Guess this weeks ins and outs

plugger66 · Post: # 1090566Post **plugger66** » Thu 16 Jun 2011 8:48am

Just for WW.

Out
Simpkin

In
Walsh

Spinner · Post: # 1090612Post **Spinner** » Thu 16 Jun 2011 12:15pm

plugger66 wrote:Just for WW.

Out
Simpkin

In
Walsh

Agreed.

Bring on TW..!

True Blue Sainter · Thu 16 Jun 2011 12:24pm

There is a thread that says "Team for Geelong" just halfway down the page...

But I agree. Think Walsh will be the one coming in for Simpkin. And I've heard some mixed mail on Monty, but one source is quite adamant he'll play.

Spinner · Post: # 1090621Post **Spinner** » Thu 16 Jun 2011 12:40pm

True Blue Sainter wrote:There is a thread that says "Team for Geelong" just halfway down the page...

But I agree. Think Walsh will be the one coming in for Simpkin. And I've heard some mixed mail on Monty, but one source is quite adamant he'll play.

This is the weekly thread. Get with it!

True Blue Sainter · Thu 16 Jun 2011 12:58pm

Spinner wrote:
True Blue Sainter wrote:There is a thread that says "Team for Geelong" just halfway down the page...

But I agree. Think Walsh will be the one coming in for Simpkin. And I've heard some mixed mail on Monty, but one source is quite adamant he'll play.

This is the weekly thread. Get with it!

Oh yeah, P66 is the author!! My bad!

Stephen Theodore · Thu 16 Jun 2011 1:42pm

No change

Eastern · Post: # 1090626Post **Eastern** » Thu 16 Jun 2011 1:44pm

I take it that no-one thinks that Joey's knee is going to come up this week !!

Dr Spaceman · Thu 16 Jun 2011 1:52pm

Eastern wrote:I take it that no-one thinks that Joey's knee is going to come up this week !!

Probably as much chance as Selwood's elbow coming up this week

White Winmar · Thu 16 Jun 2011 1:58pm

Wow! Would never have guessed that! Your degree for stating the obvious is in the mail P664.

saintspremiers · Thu 16 Jun 2011 2:11pm

Stephen Theodore wrote:No change

Boring!

Simpkin needs some Zebra time.

Lynch to replace him.

The club should announce Walsh in on Sunday morning for the following fortnight to allow half of Ireland to fly over here!

thejiggingsaint · Thu 16 Jun 2011 2:17pm

Out: Lockett

In: Rix

MCG-Unit · Post: # 1090646Post **MCG-Unit** » Thu 16 Jun 2011 3:09pm

True Blue Sainter wrote:There is a thread that says "Team for Geelong" just halfway down the page...

But I agree. Think Walsh will be the one coming in for Simpkin. And I've heard some mixed mail on Monty, but one source is quite adamant he'll play.

What about some of the other countless threads on the main board

Yes maybe Walsh or Johnson in for Simpkin - if Walsh, then he will likely have to play forward and have some time in the ruck

They should play Ledger the whole match, or send him back to Sandringham

spert · Post: # 1090651Post **spert** » Thu 16 Jun 2011 3:25pm

Geelong's main weapon is its will to win, but they still have a few questions in some positions. I think we could put a bit of pressure on by playing Roo at FF rather than CHF, and bring a strong body like Walsh into the forward line. I would lay a tag on Bartell, who is one of their most effective players under pressure. I would bring McQualter back in, just for the experience factor, and play him in the middle, not as a tagger or a defensive forward. I think Zac will hold Pods to a couple of goals. The ruck is a problem against Ottens, but McEvoy is improving all the time and will make a contest.
In:Walsh, McQualter
Out: Simpkin, Ledger

saint75 · Post: # 1090656Post **saint75** » Thu 16 Jun 2011 3:39pm

plugger66 wrote:Just for WW.

Out
Simpkin

In
Walsh

Agreed. Walsh was very close last week and only just missed the team. Would be very surprised if he didn't make it this week after another excellent performance in the VFL.

Wrote for Luck · Thu 16 Jun 2011 3:51pm

IN: Walsh, Joey
OUT: Simpkin, Ledger

Stephen Theodore · Thu 16 Jun 2011 4:10pm

saintspremiers wrote:
Stephen Theodore wrote:No change

Boring!

Simpkin needs some Zebra time.

Lynch to replace him.

The club should announce Walsh in on Sunday morning for the following fortnight to allow half of Ireland to fly over here!

Possibly so, but history says Ross does not make changes lightly, especially after a win. I'd also like to see Walsh have a run, but feel he may have to wait till after the break.

SaintPav · Post: # 1090667Post **SaintPav** » Thu 16 Jun 2011 4:22pm

In: Joey

Out: Simpkin

SainterK · Post: # 1090669Post **SainterK** » Thu 16 Jun 2011 4:34pm

In Mini Walsh
Out Baker Simpkin

St Chris · Post: # 1090671Post **St Chris** » Thu 16 Jun 2011 4:35pm

In: Walsh, Lynch, Siposs

Out: Gram, Simpkin, Gamble

Either Gram or Clarke miss for Lynch, & I'd make sure he plays at half back.

Also, I'd throw Farren Ray deep forward, has good pace and is superb overhead, surely he would give us more in the contest than Gamble does.

Although I don't think Simpkin has done a hell of a lot wrong, we can't have him and Walsh in the same side, and Walsh has earnt at least a call up, if not a decent run in the senior team.

mad saint guy · Thu 16 Jun 2011 4:37pm

SaintPav wrote:In: Joey

Out: Simpkin

I can't see us going in even smaller against Geelong. We're already a ruckman and tall forward down, dropping a tall defender means that the likes of Fisher and Gilbert can't be used anywhere else.

That said, I have no idea what changes will be made. My preference would be

Out: Simpkin - Not quite there at the moment
Gamble - Loses so many simple contests it's not funny
Gram - Doesn't have the skill to make up for his lack of physicality

In: Walsh - Mind the resting ruckman and backup Ben
Johnson - Make Scarlett accountable and bag a couple
Smith - Give some run through the midfield

bigcarl · Post: # 1090674Post **bigcarl** » Thu 16 Jun 2011 4:45pm

mad saint guy wrote:We're already a ruckman and tall forward down

Yep.

In: Johnson, Walsh
Out: Gamble, Simpkin

Old Mate · Post: # 1090676Post **Old Mate** » Thu 16 Jun 2011 4:52pm

IN: Kosi & Joey
OUT: Simpkin & Ledger

noob · Post: # 1090679Post **noob** » Thu 16 Jun 2011 5:11pm

I think Gamble will play perhaps to prove a point against the old side. So for me
Simpkin out on perhaps not running the game out.
Johnson in for being pretty consistent in the reserves.

Con Gorozidis · Thu 16 Jun 2011 5:20pm

Old Mate wrote:IN: Kosi & Joey
OUT: Simpkin & Ledger

keep your hands off the ledge buddy!!

bendigo bob · Thu 16 Jun 2011 5:28pm

If Joey doesnt come up this week changes will be

Out: Simpkin, Gamble, Gram
IN: Lynch, Walsh, Crocker

If Joey is ok to play he will come for Gram instead of Crocker

Guess this weeks ins and outs

Guess this weeks ins and outs

Re: Guess this weeks ins and outs

Re: Guess this weeks ins and outs