does Judd to the blues help our chance of ending up with fev

dborsky · Post: # 468631Post **dborsky** » Wed 03 Oct 2007 1:30am

i too heard that apparently we weren't interested in him.

but the facts remain;

1 - We could certainly use a talented full forward

2 - Judd is going to the blues

3 - they have said they won't give up pick one, the result of which is that they will most probably need to trade for another pick in the top 10

4 - Fev has clearly been unhappy there

5 - When you break it down objectively, he's worth about pick 9

Thoughts?

The_Dud · Post: # 468633Post **The_Dud** » Wed 03 Oct 2007 1:32am

why wouldn't they cut out the middle man and trade Fev straight to WC?

i hear West Coast are interested in him, so its pointless trading him to us for pick 9, then pick 9 to WC

SaintBot · Post: # 468635Post **SaintBot** » Wed 03 Oct 2007 1:33am

im pretty sure it will be a straight swap of pick 3, 2nd round pick and Josh Kennedy (wa boy) for judd

dborsky · Post: # 468637Post **dborsky** » Wed 03 Oct 2007 1:40am

The_Dud wrote:why wouldn't they cut out the middle man and trade Fev straight to WC?

i hear West Coast are interested in him, so its pointless trading him to us for pick 9, then pick 9 to WC

with big Q up and running, Hunter around to help him out with Seaby or even Hansen as a third tall forward, i would be surprised if they were genuinely interested in another middle aged loose cannon to give them more headaches

dborsky · Post: # 468638Post **dborsky** » Wed 03 Oct 2007 1:41am

but i'd take him happily

Brian Collis · Wed 03 Oct 2007 7:03am

SaintBot wrote:im pretty sure it will be a straight swap of pick 3, 2nd round pick and Josh Kennedy (wa boy) for judd

No 1 pick will have to be involved otherwise Juddy will be at Richmond. That I have no doubt. How dare the Baggers say no 1 is off the table when you're talking about a potential great playing at your club. Judd is worth 2 Marc Murphys and 3 Bryce Gibbs.

saintly · Post: # 468675Post **saintly** » Wed 03 Oct 2007 8:45am

carlton greg swan said last night on 3aw that fevolva would be staying!

saintsRrising · Wed 03 Oct 2007 10:59am

Deal will end up being 3, 20 and Kenndey....

Ratten likes Fev...so he is staying...

Besides for ket forwards we have options in Kois, allen, watts...

We have more pressing needs; mids/ small to medium forward /ruckman full back

Animal Enclosure · Wed 03 Oct 2007 11:08am

Has everyone forgotten that Greg Swan will be using the "How to trade the Collingwood Way" handbook???

There is no doubt that Judd is worth No 1. Carlton would be smarter to say, you can have No.1 and Kennedy but we're keeping pick 3. That will still get them a Cotchin (WC will take Morton, Tigers Kreuzer). Carlton will have to ask themselves, 'Do we rate Matthew Kreuzer over Chris Judd?'

We all know the answer to that...especially if Kreuzer turns into another Josh Fraser.

Ghost Like · Wed 03 Oct 2007 11:09am

saintly wrote:carlton greg swan said last night on 3aw that fevolva would be staying!

Thank god for that!

We do have more pressing needs as stated above. We need to have a little faith in what we've got, this years draft and picking up a couple of disgruntled players from other clubs that won't cost us high draft picks in a draft year that is not as deep or obvious as previous years.

GrumpyOne · Post: # 468714Post **GrumpyOne** » Wed 03 Oct 2007 11:11am

does Judd to the blues help our chance of ending up with fev?

Like we want the turd?

Dan Warna · Post: # 468724Post **Dan Warna** » Wed 03 Oct 2007 11:23am

wouldn't mind a midfielder of youth and talent for pick 9, or a quality young ruckman.

3 and 20 isn't enough IMO.

1 and 3 is what they are after

3 and 9 might go for it.

Snakeman66 · Wed 03 Oct 2007 11:41am

GrumpyOne wrote:
does Judd to the blues help our chance of ending up with fev?
Like we want the turd?

Ditto