Ins/Outs for Rd 16 v Port

dcstkfc · Post: # 1099050Post **dcstkfc** » Sun 03 Jul 2011 10:54pm

In Ledger/Geary (if Ledger not fit)
Out Polo

spert · Post: # 1099058Post **spert** » Sun 03 Jul 2011 10:56pm

Out: Gram, Polo (probably Roo after the MRP get a look at his incident)
In: McQ, Johnson, Raph

dcstkfc · Post: # 1099059Post **dcstkfc** » Sun 03 Jul 2011 10:57pm

spert wrote:Out: Gram, Polo (probably Roo after the MRP get a look at his incident)
In: McQ, Johnson, Raph

1. Raph played.

2. What was the incident with Roo?

plugger66 · Sun 03 Jul 2011 10:58pm

spert wrote:Out: Gram, Polo (probably Roo after the MRP get a look at his incident)
In: McQ, Johnson, Raph

Raph played. As will Grammy and Rooy next week.

mad saint guy · Mon 04 Jul 2011 4:14am

Out: Gamble, Gram
In: Siposs, Smith

Polo lucky. Johnson or Archer in if Roo is suspended.

axcellence · Mon 04 Jul 2011 7:42am

Can Kosi come back in next round? He could have played in vfl and then played against north ... Making it 2 weeks.

St DAC · Post: # 1099236Post **St DAC** » Mon 04 Jul 2011 8:24am

axcellence wrote:Can Kosi come back in next round? He could have played in vfl and then played against north ... Making it 2 weeks.

Nope. 2 matches is the next 2 matches the club (Saints) plays. He's back for West Coast I think.

Halo · Post: # 1099260Post **Halo** » Mon 04 Jul 2011 9:55am

What is going on with Tommy Walsh ?? Will he ever get a game ??

spert · Post: # 1099262Post **spert** » Mon 04 Jul 2011 9:57am

spert wrote:Out: Gram, Polo (probably Roo after the MRP get a look at his incident)
In: McQ, Johnson, Raph

I meant Raph stays in..

BigMart · Post: # 1099263Post **BigMart** » Mon 04 Jul 2011 10:01am

Out
Gamble, Polo

In
Johnson, geary

saintspremiers · Mon 04 Jul 2011 10:21am

In Eddy and Mini and Bakes.

We need to be a bit more tighter and defensive.

borderbarry · Mon 04 Jul 2011 10:23am

Out.. Dawson Polo

In ... Walsh Ledger

Against Port would be the ideal time to blood Tommy W.
Dawson had a very poor game again yesterday. Cost us goals with stupid free kicks again.

Mr Magic · Post: # 1099286Post **Mr Magic** » Mon 04 Jul 2011 10:23am

spert wrote:
spert wrote:Out: Gram, Polo (probably Roo after the MRP get a look at his incident)
In: McQ, Johnson, Raph
I meant Raph stays in..

We play 1 man short?
You've got 3 going out and only 2 coming in?

Dr Spaceman · Mon 04 Jul 2011 10:24am

saintspremiers wrote:In Eddy and Mini and Bakes.

We need to be a bit more tighter and defensive.

Nibble, nibble, nibble...

Nah, not hungry

Con Gorozidis · Mon 04 Jul 2011 12:38pm

Really hard at the selection table this week - especially if we have no rooey, no kosi, no stanley.

I guess Archer and Johnson get a look in with Cahill as the dark horse.

Megsie · Post: # 1099398Post **Megsie** » Mon 04 Jul 2011 12:42pm

CONGRATULATIONS ZAC. A GAME WELL PLAYED. IT'S DIFFICULT TO PLAY AGAINST A TEAM WITH AN EXTRA PLAYER.............THE UMPIRE!!!!!!!!!!

ONE OF YOUR BEST GAMES YEST.

desertsaint · Mon 04 Jul 2011 1:10pm

who knows?
if ledger is fit he should play - straight swap for raph
if siposs is ready - in for gamble
if gram is going to tag - swap for baker
if anyone is showing anything at all - swap for schneider
if kosi is fit will probably come in for? hopefully not lynch

mohannair · Post: # 1099418Post **mohannair** » Mon 04 Jul 2011 1:21pm

desertsaint wrote:who knows?
if ledger is fit he should play - straight swap for raph
if siposs is ready - in for gamble
if gram is going to tag - swap for baker
if anyone is showing anything at all - swap for schneider
if kosi is fit will probably come in for? hopefully not lynch

Kosi is suspended for one more week, will be in only for the West Coast game.

borderbarry · Mon 04 Jul 2011 2:07pm

One of Zac's best games?????
I must have been watching the wrong match.

matrix · Post: # 1099448Post **matrix** » Mon 04 Jul 2011 2:09pm

too bad
get used to it
he is the full back

you just dont go dropping KPPs willy nilly unless they are absolutely diabolical in efforts.

Thinline · Post: # 1099449Post **Thinline** » Mon 04 Jul 2011 2:10pm

borderbarry wrote:One of Zac's best games?????
I must have been watching the wrong match.

What did he do that wasn't up to your standards?

Far as I cld tell he competed pretty well with a bigger, stronger, and in form opponent in Petrie. Petrie kicked two goals, but didn't play much part in the general state of affairs.

Who'd be a fullback....

You just get slagged no matter what.

SainterK · Post: # 1099470Post **SainterK** » Mon 04 Jul 2011 2:30pm

Given Ledger has a hamstring, I'd like to see Crocker sub next week.

Out Gram, Dawson
In Walsh, Crocker (sub)

Walsh to play FB, Raph to play Grams role

Before anyone gets upset with me over Dawson, I just think it's time Tommy had a go, and as good a job as I think Zac did on Petrie, I'd tell him to work on his temper.

dcstkfc · Post: # 1099472Post **dcstkfc** » Mon 04 Jul 2011 2:35pm

SainterK wrote:Given Ledger has a hamstring, I'd like to see Crocker sub next week.

Out Gram, Dawson
In Walsh, Crocker (sub)

Walsh to play FB, Raph to play Grams role

Before anyone gets upset with me over Dawson, I just think it's time Tommy had a go, and as good a job as I think Zac did on Petrie, I'd tell him to work on his temper.

Personally I think throwing in Walsh to play on Schulz would be throwing him to the wolves. Westhoff and Ebert can take a grab too.

Thinline · Post: # 1099473Post **Thinline** » Mon 04 Jul 2011 2:37pm

SainterK wrote:Given Ledger has a hamstring, I'd like to see Crocker sub next week.

Out Gram, Dawson
In Walsh, Crocker (sub)

Walsh to play FB, Raph to play Grams role

Before anyone gets upset with me over Dawson, I just think it's time Tommy had a go, and as good a job as I think Zac did on Petrie, I'd tell him to work on his temper.

Walsh to Jay Shulz could be an interesting first hit out. A 'maybe' on a 'not bad, not super.'

I'm with you on Gram. Appreciate the role was foreign as, well, cigarettes to elite athletes, but how a tagger can't at least get more than a dribble of CP's astounds me. Maybe the instruction was 'sacrifice and learn selflessness'.

Crocker sounds like he might be a bit 'underweight' for the level, but he could be a good sub option.

I doubt Dawson will be an omission, but I think your ideas are good.

SainterK · Post: # 1099478Post **SainterK** » Mon 04 Jul 2011 2:46pm

dcstkfc wrote:
SainterK wrote:Given Ledger has a hamstring, I'd like to see Crocker sub next week.

Out Gram, Dawson
In Walsh, Crocker (sub)

Walsh to play FB, Raph to play Grams role

Before anyone gets upset with me over Dawson, I just think it's time Tommy had a go, and as good a job as I think Zac did on Petrie, I'd tell him to work on his temper.
Personally I think throwing in Walsh to play on Schulz would be throwing him to the wolves. Westhoff and Ebert can take a grab too.

It won't be Walsh on Schultz though, it will be a team defence v Schulz.

Gilbert should be able to go with Westoff, Gwilt - Ebert.

Crocker, he just stands out to me at training, his kicking is fantastic. He may be slight, but I reckon he'd make the most of the opportunity.

Not sure Johnson will get in, Lynch did a VERY good job IMO.