MRP 2017

[saynta]

The melee only started after Murphy said/did something to Carlisle who was lying defenseless on the ground and could have been seriously injured for all he knew. But apparently this is our fault.

I hope they investigate that aspect of it. After all, it's what started the melee.

Both clubs have been asked to explain.

I wont give up on this until that little turd apologises.

He won't, so neither will I.

[saintbrat]

Still no news on the Mellee

But from Rd 9
http://m.afl.com.au/news/2017-05-22/mat ... round-nine

Tippett fined for striking Gears
No action on the Newnes /Mills contact

[dragit]

I think they should either suspend Cunnington for that punch to the guts off the ball or Vince for dropping like a sack…

[saintbrat]

Nothing for or against in our Rd 12 game

[saintbrat]

Rd 13
Nick R $1,000 reprimand
Has he ver had a charge before?

[kosifantutti]

Rd 13
Nick R $1,000 reprimand
Has he ver had a charge before?

He was rubbed out when some Crow ran into him many years ago.

[Mr Magic]

Rd 13
Nick R $1,000 reprimand
Has he ver had a charge before?

He was rubbed out when some Crow ran into him many years ago.

What a sniper Roo must be.
For no reason he just 'bitch thumped' Scott Thompson in the back.

I have no problem with Roo being fined for what he did
BUT the 'cheap shot' from Thompson to Roo's ribs that elicited the response didn't get mentioned?
It's not like there was no vision of what transpired.

[CURLY]

Roo should have been handed 1000 cash Thomson is a dog.

[thefatdork]

Roo should have been handed 1000 cash Thomson is a dog.

I'm with you Curly. Thompson is a thug and Cap'n Ziebel is just as bad (prob worse) - I hate the way the commentators talk of how "tough" these 2 are - when in reality they play dirty and take cheap shots. I'm never sure how they get away with all of this.
Go Saints!
TFD

[meher baba]

FWIW, Duck, Watson and Darcy last night all got stuck into the MRP for failing to do anything to Thompson.

[St Chris]

Webster 2 weeks for eye gouging

Jack S (striking) cop $1500 fines

Melee fines for Jake, Jimmy and Roberton

McCarthy 2 weeks for KO-ing Gilbo.

[Kate]

Anyone see the Webster thing?

[kosifantutti]

Anyone see the Webster thing?

Suban

[St Chris]

Anyone see the Webster thing?

I just posted in the other thread, but it was during the melee. It was what the 50m penalty was for, before they reversed it.

[Kate]

Anyone see the Webster thing?

Suban

Does that mean you saw it?

[kosifantutti]

Anyone see the Webster thing?

Suban

Does that mean you saw it?

No, but Suban must have seen it from really, really close.

[Vazelos]

Thankfully others were not rubbed out...

[SaintPav]

Anyone see the Webster thing?

Suban

Does that mean you saw it?

No, but Suban must have seen it from really, really close.

maybe not

[saintbrat]

Second fine for Jack
And is it second suspension for Jimmy?

[Jacks Back]

Anyone see the Webster thing?

Suban

Does that mean you saw it?

No, but Suban must have seen it from really, really close.

Suban went in to remonstrate with Webster optimistically but came out misty optically.

[oh when the]

Bugg suspended for six weeks

[WellardSaint]

Anyone see the Webster thing?

Suban

Does that mean you saw it?

No, but Suban must have seen it from really, really close.

Suban went in to remonstrate with Webster optimistically but came out misty optically.

[saintbrat]

Rd 16
Patrick Keane‏ @AFL_PKeane

TCotchin can accept $1500, striking JLonie

TMembrey can accept 2 games, striking DGrimes




and they will just get a bit morte from Hodgey before he goes
Patrick Keane‏ @AFL_PKeane

Luke Hodge can accept $1500 sanction, rough conduct on JCameron.

[saintbrat]

Nothing reported from Saints vs Port- Rd 19

[saintbrat]

As alluded elswhere
Luke got off tripping -rd 20

The match day report laid against St Kilda’s Luke Dunstan for tripping West Coast’s Jack Redden was assessed. It was the view of the panel the force used was below that required to constitute a reportable offence. No further action was taken.