[saintbrat]

Rd 7

St Kilda vs Carlton
10 Steven (St K)
8 Riewoldt (StK)
3 Judd (Car)
3 McEvoy ( St K)
2 Fisher (St K)
2 Geary (St K)
1 Armfield (Car)
1 Henderson (Car)

[Old Mate]

Rd 7

St Kilda vs Carlton
10 Steven (St K)
8 Riewoldt (StK)
3 Judd (Car)
3 McEvoy ( St K)
2 Fisher (St K)
2 Geary (St K)
1 Armfield (Car)
1 Henderson (Car)

Didn't Armfield tag Steven?

[dragit]

Didn't Armfield tag Steven?

And Henderson was on Riewoldt for 3 quarters

[saintbrat]

Didn't Armfield tag Steven?

And Henderson was on Riewoldt for 3 quarters

but then henderson got the 3 goals was it in the last....

top two no debate though.

[st.byron]

Thanks for keeping up with posting this Brat. Always interesting to see how the coaches saw it.

[#1GILL]

Doesn't that mean that one coach didn't even give McEvoy a vote? Strange really

[bergholt]

Didn't Armfield tag Steven?

I wouldn't have thought so? Armfield played across half-forward most of the game - Webster went to him for most of the third quarter after he came on.

[bergholt]

Saint Totals

20 Riewoldt (4)
16 Steven (3)
15 Armitage (2)
11 McEvoy (3)
7 Geary (3)
5 Hayes (1)
3 Montagna (1), Stanley (1)
2 Fisher (1), Milera (1), Roberton(1)
1 Dal Santo (1)

Four of the top five are 23 or 24 years old, so that's a positive for the future I guess. Less positive is that the guy who's still by far our best player is 30 years old.

Presumably that top five would also be leading the B&F at this point? Joey and CJ maybe also thereabouts.