Judd leaving Eagles, SEN confirmed - discussion

This unofficial St Kilda Saints fan forum is for people of all ages to chat Saints Footy and all posts must be respectful.

Moderators: Saintsational Administrators, Saintsational Moderators

Post Reply
fisher_fan
Club Player
Posts: 105
Joined: Mon 03 Sep 2007 12:59am

Judd leaving Eagles, SEN confirmed - discussion

Post: # 456956Post fisher_fan »

Read in the Sun today its looking more and more likely Judd will be coming back to Vic. Although its irrelevant to the Saints I was just wondering what team you think will snap him up and how?

This is my guess....

Bulldogs Receive - Brendan Fevola
Eagles Receive - Kennedy, Pick 3 (Carlton) , Pick 6 (Bulldogs)
Carlton Receive - Chris Judd


plugger66
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 50626
Joined: Mon 26 Feb 2007 8:15pm
Location: oakleigh

Re: Judd trade

Post: # 456960Post plugger66 »

fisher_fan wrote:Read in the Sun today its looking more and more likely Judd will be coming back to Vic. Although its irrelevant to the Saints I was just wondering what team you think will snap him up and how?

This is my guess....

Bulldogs Receive - Brendan Fevola
Eagles Receive - Kennedy, Pick 3 (Carlton) , Pick 6 (Bulldogs)
Carlton Receive - Chris Judd
So Carlton lose pick 3 and Fevola. that will not happen.


User avatar
Dan Warna
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 12846
Joined: Tue 09 Mar 2004 12:56am
Location: melbourne

Post: # 456962Post Dan Warna »

asking price for judd 1.2m p/a
WCE want 2 round 1 draft picks one in the top 5.

and a better than gop ready to play ><


Bewaire krime, da krimson bolt is comeing to yure nayborhood to smach krime

SHUT UP KRIME!
plugger66
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 50626
Joined: Mon 26 Feb 2007 8:15pm
Location: oakleigh

Post: # 456965Post plugger66 »

Dan Warna wrote:asking price for judd 1.2m p/a
WCE want 2 round 1 draft picks one in the top 5.

and a better than gop ready to play ><
The problem with that is he can go to Richmond for nothing if they ask for to much.


fisher_fan
Club Player
Posts: 105
Joined: Mon 03 Sep 2007 12:59am

Post: # 456969Post fisher_fan »

Probably the biggest name in the AFL right now though. They won't give up Kreuzer to get him and Dogs have apparently been talking to Fev. I see it as the only way to get him......I don't think that they have enough trade bait other than Fev to get a first round pick. Big name would come at a big price. Herald Sun says $5 Mil for 5 years....


User avatar
Dan Warna
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 12846
Joined: Tue 09 Mar 2004 12:56am
Location: melbourne

Post: # 456977Post Dan Warna »

i hope he does go to carlton.

they can't afford to legitimately keep him.

also if he does go, he will be battling OP.

he is a fantastic player, but can't win matches on his own.

carlton will be a few percent better as a team, but thats about it.


Bewaire krime, da krimson bolt is comeing to yure nayborhood to smach krime

SHUT UP KRIME!
User avatar
evertonfc
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 7260
Joined: Mon 08 Mar 2004 9:11pm
Location: 'Quietly Confident' County
Has thanked: 115 times
Been thanked: 267 times
Contact:

Re: Judd trade

Post: # 456984Post evertonfc »

fisher_fan wrote:Read in the Sun today its looking more and more likely Judd will be coming back to Vic. Although its irrelevant to the Saints I was just wondering what team you think will snap him up and how?

This is my guess....

Bulldogs Receive - Brendan Fevola
Eagles Receive - Kennedy, Pick 3 (Carlton) , Pick 6 (Bulldogs)
Carlton Receive - Chris Judd
Not the *worst* I've seen, I'll say that much.

I think most parties would be quite happy with that...if Judd wanted to leave, that is.


Clueless and mediocre petty tyrant.

Image
User avatar
Animal Enclosure
SS Hall of Fame
Posts: 2364
Joined: Mon 04 Apr 2005 2:37pm
Location: Saints Footy Central

Post: # 456986Post Animal Enclosure »

I don't reckon he'll leave after the disappointing year than he's had.

If he'd had another ripping year & another premiership... maybe. I just reckon he'll feel he owes his mates to give it another crack with that group.

My tip is he'll be back in Melb after his next contract, 2010.


vacuous space
SS Life Member
Posts: 3465
Joined: Fri 29 Oct 2004 1:01pm
Has thanked: 91 times
Been thanked: 162 times

Post: # 456998Post vacuous space »

Why Kennedy? West Coast already have Hansen and Lynch up forward, and they got Mitch Brown in the 06 draft, who so far has looked better than Kennedy has. If anything, West Coast would want a midfielder if they're losing Judd.


User avatar
evertonfc
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 7260
Joined: Mon 08 Mar 2004 9:11pm
Location: 'Quietly Confident' County
Has thanked: 115 times
Been thanked: 267 times
Contact:

Post: # 457000Post evertonfc »

vacuous space wrote:Why Kennedy? West Coast already have Hansen and Lynch up forward, and they got Mitch Brown in the 06 draft, who so far has looked better than Kennedy has. If anything, West Coast would want a midfielder if they're losing Judd.
Well then they could on-trade Kennedy + a top pick to Collingwood for Didak, who could be on-traded for Van Berlo + a mid-range pick.

...or thereabouts :wink:


Clueless and mediocre petty tyrant.

Image
midas_touch
Club Player
Posts: 1636
Joined: Wed 29 Mar 2006 5:24pm
Location: Sunshine, Vic

Post: # 457008Post midas_touch »

Don't think Judd will go anywhere IMO, although the Blues have some good bargaining power.


Trust the Midas Touch

"My heart is at St.Kilda, I've been here seven years, I only wanted to play for them." (Fraser Gehrig, 27/11/2007)
User avatar
Brian Collis
Club Player
Posts: 1353
Joined: Thu 06 May 2004 2:47pm
Location: Light her up babe

Post: # 457009Post Brian Collis »

fisher_fan wrote:Probably the biggest name in the AFL right now though. They won't give up Kreuzer to get him and Dogs have apparently been talking to Fev. I see it as the only way to get him......I don't think that they have enough trade bait other than Fev to get a first round pick. Big name would come at a big price. Herald Sun says $5 Mil for 5 years....
You can't trade away a priority pick.


fisher_fan
Club Player
Posts: 105
Joined: Mon 03 Sep 2007 12:59am

Post: # 457046Post fisher_fan »

vacuous space wrote:Why Kennedy? West Coast already have Hansen and Lynch up forward, and they got Mitch Brown in the 06 draft, who so far has looked better than Kennedy has. If anything, West Coast would want a midfielder if they're losing Judd.
Sheehan reported the were more likely to use him as bait to get Judd than there first pick. Kennedy is from East Fremantle, just thought id throw him in there.....


User avatar
meher baba
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 6873
Joined: Mon 14 Aug 2006 6:49am
Location: Tasmania
Has thanked: 1 time
Been thanked: 405 times

Post: # 457088Post meher baba »

Surely Carlton will do whatever it takes to get their hands on Judd. Where there's a will there's a way. So I reckon it's highly likely to happen.

The statements from the WCE today seemed to me to be broadly accepting that this is what is going to happen. They know he is not right physically, and would be happy to let him go at the right price. I reckon that Carlton might be able to do a slightly better deal than 2 draft picks in the top 5, given Judd's injury problems. Certainly, I don't see getting rid of big Fev as a forward step: you'd want both Judd and Fev.

Carlton is the one club that probably be too bothered about how fit Judd actually is. Recruiting Judd, even if he doesn't get out on the field fully fit during 2008, sends a signal to the football world and the members that the new regime at Carlton is serious about restoring the club to its "rightful" place at the top of the league. If I were in charge of the Blues, I would throw everything bar the kitchen sink at getting him.

I certainly don't think the Saints should even spend 10 seconds thinking about getting involved. We can't afford him without taking out other irreplacable players.


"It is useless to attempt to reason a man out of a thing he was never reasoned into."
- Jonathan Swift
User avatar
Unforgiven
SS Life Member
Posts: 3258
Joined: Wed 23 Feb 2005 9:48pm
Location: Full Forward

Post: # 457098Post Unforgiven »

I don't see why Judd would want to go to Carlton, Where is the appeal?. If it'd be smart to go to a there abouts team like Kangroo's, Hawks. Who are young and already going well.


Carpe Diem
User avatar
milnedog
Club Player
Posts: 1635
Joined: Fri 03 Dec 2004 11:21am
Location: Melbourne

Re: Judd trade

Post: # 457121Post milnedog »

fisher_fan wrote:Read in the Sun today its looking more and more likely Judd will be coming back to Vic. Although its irrelevant to the Saints I was just wondering what team you think will snap him up and how?

This is my guess....

Bulldogs Receive - Brendan Fevola
Eagles Receive - Kennedy, Pick 3 (Carlton) , Pick 6 (Bulldogs)
Carlton Receive - Chris Judd
Bulldogs would win there, pick 6 for fev.
WOuld have to be a better player than kennedy.


BROWNLOW: DalSanto 06, Ball 08, Riewoldt 07, Ball + Dal + ROO tie 09.
True Blue Sainter
Club Player
Posts: 1906
Joined: Fri 19 Mar 2004 5:47pm
Has thanked: 4 times
Been thanked: 17 times

Post: # 457125Post True Blue Sainter »

Another thing is also, would the Blues be willing to trade their most likely replacement for Fevola?


The Saints are coming!
Batnoe

Post: # 457126Post Batnoe »

Simon Black to Eagles and 2nd round pick


Chris Judd to Blues


Lions get off the Blues their 2 first picks


Bulldogs then offer pick 6 for Fevola


Lions in pick 3 and 19, out Black and pick 24

Eagles in Black and pick 24, out Judd

Blues, in Judd and pick 6, out picks 3, 19 and Fevola

Dogs, out pick 6 in fevola


User avatar
Eastern
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 14357
Joined: Tue 09 Mar 2004 1:46pm
Location: 3132
Been thanked: 1 time

Post: # 457127Post Eastern »

I noticed that Daniel Harford on SEN was trying to boost the value of Fevola by saying that the saints could be interested in him !!


User avatar
meher baba
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 6873
Joined: Mon 14 Aug 2006 6:49am
Location: Tasmania
Has thanked: 1 time
Been thanked: 405 times

Post: # 457130Post meher baba »

Saint Corin wrote:I don't see why Judd would want to go to Carlton, Where is the appeal?. If it'd be smart to go to a there abouts team like Kangroo's, Hawks. Who are young and already going well.
He's already won a premiership. Helping turn Carlton around would be a new and exciting challenge for him. And the Blues would build a team around him, rather than expect him to fit in to existing plans.

Also, I suspect he has significant ambitions beyond football, and playing for Carlton is better pathway to these than playing for the likes of the Roos or Hawks.


"It is useless to attempt to reason a man out of a thing he was never reasoned into."
- Jonathan Swift
User avatar
stinger
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 38126
Joined: Tue 09 Mar 2004 9:06pm
Location: Australia.

Post: # 457174Post stinger »

pagan reckons that he would cost the blues their no1 and 3 picks.....also they are prepared to pay 7.5 mil over 5 years...hope they sign him for that...then hope that he doesn't get out on the park...would be called karma..for all the sh!t we have had to put up with from the scummers for signing hamill to a five year deal.....


.everybody still loves lenny....and we always will

"Freedom of expression is the cornerstone of a free society,"

However, freedom of expression is not encouraged in certain forums.
User avatar
locoplayaz
Club Player
Posts: 395
Joined: Wed 10 May 2006 8:17pm
Location: Melbourne

Post: # 457176Post locoplayaz »

C.JUDD to (ST.K)
BLUES 3RD ROUND PICK to (ST.K)

WB 1ST ROUND PICK to (WCE)
ST.K 1ST ROUND PICK to (WCE)

M.MAGUIRE to (BLUES)
ST.K 2ND ROUND PICK to (BLUES)

WCE 3RD ROUND PICK to (WB)
B.FEVOLA to (WB)

______________________________

WCE - GET 2 TOP 10 PICKS, LOSE JUDD + 3RD ROUND PICK

ST.K - GET JUDD + 3RD ROUND PICK, LOSE MAGUIRE + 1ST & 2ND ROUND PICKS

BLUES - GET M.MAGUIRE + 2ND ROUND PICK, LOSE FEVOLA AND 3RD ROUND PICK

WB - GET FEVOLA + 3RD ROUND PICK, LOSE 1ST ROUND PICK


User avatar
stinger
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 38126
Joined: Tue 09 Mar 2004 9:06pm
Location: Australia.

Post: # 457183Post stinger »

locoplayaz wrote:C.JUDD to (ST.K)
BLUES 3RD ROUND PICK to (ST.K)

WB 1ST ROUND PICK to (WCE)
ST.K 1ST ROUND PICK to (WCE)

M.MAGUIRE to (BLUES)
ST.K 2ND ROUND PICK to (BLUES)

WCE 3RD ROUND PICK to (WB)
B.FEVOLA to (WB)

______________________________

WCE - GET 2 TOP 10 PICKS, LOSE JUDD + 3RD ROUND PICK

ST.K - GET JUDD + 3RD ROUND PICK, LOSE MAGUIRE + 1ST & 2ND ROUND PICKS

BLUES - GET M.MAGUIRE + 2ND ROUND PICK, LOSE FEVOLA AND 3RD ROUND PICK

WB - GET FEVOLA + 3RD ROUND PICK, LOSE 1ST ROUND PICK

i would think that wet toast would want a lower pick than that...or two lower picks.....judd is the premier player in the competition....


.everybody still loves lenny....and we always will

"Freedom of expression is the cornerstone of a free society,"

However, freedom of expression is not encouraged in certain forums.
User avatar
Oh When the Saints
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 5621
Joined: Wed 29 Mar 2006 4:25pm
Location: QLD
Contact:

Post: # 457185Post Oh When the Saints »

Bulldogs do far too well out of that trade, and Carlton don't get nearly enough.

Carlton effectively get Goose for Fev. That's never going to happen.


They should only play AFL games now when it's raining. Slow games of footy are so much better to watch.
User avatar
evertonfc
Saintsational Legend
Posts: 7260
Joined: Mon 08 Mar 2004 9:11pm
Location: 'Quietly Confident' County
Has thanked: 115 times
Been thanked: 267 times
Contact:

Post: # 457187Post evertonfc »

Eastern wrote:I noticed that Daniel Harford on SEN was trying to boost the value of Fevola by saying that the saints could be interested in him !!
Of course we're interested. We may not pursue that interest, however.

As much as we'd like to get him, other clubs will offer more, and our priority will be getting a ruckman, allowing Kosi to play FF full-time and develop Fergus Watts as well.


Clueless and mediocre petty tyrant.

Image
Post Reply