Trading our 1st round pick

SaintWodonga · Sun 16 Sep 2007 7:53pm

Keep number 9 at all costs... Unless we get Judd of course!

borderbarry · Sun 16 Sep 2007 7:57pm

If the Eagles want two top ten draft picks, that lets out Collingwood, they dont have any.
If we could get a good kid from Carlton or Richmond plus their 2nd round pick, 19, 20, it might be worth while. The kid would have to be a good one though.

Iratedebate · Sun 16 Sep 2007 7:58pm

i would think that the eagles would want to ensure they had a pick high enough to get young morton....

They will definitely go for either Morton or Palmer with the pick/picks they get from the Judd trade, if not both.
As hard as it is for the Eagles fans at the moment, they will come out of this trade very well i would think.

rexy · Post: # 457407Post **rexy** » Sun 16 Sep 2007 8:00pm

stinger wrote:i would think that the eagles would want to ensure they had a pick high enough to get young morton....

God point Stinger, so you think more like a top 3 pick and another first rounder.

Eastern · Post: # 457419Post **Eastern** » Sun 16 Sep 2007 8:06pm

rexy wrote:
stinger wrote:i would think that the eagles would want to ensure they had a pick high enough to get young morton....
God point Stinger, so you think more like a top 3 pick and another first rounder.

I thought it has already been reported that they would want 2 x top 10 picks with one of those being in the top 3-5. It very much appears that they have their eyes on Carlton's pick 3. That would add to the Morton theory !!

Armoooo · Post: # 457442Post **Armoooo** » Sun 16 Sep 2007 8:35pm

Potential Deals for our pick number 9:
Carlton: Fev and 4th rounder
Richmond: Pettifer and 2nd rounder
Melbourne: Cameron Bruce, Travis Johnstone and 4th rounder, Nathan Jones and 4th rounder
Doggies: Giansiracusa and 3rd round, Tom Williams and 2nd rounder

saintrod · Post: # 457444Post **saintrod** » Sun 16 Sep 2007 8:39pm

There is some merit in considering trading our pick 9 for a later first round pick say 13 or 14 if you could pick up an OK player as well a la Richmond did with Polak and also end up with someone like Spider junior at the dogs with your first round pick.

battye · Post: # 457445Post **battye** » Sun 16 Sep 2007 8:41pm

Pick 9 and a player (maybe a dud like Brooks) to Melbourne for Davey.

sasaint · Post: # 457571Post **sasaint** » Sun 16 Sep 2007 11:04pm

Armoooo wrote:Potential Deals for our pick number 9:
Carlton: Fev and 4th rounder
Richmond: Pettifer and 2nd rounder
Melbourne: Cameron Bruce, Travis Johnstone and 4th rounder, Nathan Jones and 4th rounder
Doggies: Giansiracusa and 3rd round, Tom Williams and 2nd rounder

of those Nathan Jones would be what I would go for. Proven gun midfielder would round out out team nicely.

woooosaints · Sun 16 Sep 2007 11:08pm

Armoooo wrote:Potential Deals for our pick number 9:
Carlton: Fev and 4th rounder
Richmond: Pettifer and 2nd rounder
Melbourne: Cameron Bruce, Travis Johnstone and 4th rounder, Nathan Jones and 4th rounder
Doggies: Giansiracusa and 3rd round, Tom Williams and 2nd rounder

LOL you are overrating pick 9

plugger66 · Post: # 457651Post **plugger66** » Mon 17 Sep 2007 12:30am

I would think for pick 9 we would get either Judd or Kerr ao both if we also gave them our second round. Lets get really tough at least Judd for pick 9.

Otiman · Post: # 457664Post **Otiman** » Mon 17 Sep 2007 12:42am

Trade Pick 9 for multiple 2nd or 3rd round picks. We need to start recruiting now for when our next lot of retirements come through.

Richter · Post: # 457690Post **Richter** » Mon 17 Sep 2007 2:21am

plugger66 wrote:I would think for pick 9 we would get either Judd or Kerr ao both if we also gave them our second round. Lets get really tough at least Judd for pick 9.

Do you think if we give them our 3rd rounder they might throw in Benny too?

Richter · Post: # 457692Post **Richter** » Mon 17 Sep 2007 2:32am

Here's a list of who has gone at pick 9 in the last 10 years.......

1997 Chad Cornes (Port Adelaide)

1998 Mark McVeigh (Essendon)

1999 Cadyn Beetham (St Kilda)

2000 Kayne Pettifer (Richmond)

2001 Luke Molan (Melbourne)

2002 Hamish McIntosh (Kangaroos)

2003 David Trotter (Kangaroos)

2004 Jordan Russell (Carlton)

2005 Mitchell Clark (Brisbane Lions)

2006 David Armitage (St Kilda)

2007 ?????????

gosaints · Post: # 457693Post **gosaints** » Mon 17 Sep 2007 2:50am

What about a scenario where Carlton gets to offer the Eagles 2 top 10 picks but get to keep pick 1 and they keep Fev...

We trade pick 9 to Carlton for Andrew Walker who is a good young player with pace.

Carlton offer picks 3, 9 and either Kennedy or Scotland for Judd.

We get a young, speedy mid who will end up a cracking player for us.

Carlton get to team Judd with Fev, Murphy, Gibbs, Pick 1, Stevens etc

Eagles get pick 3, pick 9 and either Scotland or Josh Kennedy.

Richter · Post: # 457695Post **Richter** » Mon 17 Sep 2007 2:56am

I like it for us, but reckon that Walker would command more than pick 9 (was pick 2 in 2003 draft).

Little Dozer · Mon 17 Sep 2007 5:18am

True Blue Sainter wrote:
Sam23 wrote:Pick 9 for Brent Prismall.
Pick 9 for Colin Sylvia and Demon's 3rd rounder!

Colin Sylvia!! ROFL no thanks. Already got enough duds.

saintsRrising · Mon 17 Sep 2007 11:56am

If the Blues do not trade their No 1 (which has been confirmed as being able to be traded....)

You would imagine that as WC have flafgged that as they want draft picks....that the most likely two clubs would be the Blues and Tigers each with picks 3 & 2.

But with their next picks being 20 and 18...I would imagine that a deal of

2 & 18 or even 2, 18 & 19
Or 3 and 20 are not attractive enough.
The Cats for example had to trade two good picks for Ottens....and Judd is alot more valuable than Judd.

So that either the Blues or Tigers will need to trade a player to gain another pick.

The wildcard could be Essendon if they hand over say their pick 6 PLUS Ryder and Jetta. having lost their very marketbale player in Hird the Dons would love to get Judd....plus his pace is what they need.

saintspremiers · Mon 17 Sep 2007 12:21pm

Oh When the Saints wrote:Never trade a first round pick unless the deal is heavily in your favour.

Correct.

That's exactly why we traded our first round pick (number 13?) two years back for Fergus Watts.....hmmm.......and Armitage at number 9 as yet has delivered nothing (time will tell if that's a good selection!).

Anyway, what I'm getting at is that we haven't been that good re drafting/trading in recent years, so I'm open to anything at this stage!

Saints94 · Post: # 457815Post **Saints94** » Mon 17 Sep 2007 12:24pm

trade joey for judd

True Blue Sainter · Mon 17 Sep 2007 12:25pm

homework wrote:trade joey for judd

And the Clarkes for the Cornes boys.

And Armitage to go back home for Brown

Saints94 · Post: # 457820Post **Saints94** » Mon 17 Sep 2007 12:27pm

True Blue Sainter wrote:
homework wrote:trade joey for judd
And the Clarkes for the Cornes boys.

And Armitage to go back home for Brown

good comeback

congorozides · Mon 17 Sep 2007 1:15pm

I think Judd will be going to the demons.
Pick 9 for Travis Johnstone.

congorozides · Mon 17 Sep 2007 1:17pm

Richter wrote:Here's a list of who has gone at pick 9 in the last 10 years.......

1997 Chad Cornes (Port Adelaide)

1998 Mark McVeigh (Essendon)

1999 Cadyn Beetham (St Kilda)

2000 Kayne Pettifer (Richmond)

2001 Luke Molan (Melbourne)

2002 Hamish McIntosh (Kangaroos)

2003 David Trotter (Kangaroos)

2004 Jordan Russell (Carlton)

2005 Mitchell Clark (Brisbane Lions)

2006 David Armitage (St Kilda)

2007 ?????????

Dont remind me of Caydn please...
Hamish and Chad are pretty decent players...

Saints94 · Post: # 457853Post **Saints94** » Mon 17 Sep 2007 1:19pm

congorozides wrote:
Richter wrote:Here's a list of who has gone at pick 9 in the last 10 years.......

1997 Chad Cornes (Port Adelaide)

1998 Mark McVeigh (Essendon)

1999 Cadyn Beetham (St Kilda)

2000 Kayne Pettifer (Richmond)

2001 Luke Molan (Melbourne)

2002 Hamish McIntosh (Kangaroos)

2003 David Trotter (Kangaroos)

2004 Jordan Russell (Carlton)

2005 Mitchell Clark (Brisbane Lions)

2006 David Armitage (St Kilda)

2007 ?????????
Dont remind me of Caydn please...
Hamish and Chad are pretty decent players...

what was wrong with caydn?