Who could we Trade Leigh Fisher for?

Batnoe · Post: # 473570Post **Batnoe** » Thu 11 Oct 2007 10:56pm

On the basis that we happen to sign Schneider and Dempster for pick 26 and there is no leigh Fisher involved who can we get with him.

At the start i didnt want to see it happen but now, i am liking to the idea if we can get anyone for him

Would the Lions look at him for Richard Hadley, now that they have Johnstone?

ausfatcat · Post: # 473571Post **ausfatcat** » Thu 11 Oct 2007 10:57pm

should be able to get cox and kerr for him.

SaintBot · Post: # 473572Post **SaintBot** » Thu 11 Oct 2007 10:57pm

If we dont have to trade him then dont...

Fisher for Hadley is a win for Brisbane

The_Dud · Post: # 473573Post **The_Dud** » Thu 11 Oct 2007 10:58pm

i'm more than happy with keeping him

plugger66 · Post: # 473574Post **plugger66** » Thu 11 Oct 2007 10:58pm

Batnoe wrote:On the basis that we happen to sign Schneider and Dempster for pick 26 and there is no leigh Fisher involved who can we get with him.

At the start i didnt want to see it happen but now, i am liking to the idea if we can get anyone for him

Would the Lions look at him for Richard Hadley, now that they have Johnstone?

I think Carlton will get Hadley.

saintbrat · Post: # 473575Post **saintbrat** » Thu 11 Oct 2007 10:58pm

NO One- KEEP HIM

thank goodness only 16 hours of this madness left., Bring on 2 pm

)

Batnoe · Post: # 473576Post **Batnoe** » Thu 11 Oct 2007 10:59pm

What about Leigh Brown?

Full forward?

CeilidhSaint · Thu 11 Oct 2007 11:02pm

Batnoe out, Fisher in.
Perhaps we'll shift you out of your work, school, city, Uni where your friends and family are to a different place to where you know no one.
St Kilda is about loyalty.
We demand it from our players, but when it suits us, well bad luck, right?!

Batnoe · Post: # 473589Post **Batnoe** » Thu 11 Oct 2007 11:04pm

CeilidhSaint wrote:Batnoe out, Fisher in.
Perhaps we'll shift you out of your work, school, city, Uni where your friends and family are to a different place to where you know no one.
St Kilda is about loyalty.
We demand it from our players, but when it suits us, well bad luck, right?!

Fair enough

I am just floating the question

If you read it i said 'IF'

Also many people are saying if we have to do it for part of the Schneider and Dempster trade, plus pick 26, do it

What if we have a spare Leigh Fisher that we can trade, i was asking who would you be happy to trade him for. I am not a Fisher bagger, however if we could get something for him, we would def entertain the idea

CeilidhSaint · Thu 11 Oct 2007 11:12pm

I don't see much "if" in what you wrote at all! The "if" relates to you basically saying get whoever we can from any team even if they are cast offs.
"Who can we get with him?"
Please check the English translation of your signature - might make interesting reading for you or are you trying to be ironic??

Who could we Trade Leigh Fisher for?
On the basis that we happen to sign Schneider and Dempster for pick 26 and there is no leigh Fisher involved who can we get with him.

At the start i didnt want to see it happen but now, i am liking to the idea if we can get anyone for him

Would the Lions look at him for Richard Hadley, now that they have Johnstone?[/color]

Batnoe · Post: # 473604Post **Batnoe** » Thu 11 Oct 2007 11:23pm

Strength Through Loyalty!!!

You don't think i know what it means...

I think Strength through Loyalty is -winning flags

If we can get someone for Leigh that will take us to a flag i would be happy to trade him. If we don't have to trade him to Sydney, that is a bonus and is prob equivalent to a 2nd round pick if it were to be Fisher- Schneider trade, which it wont be, we then have a player to trade if we need it....

Who else out of our line up is worth anything on the trade table? No one!

This is football, which is life and they know that, you think Schneider had a choice on where he wants to go? he was contracted for 2 years...thought he was safe...obviously not.. that is the game and that is what happens in football. What about the Kennedy debacle? He didn't originally want to go, but did.

The question is, i repeat, if he is not part of the Sydney trade, (bonus) what can we get for him or what would we need off another team to let him go. I would love to keep him, but he is replaceable.

Oh and by the way, please check the English translation for your name ceilidhsaint

what is that!!

CeilidhSaint · Thu 11 Oct 2007 11:29pm

Strength through loyalty means you become stronger by being loyal.
Trevor Barker was a fine example of that - it is not just about winning, he never won us a flag but he was everything good about Football Clubs....and I wasn't aware Batnoe was in the dictionary.

Batnoe · Post: # 473614Post **Batnoe** » Thu 11 Oct 2007 11:29pm

Well if we cant win a flag with that slogan- lets change it!

CeilidhSaint · Thu 11 Oct 2007 11:33pm

Better suggest some then - perhaps start a new thread!!!
Win the Cup or Die Trying perhaps!

stinger · Post: # 473620Post **stinger** » Thu 11 Oct 2007 11:33pm

saintbrat wrote:NO One- KEEP HIM

thank goodness only 16 hours of this madness left., Bring on 2 pm )

amen brother amen....

Otiman · Post: # 473634Post **Otiman** » Thu 11 Oct 2007 11:43pm

In all honesty, he's worth about pick 30-35. I'd prefer to keep him though. He is developing well as a defensive mid. Some time with Gilbo in tackle school will do him a world of good.

chook23 · Post: # 473787Post **chook23** » Fri 12 Oct 2007 10:32am

Did Leigh Fisher fail a medical test arranged by the Swans?

Was it based on his hamstrings??

yipper · Post: # 473825Post **yipper** » Fri 12 Oct 2007 11:05am

chook23 wrote:Did Leigh Fisher fail a medical test arranged by the Swans?

Was it based on his hamstrings??

I've heard no he didn't fail any fitness exam - he just did not want to be part fo any trade. Does not want to leave St.Kilda period.

chook23 · Post: # 473826Post **chook23** » Fri 12 Oct 2007 11:07am

yipper wrote:
chook23 wrote:Did Leigh Fisher fail a medical test arranged by the Swans?

Was it based on his hamstrings??
I've heard no he didn't fail any fitness exam - he just did not want to be part fo any trade. Does not want to leave St.Kilda period.

confirmed by Greg Denham on SEN just after I typed.

saintspremiers · Fri 12 Oct 2007 11:08am

stinger wrote:
saintbrat wrote:NO One- KEEP HIM

thank goodness only 16 hours of this madness left., Bring on 2 pm )
amen brother amen....

nah, I love trade week.....players like horse meat, it's great as a fan IMO, hate to be a player though.

Every player is tradeable......I'd trade Rooey even if the incentive was enormous (but that wouldn't happen in reality, plus Rooey wouldn't go back to Brisbane for a $6 million dollar deal and pretend it's just because he's "homesick")

Dan Warna · Post: # 473845Post **Dan Warna** » Fri 12 Oct 2007 11:27am

chook23 wrote:
yipper wrote:
chook23 wrote:Did Leigh Fisher fail a medical test arranged by the Swans?

Was it based on his hamstrings??
I've heard no he didn't fail any fitness exam - he just did not want to be part fo any trade. Does not want to leave St.Kilda period.
confirmed by Greg Denham on SEN just after I typed.

good on him.

The story of 26+fish just goes to show you how much we would have lost out on the trade given sydney were willing to unload for just pick 26!

Sobraz · Post: # 473848Post **Sobraz** » Fri 12 Oct 2007 11:31am

Good on Fish for sticking strong and wanting to stay a siant.. why wouldnt he... Im rapt he is staying, and wouldnt trade look to trade him unless it was slanted heavily in our favour... We must keep the core of our younge players and just build on it, as we have done with the schnider trade..

chook23 · Post: # 473849Post **chook23** » Fri 12 Oct 2007 11:32am

Dan Warna wrote:
chook23 wrote:
yipper wrote:
chook23 wrote:Did Leigh Fisher fail a medical test arranged by the Swans?

Was it based on his hamstrings??
I've heard no he didn't fail any fitness exam - he just did not want to be part fo any trade. Does not want to leave St.Kilda period.
confirmed by Greg Denham on SEN just after I typed.
good on him.

The story of 26+fish just goes to show you how much we would have lost out on the trade given sydney were willing to unload for just pick 26!

Confirmation was in relation to failed medical test by Leigh...

Don't know what it was though.

PLUGGER14 · Post: # 473850Post **PLUGGER14** » Fri 12 Oct 2007 11:32am

stinger wrote:
saintbrat wrote:NO One- KEEP HIM

thank goodness only 16 hours of this madness left., Bring on 2 pm )
amen brother amen....

maybe amen sister amen

chook23 · Post: # 473852Post **chook23** » Fri 12 Oct 2007 11:36am

Sobraz wrote:Good on Fish for sticking strong and wanting to stay a siant.. why wouldnt he... Im rapt he is staying, and wouldnt trade look to trade him unless it was slanted heavily in our favour... We must keep the core of our younge players and just build on it, as we have done with the schnider trade..

He may have infact been on his way to Sydney.

Failed Sydney medical according to Denham on SEN.

Who could we Trade Leigh Fisher for?

Who could we Trade Leigh Fisher for?

Re: Who could we Trade Leigh Fisher for?