frawley for pick 9?

Saints Premiers 2008 · Fri 28 Sep 2007 8:21pm

seems like a blast from the past here

would you take it???

personally i wouldnt considering we already have gilbo as a frawley type player..

our kpp's are our major strength

Rooy_coin · Post: # 465710Post **Rooy_coin** » Fri 28 Sep 2007 8:22pm

i agree with you mate

Lynch Beast · Fri 28 Sep 2007 8:27pm

Frawley is a genuine full back & as far as I'm aware the deal will be done.

Compares more than favourably to Darren Glass at the same age & is an awesome spoiler with very good pace.

ausfatcat · Post: # 465715Post **ausfatcat** » Fri 28 Sep 2007 8:30pm

Lynch Beast wrote:Frawley is a genuine full back & as far as I'm aware the deal will be done.

Compares more than favourably to Darren Glass at the same age & is an awesome spoiler with very good pace.

then why would they trade him????

mad saint guy · Fri 28 Sep 2007 8:31pm

ausfatcat wrote:then why would they trade him????

Picks for Judd

ausfatcat · Post: # 465717Post **ausfatcat** » Fri 28 Sep 2007 8:33pm

just realised he's at Melbourne, because lynch responed presumed he was from WestCoast.

taken pick 12 in the super draft.....

Also on the nostalgia side a frawley at full back again.......

claystreet · Post: # 465718Post **claystreet** » Fri 28 Sep 2007 8:34pm

Pick 9 for Tony Lockett then
if we are talking frawley era

Otiman · Post: # 465719Post **Otiman** » Fri 28 Sep 2007 8:34pm

As long as we aren't suckered in by the name.

Rooy_coin · Post: # 465723Post **Rooy_coin** » Fri 28 Sep 2007 8:43pm

mad saint guy wrote:
ausfatcat wrote:then why would they trade him????
Picks for Judd

we wont get judd

BelfastSaint · Fri 28 Sep 2007 8:45pm

Apparantly the Frawley rumour is quite strong ........Dont know anything about him...Is he worth pick 9.....?

Rooy_coin · Post: # 465726Post **Rooy_coin** » Fri 28 Sep 2007 8:46pm

BelfastSaint wrote:Apparantly the Frawley rumour is quite strong ........Dont know anything about him...Is he worth pick 9.....?

IMO no

saintsRrising · Fri 28 Sep 2007 8:47pm

Rooy_coin wrote:
mad saint guy wrote:
ausfatcat wrote:then why would they trade him????
Picks for Judd
we wont get judd

he means tha the Dees swap Frawley for 9 from us and on trade it with pick 4 plus a player or another pick for Judd

Rooy_coin · Post: # 465729Post **Rooy_coin** » Fri 28 Sep 2007 8:48pm

saintsRrising wrote:
Rooy_coin wrote:
mad saint guy wrote:
ausfatcat wrote:then why would they trade him????
Picks for Judd
we wont get judd
he means tha the Dees swap Frawley for 9 from us and on trade it with pick 4 plus a player or another pick for Judd

oh ok thanks i must have read it wrong

Otiman · Post: # 465730Post **Otiman** » Fri 28 Sep 2007 8:49pm

BelfastSaint wrote:Apparantly the Frawley rumour is quite strong ........Dont know anything about him...Is he worth pick 9.....?

Was Pick 12 in last years draft.

Rooy_coin · Post: # 465733Post **Rooy_coin** » Fri 28 Sep 2007 8:51pm

Otiman wrote:
BelfastSaint wrote:Apparantly the Frawley rumour is quite strong ........Dont know anything about him...Is he worth pick 9.....?
Was Pick 12 in last years draft.

really? still dont think we need him in the team

rexy · Post: # 465734Post **rexy** » Fri 28 Sep 2007 8:51pm

Would want more than just Frawley for 9. Frawley and Silvia for 9 I would take. Melbourne need this pick we should play hardball.

SaintBot · Post: # 465735Post **SaintBot** » Fri 28 Sep 2007 8:53pm

Otiman wrote:
BelfastSaint wrote:Apparantly the Frawley rumour is quite strong ........Dont know anything about him...Is he worth pick 9.....?
Was Pick 12 in last years draft.

which was considerably stronger than this years draft...

i havnt seen enough of him to comment but if he is a gilbo type player then id trade pick 9 for frawley + 3rd/4th rounder

up to our recruiting officers...do they think we will get a better player with pick 9?

Richter · Post: # 465739Post **Richter** » Fri 28 Sep 2007 8:59pm

We can't get him if he was taken last year. Minimum 2 years at the first club AFAIK.

SaintBot · Post: # 465741Post **SaintBot** » Fri 28 Sep 2007 9:02pm

Richter wrote:We can't get him if he was taken last year. Minimum 2 years at the first club AFAIK.

minimum contract is two years...not sure if it is compulsury to stay at the club if they are happy to trade you

Eastern · Post: # 465750Post **Eastern** » Fri 28 Sep 2007 9:16pm

Richter wrote:We can't get him if he was taken last year. Minimum 2 years at the first club AFAIK.

Can Trade

Cannot delist

!!

SaintBot · Post: # 465751Post **SaintBot** » Fri 28 Sep 2007 9:18pm

Eastern wrote:
Richter wrote:We can't get him if he was taken last year. Minimum 2 years at the first club AFAIK.
Can Trade

Cannot delist

!!

can delist but have to pay out the contract...austin lucy or something like that was delisted from essendon after one year

ben_fff · Post: # 465752Post **ben_fff** » Fri 28 Sep 2007 9:18pm

rexy wrote:Would want more than just Frawley for 9. Frawley and Silvia for 9 I would take. Melbourne need this pick we should play hardball.

Yeah I'm sure the Dees would do this trade for pick 9.

SaintBot · Post: # 465754Post **SaintBot** » Fri 28 Sep 2007 9:21pm

ben_fff wrote:
rexy wrote:Would want more than just Frawley for 9. Frawley and Silvia for 9 I would take. Melbourne need this pick we should play hardball.
Yeah I'm sure the Dees would do this trade for pick 9.

is this sarcasm?

im not sure...im not good at judging trades, im always to biased towards making sure we end up with a better deal

but i reckon we are in a stronger negotiating position than melbourne

btw where was this rumour made? or is this just the view of saints premiers 2006?

rexy · Post: # 465755Post **rexy** » Fri 28 Sep 2007 9:22pm

ben_fff wrote:
rexy wrote:Would want more than just Frawley for 9. Frawley and Silvia for 9 I would take. Melbourne need this pick we should play hardball.
Yeah I'm sure the Dees would do this trade for pick 9.

Its not for pick 9 really, its for Chris Judd

Lynch Beast · Fri 28 Sep 2007 9:28pm

I would think it also involves west coast 2nd round pick (29 i think) going to you boys.

Out

West Coast : Chris Judd, Pick 29

Melbourne: Pick 4, Pick 21, James Frawley

St Kilda: Pick 9

In

West Coast : Pick 4, Pick 9, Pick 21 (already have Pick 13)

Melbourne: Chris Judd

St Kilda : James Frawley, Pick 29