Saints players rated out of 100

[King Max]

On code sports. Probably Hun as well.

https://www.codesports.com.au/afl/ultim ... 22b6fcceac


Sinclair 89
Wilkie 87
Marshall 86
King 79
Steele 79
Owens 78
Wanganeen Milera 75
Crouch 73
Higgins 72
Wood 72
Hill 71
Battle 70
Howard 67
Phillipou 66
Butler 65
Ross 64
Caminiti 64
Membrey 63
Henry 62
Dow 61
Clark 57
Webster 56
Windhager 56
Jones 55
Wilson 54
Cordy 52
Stocker 51
Sharman 50
Byrnes 50
Hayes 47
Bonner 46
Heath 39
Campbell 38
Schoenmaker 33
Collard 33
Hastie 32
Hotton 31
Keeler 29
Van Es 29
Allison 28
McLennan 25
Garcia 24

[B.M]

Some of those ratings are laughable

[BadRossco]

Webster a bit hard done by, Higgins and Cordy a bit overrated and I don’t know how they can rate the new recruits this early

[diddley]

Just for reference, what are some other non saints rated at, to compare what these numbers mean.
Also, who is Batty?
And, I am looking forward to see what Wilson can do, but how is he already rated higher than the likes of Cordy and Stocker, and on par with Jones? He hasn’t played a game or even finished his first pre season.

[B.M]

It’s ridiculous

Mattaus Phillipou is rated higher than Seb Ross.

Phillipou has potential but his actual performance is nowhere near some of the senior players he was rated higher than

Other examples absurd too

[SaintWiki]

Not too bad as an opinion but I'd make some changes. Personally I would prefer to group them into individual match form, potential, consistency and overall team influence, after all it is a 'team' even if it's made up of individuals.

[Beno88]

Caminiti above Membrey is amusing.

[samoht]

Our top 30 players score 46 and above ... I wonder what the average is, and how we compare with other teams?
I can't be bothered adding the individual player ratings up and dividing by 30.

Not that it really matters ... it is just their opinion.

I think our overall strength, is our strength.

And my opinion counts.

[King Max]

Just for reference, what are some other non saints rated at, to compare what these numbers mean.
Also, who is Batty?
And, I am looking forward to see what Wilson can do, but how is he already rated higher than the likes of Cordy and Stocker, and on par with Jones? He hasn’t played a game or even finished his first pre season.

Batty was a moderator here I think.
But the correct answer is Battle.

[Mr Magic]

And I think Webster's rating is actually his jumper # (a typo?)

[King Max]

And I think Webster's rating is actually his jumper # (a typo?)

I hope it's not his IQ.
I've changed it to 56

[Life Long Saint]

And I think Webster's rating is actually his jumper # (a typo?)

Expect nothing less from the Herald-Sun, really.

[Impatient Sainter]

Its an opinion piece its difficult to see how it could be founded on any stats - so I wouldnt be getting bent out of shape over their ratings.

[AnythingsPossibleSaints]

The ratings are projections of what they think they’ll be contributing this upcoming season.

[AnythingsPossibleSaints]

It’s ridiculous

Mattaus Phillipou is rated higher than Seb Ross.

Phillipou has potential but his actual performance is nowhere near some of the senior players he was rated higher than

Other examples absurd too

They’re predicting he’ll have a big season, on that back of what they described as a “bumper summer”. Possibly a bit like the second season of the guy he’s often been compared with, Bontempelli. They’re tipping he’ll “go places in a hurry”. While I suspect they’re predicting that Seb might start getting squeezed out of the team or to the periphery, as I can also see happening. Dow is probably expected to effectively take his spot in the midfield, which could leave him very vulnerable. Especially as he only went at 50% kicking efficiency last year, according to this article.

If by some minor miracle Jones happens to play regular footy and Dow is also playing, it’s really hard to see where Seb fits.

[diddley]

Just for reference, what are some other non saints rated at, to compare what these numbers mean.
Also, who is Batty?
And, I am looking forward to see what Wilson can do, but how is he already rated higher than the likes of Cordy and Stocker, and on par with Jones? He hasn’t played a game or even finished his first pre season.

Batty was a moderator here I think.
But the correct answer is Battle.

I stared at that for ages and couldn’t figure it out.
Battle was so obvious now I know the answer.

[Yorkeys]

What's the rating scale and weighed attributes?
Oh just pulled numbers out of your arse. Fair enough.