Best Trades from other Clubs

[OldGeorgeYoung]

Just for entertainment value, I was trying to think of our best trade deals from each club.
i.e Players that have cost us something (negotiated deals) as opposed to Rookie listed or delisted.
Please abuse for obvious omitions & I'll update the post.
Adelaide Mathew Clarke
Brisbane Gram/ Voss
Carlton Hamill/ Jezza
Collingwood McGough/ Freeman
Essendon Max Crowe/ Carlisle ?
Fremantle Roberton
Geelong Fetcher/ King
Gold Coast Hickey
GWS Bruce
Hawthorn Savage/ Morris
Melbourne Wilson
North Melb Krakour/ Delaney
Port Adelaide Guerra
Richmond Barrott/ Fiora
Sydney Swans Dempster/ Membrey
West Coast Gehrig/ Gardiner
Bulldogs Luke Penny/ Ray

[BigMart]

Essendon - Max Crowe won a b&f
Geelong - Fletcher, Neal, C.Gardiner. Vegas (quality there!)
Sydney - Schneider, Danyels

[SaintPav]

Thin

[Freebird]

Melbourne - Newport

[bobmurray]

Melbourne Brian Wilson

[desertsaint]

essendon - milne.

[loris]

How far in history are you allowed to go back?

[desertsaint]

So just three really good picks from west coast, carlton, and the Swans (hopefully Bruce and Carlisle become others). Horrid in comparison to who we've let go.
Just not a destination club through our history and will not become one untl we move (is it in two seasons?) and have a sustained run at the top.

[Munga]

Membrey from Sydney

[To the top]

Russell Morris from Hawthorn

[OldGeorgeYoung]

Essendon - Max Crowe won a b&f: Agreed, good memory, Op updated
Geelong - Fletcher, Neal, C.Gardiner. Vegas (quality there!) Fletcher vs King. toss up
Sydney - Schneider, Danyels

I'll stick with Sean.

[OldGeorgeYoung]

Membrey from Sydney

Hopefully this trade will be better than Dempster within 3 years, but not just yet.

[OldGeorgeYoung]

How far in history are you allowed to go back?

Back to when you were 3 years old, so only as far back as 1970

[OldGeorgeYoung]

essendon - milne.

Tip Rat was rookie listed so didn't cost us anything.
The point of this this thread is to focus on negotiated deals to see how we've gone.

[desertsaint]

essendon - milne.

Tip Rat was rookie listed so didn't cost us anything.
The point of this this thread is to focus on negotiated deals to see how we've gone.

yep, realised that after, hence didn't include him in my second post. still, nice to know we grabbed him and they didn't.

[Scollop]

Essendon - Max Crowe won a b&f
Geelong - Fletcher, Neal, C.Gardiner. Vegas (quality there!)
Sydney - Schneider, Danyels

Sydney - Silvio Foschini

[BigMart]

Essendon - A.Lovett
Hawthorn - M.Scott
Richmond - B.Barrott or Robert Powell or Damien Ryan
North - J.Krakour or Matty Capuano
WCE - Dale Kickett
Collingwood - Tony Francis or Damien Monkhurst
Freo - Tony Delaney or Mark Gale
Brisbane - Steven Lawrence
Adelaide - Matthew Clarke
Collingwood - Mark McGough

[saynta]

Hickey gold coast

Rex hunt. Geelong.

[Wombat15]

Surely Fergus Watts from Adelaide. Barry Brooks from Port Adelaide!

[OldGeorgeYoung]

Hickey gold coast

Rex hunt. Geelong.

How could I forget Tom!
I don't think Rex cost us anything? but I'll stick witk King

[robsaint]

Adelaide Mathew Clarke
Brisbane Gram/ Voss
Carlton Hamill/ Jezza/Peter McConville/Wow Jones/Vinnie catoggio/Marcou
Collingwood McGough/ Freeman /Kink
Essendon Max Crowe/ Carlisle ?
Fremantle Roberton
Geelong Fetcher/ King/Rex Hunt/Neal
Gold Coast Hickey
GWS Bruce
Hawthorn Savage/ Morris/Mark Scott
Melbourne Wilson/Newport
North Melb P and J Krakour
Port Adelaide Guerra
Richmond Barrott/ Fiora
Sydney Swans Dempster/ Membrey/Schnider
West Coast Gehrig/ Gardiner
Bulldogs Ray

[robsaint]

Adelaide Mathew Clarke
Brisbane Gram/ Voss
Carlton Hamill/ Jezza/Peter McConville/Wow Jones/Vinnie catoggio/Marcou
Collingwood McGough/ Freeman /Kink
Essendon Max Crowe/ Carlisle ?
Fremantle Roberton\Black\ Craig Callaghan
Geelong Fetcher/ King/Rex Hunt/Neal
Gold Coast Hickey
GWS Bruce
Hawthorn Savage/ Morris/Mark Scott/Anderson
Melbourne Wilson/Newport/ Rod Keogh /Beveridge
North Melb P and J Krakour
Port Adelaide Guerra
Richmond Barrott/ Fiora
Sydney Swans Dempster/ Membrey/Schnider/ Silvio Foschini
West Coast Gehrig/ Gardiner/Paul Harding/Jason Heatley
Bulldogs Ray

[coopergrech]

Suns- MAV WELLER!

[OldGeorgeYoung]

Suns- MAV WELLER!

Mav would have been a good trade with the Suns....but de-listed & Rookie listed so didn't cost us anything

'Made his debut in Round 3 of the 2011 season and featured in the Gold Coast's first ever win over Port Adelaide.
Weller was delisted by the Suns on 2 September 2013 after playing just four games in 2013 AFL season'.

[kosifantutti]

Adelaide Mathew Clarke
Brisbane Gram/ Voss
Carlton Hamill/ Jezza/Peter McConville/Wow Jones/Vinnie catoggio/Marcou
Collingwood McGough/ Freeman /Kink
Essendon Max Crowe/ Carlisle ?
Fremantle Roberton\Black\ Craig Callaghan
Geelong Fetcher/ King/Rex Hunt/Neal
Gold Coast Hickey
GWS Bruce
Hawthorn Savage/ Morris/Mark Scott/Anderson
Melbourne Wilson/Newport/ Rod Keogh /Beveridge
North Melb P and J Krakour
Port Adelaide Guerra
Richmond Barrott/ Fiora
Sydney Swans Dempster/ Membrey/Schnider/ Silvio Foschini
West Coast Gehrig/ Gardiner/Paul Harding/Jason Heatley
Bulldogs Ray

An impressive list but I can't recall Vinny Catoggio playing with us.