OFFICIAL - trade rumours/wishlist thread

[mrtanz]

with the need for at least a half decent ruckman is it ridiculous to say that llane spaanderman from wce should be looked at? i know he's already been at 2 clubs (bris and wce) but is young and goes ok and i think it wouldn't be the worst pick up (maybe 2nd or 3rd round pick for him)

[Animal Enclosure]

Wasn't Spandermaan heading in the Lawrence Angwin direction?

[mrtanz]

maybe not then if thats true. i just reckon that we should be looking at any young back up ruckmen from other clubs coz drafting a ruckman straight from the tac cup usually means waiting 2-3 years for them to develop physically and god only knows when a decent ruckman was around the club

[True Blue Sainter]

I still think Jolly would be a mighty good pick up- If he does a Judd and says I want to go home, and nominates us as preferred club (due to RL connection, for example) he would be a terrific pick up!!

[Shades]

Judd 4 PM if he comes 2 saints if not his skum

[plugger66]

with the need for at least a half decent ruckman is it ridiculous to say that llane spaanderman from wce should be looked at? i know he's already been at 2 clubs (bris and wce) but is young and goes ok and i think it wouldn't be the worst pick up (maybe 2nd or 3rd round pick for him)

Surely this is a joke.

[luckysaint]

Sam Butler from the eagles and Brad Moran from north might be worth a go, wouldn't give too much for them though.

[plugger66]

Sam Butler from the eagles and Brad Moran from north might be worth a go, wouldn't give too much for them though.

Seconds players. No.

[luckysaint]

Sam Butler from the eagles and Brad Moran from north might be worth a go, wouldn't give too much for them though.

Seconds players. No.

I thought that the only thing that kept Butler out of the West Coast Eagles line up was injury?

Brad Moran is probably a bit ambitious.

[Sam23]

Sam Butler from the eagles and Brad Moran from north might be worth a go, wouldn't give too much for them though.

Seconds players. No.

I thought that the only thing that kept Butler out of the West Coast Eagles line up was injury?

Correct, I doubt Plugger would now apologize because he is a snide arrogant bastard lately, but yeh anyway

[plugger66]

Sam Butler from the eagles and Brad Moran from north might be worth a go, wouldn't give too much for them though.

Seconds players. No.

I thought that the only thing that kept Butler out of the West Coast Eagles line up was injury?

Correct, I doubt Plugger would now apologize because he is a snide arrogant bastard lately, but yeh anyway

Thanks for those kind words. Much appreciated.

[Sam23]

What happened to you lately....you seem to think your better than everyone else becasue you know people?

[plugger66]

What happened to you lately....you seem to think your better than everyone else becasue you know people?

You had a go at me and I didnt have a go back and you still comment. Sorry should I have abused you.

I certainly dont think I am better and who do I know apart from my mates.

[Sam23]

Mates?..

[plugger66]

Mates?..

Your not being very nice.

[Sam23]

I like your inside knowledge and when you want to you can be a good poster, but lately very boring and predictable...but what do you care, right...

[ausfatcat]

I like your inside knowledge and when you want to you can be a good poster, but lately very boring and predictable...but what do you care, right...

it's plugger66au with all the really good inside news.

[True Blue Sainter]

So far, we've officially been notified that we're interested in Judd, although it doesn't seem too likely that
a) he would want to come here
b) we could offer them a good enough package

Is there anyone else that Sheldon has expressed interest in? Jolly? Pettifer?

[fisher_fan]

So far, we've officially been notified that we're interested in Judd, although it doesn't seem too likely that
a) he would want to come here
b) we could offer them a good enough package

Is there anyone else that Sheldon has expressed interest in? Jolly? Pettifer?

I don't think so. I just hope when they realise its official they won't get him that it's to late to go afte a Pettifer or a Jolly. I would have to miss out on one of them because we put to much into trying to get the ungettable.

[roo+hayes=flag]

I think we need to look at getting a reconised and proven FF. We could offer Rixy and 2nd rnd pick for fev or give them pick 9 for fev and Kennady

[st_Trav_ofWA]

wow you must be important cause you wrote in really big letters and (even though you failed) purple text

[dalboy]

Was reported on CH 10 news tonight that we are having a big go at Fev...talk of giving pick 9 for him. Hope this is wrong. While he can be a great player he can also be a great tool and we don't need his attitude imo.

[Megamaguire]

Was reported on CH 10 news tonight that we are having a big go at Fev...talk of giving pick 9 for him. Hope this is wrong. While he can be a great player he can also be a great tool and we don't need his attitude imo.

Fev is undoubtedly a sweet long kick for goal and is able to lead and lead - great but the down side is his unstable character (as i see it). Perhaps this would even out at Saint Kilda where we are currently blessed with a group of no rubbish focused players that are genuinely aiming for success. Fev may well blossom at Moorabbin and knuckle down who knows. Loosing Pick 9 for him might sweeten a judd 3 -way deal but our club can't afford to to let top picks go . Fev and Pick 9. both suggest possible stability - we have to play hard ball and entice carlton or the eagles to release a young genuine prospect to sweeten OUR deal

[Davo027]

Hille ?

[True Blue Sainter]

Hille would be a useful pick up Davo... particularly if we can get Gardiner up and running. I think Hille would thrive as a 2nd ruckman, with say, 25-30% game time in the ruck and 30-35% up forward, alternating with Gardiner, and Kosi as a relief ruckman, permanent FF. That would be a frightening trio of talls...