Scan results for Harvs and Maxie ...

[Oh When the Saints]

Courtesy www.afl.com.au

ST KILDA stars Robert Harvey and Max Hudghton will both miss Friday night's crucial match against West Coast through injury.

Both players had scans on Monday after sustaining quadriceps injuries during Saturday's win over Fremantle.

Football operations manager Ken Sheldon said with only a six-day break between games, Harvey and Hudghton would miss the Eagles clash.

But the club was hopeful they could both recover in time to play against Richmond in the following round.

Sheldon said ruckman Justin Koschitzke, a late withdrawal from Saturday's match because of soreness, and Luke Ball, who spent some time on the bench with a thigh problem, would both play against the Eagles.

[saintsrus]

Best we could have hoped for..............i guess

[chook23]

no mention of level of strain to thigh (quad)

given my experience when playing

rare if only one week.............not so sure........but fingers crossed

Max would appear to be the worst from observation on Sat..........

but the club docs etc are privy to info though and the ability to read it!!

[Oh When the Saints]

Agree chook

Not surprised with Harvs ... I have a feeling that if we had been playing Sunday, he would have been right to go.

But very surprised with Maxie ... given his history this year too.


Oh well ... let's hope both are back up and running, and we can give Harvs a shot at the finals by winning this week.

[Otiman]

Hopeful was the word used, not Confident.

Reading between the lines, means there is a slight possibility of both of them playing.

[chook23]

Hopeful was the word used, not Confident.

Reading between the lines, means there is a slight possibility of both of them playing.

Understand that................

but my experience a quad 3-4 weeks if a reasonable strain

[midas_touch]

Kinda expected Harvey to be not playing this Friday. As for Max, if he were to come back for the Richmond game, that would be a pleasant surprise considering he missed 7 weeks with a quad strain earlier in the year.

[Saints Premiers 2008]

the sooner the season is over for maxxy the better one feels

[saintsRrising]

the sooner the season is over for maxxy the better one feels

WTF???

The week earlier Max had thrashed Hall....

We need an in form Max at FB.

[Saints Premiers 2008]

the sooner the season is over for maxxy the better one feels

WTF???

The week earlier Max had thrashed Hall....

We need an in form Max at FB.

its the third or fourth time he has gone down during a game....

with no preseason

regardless of who he has towelled up his body is clearly failling him

[saintsRrising]

the sooner the season is over for maxxy the better one feels

WTF???

The week earlier Max had thrashed Hall....

We need an in form Max at FB.

its the third or fourth time he has gone down during a game....

with no preseason

regardless of who he has towelled up his body is clearly failling him

....and that makes you feel better??????????????????????????????????????????????????

[skeptic]

SR, i think he means Max has never really looked like he's regained full fitness and looks like he could break down for 5-6 weeks at any minute

[Saints Premiers 2008]

the sooner the season is over for maxxy the better one feels

WTF???

The week earlier Max had thrashed Hall....

We need an in form Max at FB.

its the third or fourth time he has gone down during a game....

with no preseason

regardless of who he has towelled up his body is clearly failling him

....and that makes you feel better??????????????????????????????????????????????????

geez i am just stating my opinion and consdering he has broken down frequently i think it is fairly valid

oh yes i do feel better that maxxy has gone down???

what a strange post on your behalf sr...get a grip