Should be on notice IMO

[WellardSaint]

I'd say on notice is/should be:


Bruce - Missing too many shots, not providing enough in the ruck - Marshall again

There's some really dumb stuff in this thread, but this wins.

lol, if you can't give a player that's not at or near his best a rocket then what can you do

but you're right, bruce on notice is overkill. What do you think about the others?

Somebody at the club needs to give Hammill 2 weeks leave,
to stop his silliness about trying to make Bwoose into a ruckman.
He is NOT a ruckman and never will be.
Let him be a marking forward FFS

[Beno88]

I'd say on notice is/should be:


Bruce - Missing too many shots, not providing enough in the ruck - Marshall again

There's some really dumb stuff in this thread, but this wins.

lol, if you can't give a player that's not at or near his best a rocket then what can you do

but you're right, bruce on notice is overkill. What do you think about the others?

Brucey is going ok. Five shots on goal, he was playing both ends of the ground, rucking, wasn't beaten in a contest and was trying to compete in the air when we were delivering the ball via the rafters inside 50. He'll be ok.

I think Paddy and JB are playing below expectation. Fortunately both are young, and we're only three games in. They may require some confidence building at Sandy, Paddy in particular. Certainly no alarm bells with either though.

Lonie has been solid and probably deserves his spot, but Sinclair or Wright would probably give us more. Long seems to be above VFL level too.

Weller and Savage are a long way off being dropped. Savage can give more, but McKenzie, White and Rice aren't banging the door down just yet. Positive signs from Rice on Sunday though.