M.Voss all Australian Side

sainter58 · Post: # 440560Post **sainter58** » Thu 23 Aug 2007 3:58pm

Does Not include any saints.
And i thought he knew something about football.

Saints94 · Post: # 440561Post **Saints94** » Thu 23 Aug 2007 3:59pm

at least harvs dal or gilbert toal disgrace

saintm · Post: # 440565Post **saintm** » Thu 23 Aug 2007 4:00pm

sainter58 wrote:Does Not include any saints.
And i thought he knew something about football.

Seems prone to changing his mind a bit of late - probably had them in there then took them out!!

stinger · Post: # 440568Post **stinger** » Thu 23 Aug 2007 4:02pm

saintm wrote:
sainter58 wrote:Does Not include any saints.
And i thought he knew something about football.
Seems prone to changing his mind a bit of late - probably had them in there then took them out!!

not sure if he saw the side he selected or not.......

Saints94 · Post: # 440569Post **Saints94** » Thu 23 Aug 2007 4:02pm

he is a smartass (m.voss)

suss · Post: # 440578Post **suss** » Thu 23 Aug 2007 4:08pm

I used to respect Voss but how anyone could leave Roo out of their all Australian team is beyond me.

He's put in some super human efforts this year and even on his 'off' weeks he's better than 90% of players. I would have thought he'd be one of the first few picked. Shows what I know.

Otiman · Post: # 440580Post **Otiman** » Thu 23 Aug 2007 4:09pm

Which saints players would you have in the AA side this year?

For me, it'd be Sam Fisher, Nick Riewoldt and that's about it.

luckysaint · Post: # 440582Post **luckysaint** » Thu 23 Aug 2007 4:09pm

i don't think it's unreasonable. We haven't really had anyone that has stood consistently the whole season. S.Fisher has been good, but he hasn't been tearing the competition apart. Our mids have been average with the exception of Montagna, but he won't get the nod because there are too many before him.

Saints94 · Post: # 440585Post **Saints94** » Thu 23 Aug 2007 4:10pm

Otiman wrote:Which saints players would you have in the AA side this year?

For me, it'd be Sam Fisher, Nick Riewoldt and that's about it.

gilbert?

plugger66 · Post: # 440601Post **plugger66** » Thu 23 Aug 2007 4:19pm

homework wrote:at least harvs dal or gilbert toal disgrace

Why would any of them get in AA squad. Only chance would be Rooy and Chips.

Winmarvellous · Thu 23 Aug 2007 4:19pm

Doubt I'd have any either to be perfectly honest. Maybe Roo and Fisher. Nobody else comes close IMO. While Roo has starred, I don't think he's best at his position this year, and I'd probably take Pavlich second after Brown. To suggest Gilbert would get a berth is a bit too much, no matter how much you love the Saints.

Otiman · Post: # 440605Post **Otiman** » Thu 23 Aug 2007 4:20pm

homework wrote:
Otiman wrote:Which saints players would you have in the AA side this year?

For me, it'd be Sam Fisher, Nick Riewoldt and that's about it.
gilbert?

No chance. Not even close to being the rising star.

Saints94 · Post: # 440606Post **Saints94** » Thu 23 Aug 2007 4:21pm

plugger66 wrote:
homework wrote:at least harvs dal or gilbert toal disgrace
Why would any of them get in AA squad. Only chance would be Rooy and Chips.

they have all had a great year!

evertonfc · Post: # 440611Post **evertonfc** » Thu 23 Aug 2007 4:24pm

How one-eyed is this forum? Unreal.

I wouldn't pick any of our players in the AA team. Not even close.

Riewoldt maybe, but after that, there'd be nobody.

And so ****ing what if Michael Voss doesn't pick one of our players? Seriously - it's his opinion, let him have it.

ausfatcat · Post: # 440612Post **ausfatcat** » Thu 23 Aug 2007 4:25pm

god homework you have some rose coloured glasses.

Gilbert no chance to make it

Dal no chance to make

They are goodyears but many people in the whole of AFL have had better.

Roo i'd say is 50/50 and Sam Fisher should be there but may just miss out.

fonz_#15 · Post: # 440616Post **fonz_#15** » Thu 23 Aug 2007 4:29pm

evertonfc wrote:How one-eyed is this forum? Unreal.

I wouldn't pick any of our players in the AA team. Not even close.

Riewoldt maybe, but after that, there'd be nobody.

And so ****ing what if Michael Voss doesn't pick one of our players? Seriously - it's his opinion, let him have it.

agree everton..

i would say roo is a chance fior a spot on the bench, but no other saint has earnt a position in the comps best 22 over a season.

chips has had a good year but he will not get a spot. too many ahead of him in his position.

ausfatcat · Post: # 440618Post **ausfatcat** » Thu 23 Aug 2007 4:30pm

just curious who would you put in front of chips in a pocket or half flank, because I struggle to think of too many.

saintsrus · Post: # 440619Post **saintsrus** » Thu 23 Aug 2007 4:30pm

evertonfc wrote:How one-eyed is this forum? Unreal.

I wouldn't pick any of our players in the AA team. Not even close.

Riewoldt maybe, but after that, there'd be nobody.

And so ****ing what if Michael Voss doesn't pick one of our players? Seriously - it's his opinion, let him have it.

I agree, Rooey only.

btw never like M Voss since he wanted Sydney to beat us in 95 pf over his brother having some success, what a knob

Saints94 · Post: # 440620Post **Saints94** » Thu 23 Aug 2007 4:31pm

fonz_#15 wrote:
evertonfc wrote:How one-eyed is this forum? Unreal.

I wouldn't pick any of our players in the AA team. Not even close.

Riewoldt maybe, but after that, there'd be nobody.

And so ****ing what if Michael Voss doesn't pick one of our players? Seriously - it's his opinion, let him have it.
agree everton..

i would say roo is a chance fior a spot on the bench, but no other saint has earnt a position in the comps best 22 over a season.

chips has had a good year but he will not get a spot. too many ahead of him in his position.

true there are heaps of players that good easily have taken chips position

StSteven · Post: # 440624Post **StSteven** » Thu 23 Aug 2007 4:33pm

Sadly I afree with him. Not been our year this one. Best forgotten and move on.

hAyES · Post: # 440644Post **hAyES** » Thu 23 Aug 2007 4:52pm

Roo was the only real chance I think, but his kicking continues to let him down, so I can see not picking him.

Stephen Theodore · Thu 23 Aug 2007 4:54pm

[quote]Which saints players would you have in the AA side this year?

[/b]Rooey would be it

Saints94 · Post: # 440650Post **Saints94** » Thu 23 Aug 2007 4:56pm

now that you think about rooy would be the only one in it

BAM! (shhhh) · Thu 23 Aug 2007 4:57pm

ausfatcat wrote:just curious who would you put in front of chips in a pocket or half flank, because I struggle to think of too many.

Plenty of guys around who may get a guernsee ahead of Fisher (not saying any/all deserve it, but it wouldn't shock to see 6 guys in ahead of Fisher).

Matty Scarlett, Dustin Fletcher, C. Cornes (doesn't generally play CHB, but that's never stopped them selecting him there before), J Bowden (possession master. It'd be interesting to see him play on a better team), Heath Shaw, Andrew Macleod, Luke Hodge has spent some time roaming the half back line, I believe Voss had Malceski in, who I haven't seen that much of (avoid watching Sydney games generally), and Campbell Brown, Jarrad Waite is probably a longshot, but a possibility, Jed Adcock, Firrito, Milburn, Egan... and given the way that AA selection tends to go, someone could be selected totally from left field - WA selector and SA selector often get a guy in who isn't on the radar here in Vic, and I didn't name any dockers.

Again, not to say either Fisher hasn't had a great season, or that any of these players should/shouldn't go in front of him, but he's certainly not a lock for a spot.

Saints94 · Post: # 440654Post **Saints94** » Thu 23 Aug 2007 4:59pm

BAM! (shhhh) wrote:
ausfatcat wrote:just curious who would you put in front of chips in a pocket or half flank, because I struggle to think of too many.
Plenty of guys around who may get a guernsee ahead of Fisher (not saying any/all deserve it, but it wouldn't shock to see 6 guys in ahead of Fisher).

Matty Scarlett, Dustin Fletcher, C. Cornes (doesn't generally play CHB, but that's never stopped them selecting him there before), J Bowden (possession master. It'd be interesting to see him play on a better team), Heath Shaw, Andrew Macleod, Luke Hodge has spent some time roaming the half back line, I believe Voss had Malceski in, who I haven't seen that much of (avoid watching Sydney games generally), and Campbell Brown, Jarrad Waite is probably a longshot, but a possibility, Jed Adcock, Firrito, Milburn, Egan... and given the way that AA selection tends to go, someone could be selected totally from left field - WA selector and SA selector often get a guy in who isn't on the radar here in Vic, and I didn't name any dockers.

Again, not to say either Fisher hasn't had a great season, or that any of these players should/shouldn't go in front of him, but he's certainly not a lock for a spot.

his disposal of the footy hasnt been the best

M.Voss all Australian Side

M.Voss all Australian Side

Re: M.Voss all Australian Side

Re: M.Voss all Australian Side