Paddy Concussed

[saintspremiers]

Medically speaking - how many concussions is to many before you need to take the boots off?
Is there a number?

5 sounds like a awful lot.
I would want him to be a gun, I would like to see him have success- but first i would want him to be healthy and safe.
Its his LIFE.
His so young. That is really sad.

Add to that being a Type One.

[suss]

Why doesn't he just wear a helmet?

[satchmo]

I hope that Paddy is ok.
I hope that Paddy plays again very soon.
I hope that Paddy cements a spot in the senior team.
I wish Paddy the best in everything he does.

[To the top]

The solution to St Kilda halting the fall to Grade Z in the Amateur League is to install Big Fart to the position of supreme controller of the St Kilda FC, obviously!

If North Korea will approve his transfer and St Kilda FC can afford him.

[Joffa Burns]

Ok Curley

Let's compare there numbers if you want, and ask some neutral supporters what they think?

Stone cold

Which player are we allowed to critique?
Hickey?
The ones you don't rate?
Are we allowed to have commentary on the biggest investment we've made since 2002

Well Hugh Goddard is one stonefish is happy for you to bag.
The Hugh hating, Goddard gobbling bone monkey is happy to hammer Goddard!!!!!!!!
Just don't be objective on Paddy!!!!!!!!!!!!

[stonecold]

Ok Curley

Let's compare there numbers if you want, and ask some neutral supporters what they think?

Stone cold

Which player are we allowed to critique?
Hickey?
The ones you don't rate?
Are we allowed to have commentary on the biggest investment we've made since 2002

Well Hugh Goddard is one stonefish is happy for you to bag.
The Hugh hating, Goddard gobbling bone monkey is happy to hammer Goddard!!!!!!!!
Just don't be objective on Paddy!!!!!!!!!!!!

So, Hugh has shown more than Paddy, is that right Joffa?????

Maybe stick to your day job!!!!!

Head Guru at tCCS!!!!!

[The Fireman]

His parents must be worried sick and if I were them I wouldn't let him play again

[The_President]

Just saw vision on channel 7.

What's Paddy doing, the lack of athleticism really showed.

Any other player would've kept their feet and tried to put their hands up to keep the arms free to shoot of a handball.

Clumsily goes to ground, doesn't turn to protect himself at all and just cops it.

[To the top]

Watching the footy and dabbling on here - and my wife tells me men can not do two things at the one time!

I have rested my case.

But, seriously, this forum once suffered from the recalcitrant "Plugger 66" chasing down everyone's contributions, with me for one losing any interest accordingly.

Now we appear to have multiples of "Plugger 66" - and worse.

So I am returning to doing just one thing at a time!!!

Enjoy your slagging competition.

And your lives!!!

IF you have one.

[stonecold]

Money or the box Jaffa?????

You happy to back Hughie to have a better career than Paddy, man up and speak up!!!!!

Paddy could quit tomorrow and Hughie still won't catch him at the current exchange rate, so, go your hardest, Marto needs a TagTeam partner, you interested?????

[satchmo]

ahhhh...the gangs all here!

[stonecold]

ahhhh...the gangs all here!

Not quite, missing a couple!!!!!

Bluthy and Winny to name a couple!!!!!

[stonecold]

Still haven't managed to fill that new script yet Jaffa!!!!!

[The Fireman]

ahhhh...the gangs all here!

Not quite, missing a couple!!!!!

Bluthy and Winny to name a couple!!!!!

Bluthy has disappeared what have you done with him stone , where have you hidden the body ?

[Con Gorozidis]

Paddy and Goddard are looking disastrous. I think we need to face it.

I think Elshaugh might need to be shown the door.

[stonecold]

ahhhh...the gangs all here!

Not quite, missing a couple!!!!!

Bluthy and Winny to name a couple!!!!!

Bluthy has disappeared what have you done with him stone , where have you hidden the body ?

I know Bluthy nothing about a Bluthy disappearance!!!!!

[Jacks Back]

Paddy and Goddard are looking disastrous. I think we need to face it.

I think Elshaugh might need to be shown the door.

Plus a whole 2 games from last year's new recruits (both to Long who didn't deserve them). Yep, good recruiting.

[Proph3t of egan]

Why doesn't he just wear a helmet?

If only. I'm pretty sure helmets don't stop concussions because that's when your brain rattles around your skull, not much some padding cans do to stop that. Helmets generally help with protecting the outside of your head, which is why so many Rugby Union players wear them so they don't get so much scarring when stepped on

But hey, I'm no expert

[BigMart]

So we turn our attention to the posters when we are trying to redirect, distraction is the tactic of people with no counter

How about stay on topic??

Why do some posters think they can just belittle other posters because the have a different opinion?

Is that not allowed????

Paddy is underwhelming, there you go, that's my opinion, and it's a fairly commonly held one at that... it's not outlandish

[RODOS]

and you wonder why people don't post here. place is an echo chamber for the failures in peoples own lives. Support your team involves an element of faith and hope, without it there is no point. Do something else with your time

[SMS]

Petracca

[WellardSaint]

So we turn our attention to the posters when we are trying to redirect, distraction is the tactic of people with no counter

How about stay on topic??

Why do some posters think they can just belittle other posters because the have a different opinion?

Is that not allowed????

Paddy is underwhelming, there you go, that's my opinion, and it's a fairly commonly held one at that... it's not outlandish

+1000

Demons beat WCE, dees are way ahead of us, they'll play finals while we end up in 17th spot.
Bombers have rebuilt and are heaps better than us most of this year.

The sky isn't blue, regardless of how many folk want to believe.
I'm sure RODOS is an acronym for
"Regardless Of Deficiencies- Optimistically Stupid"

[saintspremiers]

Paddy and Goddard are looking disastrous. I think we need to face it.

I think Elshaugh might need to be shown the door.

But aren't they our bookends for the next decade?

I'm sure the club in their wisdom will sign Hugh for 2018 and we will be told to be patient. Problem is you have to watch Hugh play on double speed so he's up to AFL pace.

[Joffa Burns]

Money or the box Jaffa?????

You happy to back Hughie to have a better career than Paddy, man up and speak up!!!!!

Paddy could quit tomorrow and Hughie still won't catch him at the current exchange rate, so, go your hardest, Marto needs a TagTeam partner, you interested?????

He stonefish, I don't know what TCCS is and I can't see how that has anything to do with my career as head wax pourer at Brazilian Butterfly!!!!!!!!!! Still in for your weekly B, S & C tomorrow????????????

As for tag teaming, I'm more a keys in the bowl sorta character
But each to their own, not that there is anything wrong with it.

Seriously, where have I written that Hugh will have a better career than Paddy?
My point "little fella" is that anyone who says Paddy is a bust gets invited to meet you in the Etihad carpark but you can be as negative about Hugh as you wish.

Where is the consistency fish boy? Why don't you support all the players?
Be consistent!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Why is ok to got you bag Hugh but Paddy is sacrosanct?

[jonesy]

We needed a thread like this, it evokes chapters of yesteryear on saintsational. The place has been a bit ho him the last few years