Membrey named

[Bruce G McAbee]

That's all, announced on 7 News.

[diddley]

Looks like
Membrey
Campbell
Windy
Cordy
Paton
Bytel
Sharman
Butler
Named as the extended bench.

[ace]

https://www.saints.com.au/news/1306331/ ... rward-call
Tim Membrey will likely line up in Sandringham colours this weekend as St Kilda makes the trip interstate to face Collingwood for Gather Round.
Membrey joins newcomers Cooper Sharman and Tom Campbell on the extended bench, with Dan Butler, Marcus Windhager, Zaine Cordy, Ben Paton and Jack Bytel also named.

[diddley]

My money is on
Membrey
Windy
Butler
Paton
Bytel sub

Sharman Campbell Cordy to miss out.

[ace]

B
Josh Battle Dougal Howard Callum Wilkie

HB
Liam Stocker Jack Sinclair Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera

C
Mason Wood Seb Ross Ryan Byrnes

HF
Mattaes Phillipou Bradley Hill Jack Higgins

F
Mitch Owens Jade Gresham Anthony Caminiti

R
Rowan Marshall Brad Crouch Hunter Clark

INT
Dan Butler Marcus Windhager Zaine Cordy
Jack Bytel Tim Membrey Ben Paton
Tom Campbell Cooper Sharman

[diddley]

My money is on
Membrey
Windy
Butler
Paton
Bytel sub

Sharman Campbell Cordy to miss out.

Swap Cordy for Membrey after Ace’s article then.

[saynta]

St Kilda v Collingwood
Sunday April
4:20pm ACST (4:50pm AEST), Adelaide Oval
Broadcast live on Fox Footy, Kayo and the AFL Live Official App

IN: Campbell, Membrey, Sharman
OUT: -

Last week’s substitute: Jack Bytel replaced Rowan Marshall in the fourth quarter.

[Toy Saint]

My money is on
Membrey
Windy
Butler
Paton
Bytel sub

Sharman Campbell Cordy to miss out.

Not so sure they'll leave Cordy out. Depends on our ruck strategy, on one hand Membrey would add greater pace and flexibility, alternately we could exploit the Pies lack of ruck and double team them with either Cordy or even Campbell.

[ace]

6 guys deemed fit but not selected
Tom Highmore
Max Heath
Oscar Adams
James Van Es
Lee Connolly
Jack Peris

[B.M]

Cordy is not a ruckman’s arsehole!

He’s been doing a job because of necessity

If he’s best 22 - with players back

We are still average

FFS
He was subbed out at 3qtr time with 1 possession a couple of weeks ago

[ace]

St Kilda v Collingwood
Sunday April
4:20pm ACST (4:50pm AEST), Adelaide Oval
Broadcast live on Fox Footy, Kayo and the AFL Live Official App

That's right folks
The game between No 1 and No 5 on the ladder is being played in Adelaide making it hard for Melbourne based fans
And it won't be shown live on free to air channel 7.
You got to love the way the AFL negotiates broadcast rights to screw over footy fans.
St Kilda will just have to accept this insult.
I can't wait for Collingwood to unlease on the AFL for this.

[Rubyjo]

St Kilda v Collingwood
Sunday April
4:20pm ACST (4:50pm AEST), Adelaide Oval
Broadcast live on Fox Footy, Kayo and the AFL Live Official App

That's right folks
The game between No 1 and No 5 on the ladder is being played in Adelaide making it hard for Melbourne based fans
And it won't be shown live on free to air channel 7.
You got to love the way the AFL negotiates broadcast rights to screw over footy fans.
St Kilda will just have to accept this insult.
I can't wait for Collingwood to unlease on the AFL for this.

Who the hell watches free to air these days .

[Moods]

Cordy is not a ruckman’s arsehole!

He’s been doing a job because of necessity

If he’s best 22 - with players back

We are still average

FFS
He was subbed out at 3qtr time with 1 possession a couple of weeks ago

Ok. Who’s 2nd ruck then?

[B.M]

The toughest and probably strongest fella on the list

[Vortex]

The toughest and probably strongest fella on the list

Cordy then

[WellardSaint]

RTB has praised Cordy in pressers, at least once, for being physical in F50 and showing the way to Pou n Hammer.
If Skunk's not in, then Cordy plays for his leadership

[Otiman]

Saints article has him coming back in via the VFL.

https://www.saints.com.au/news/1306331/ ... rward-call

[skeptic]

Looks like
Membrey
Campbell
Windy
Cordy
Paton
Bytel
Sharman
Butler
Named as the extended bench.

So…
Membrey coming through the reserves and Bytel missing a week.

Butler
Windy
Cordy
Paton

Pointless having Cordy on the bench and Campbell as sub. Have to go with one or the other.

I’d go Sharman as sub.

[Rubyjo]

Bring on the Sharman.. goal kicker and has learnt defence ..perfect fit for Cordy.

[saynta]

St Kilda v Collingwood
Sunday April
4:20pm ACST (4:50pm AEST), Adelaide Oval
Broadcast live on Fox Footy, Kayo and the AFL Live Official App

That's right folks
The game between No 1 and No 5 on the ladder is being played in Adelaide making it hard for Melbourne based fans
And it won't be shown live on free to air channel 7.
You got to love the way the AFL negotiates broadcast rights to screw over footy fans.
St Kilda will just have to accept this insult.
I can't wait for Collingwood to unlease on the AFL for this.

Who the hell watches free to air these days .

News only. Then only ch 9.

[B.M]

Leadership… seriously

He led the chorus with his mad Monday exploits, that’s about it

In a forward line with an eleven gamer and two 4 games

He’s been the 4th best tall forward!

I know we love to stick up for saints players, but seriously
He’s about as good as Dean Kent
He’s hardly got a kick and two of his three goals were gifted to him by kids.

Sorry to say it how it is, but he’s BOG

It’s funny, we question a proven good player like Seb Ross, but defend a Gumby???

Happy he’s on the list as back up - like Campbell- but that’s it

Cordy over the 4 wins has probably been the least effective player
We are 17th for converting entries into scores - he doesn’t help!

[desertsaint]

you'd hope he comes in via sandy - teams on a roll and any player yet to have a run in 23 need to prove matchfit and earn a spot.

[Banger9798]

If you were Collingwood, you would prefer to see Cordy named over Membrey.

[saynta]

If you were Collingwood, you would prefer to see Cordy named over Membrey.

s*** yes.

[Moods]

Leadership… seriously

He led the chorus with his mad Monday exploits, that’s about it

In a forward line with an eleven gamer and two 4 games

He’s been the 4th best tall forward!

I know we love to stick up for saints players, but seriously
He’s about as good as Dean Kent
He’s hardly got a kick and two of his three goals were gifted to him by kids.

Sorry to say it how it is, but he’s BOG

It’s funny, we question a proven good player like Seb Ross, but defend a Gumby???

Happy he’s on the list as back up - like Campbell- but that’s it

Cordy over the 4 wins has probably been the least effective player
We are 17th for converting entries into scores - he doesn’t help!

Why don’t you just enlighten us as to who would play 2nd ruck. I’m not defending Cordy necessarily I’m asking a serious question. Cordy not overly gifted and he has had quiet games, except for the dogs game, Are you nominating Owens for 2nd ruck, because that’s a sure fire way to ruin the kid