Delistings

[darylcowie]

Joyce
Highmore
Allison
Kent
Bytel
Geary
Hannebery
Byrnes

[Wayne42]

Joyce
Highmore
Allison
Kent
Bytel
Geary
Hannebery
Byrnes

I don't think we'd miss any of that lot if they were all moved on.

I think Allison is contracted for 2023 so he may get another year to wither at Sandy.

[skeptic]

Personally I’d keep Byrnes, Bytel and Highmore

[saynta]

Bytel and Byrnes are keepers but they are not getting a fair go at Moorabbin and may look elsewhere, which would be a crying shame. IMHFO

[Gershwin]

Joyce
Highmore
Allison
Kent
Bytel
Geary
Hannebery
Byrnes

I would add Ryder to that list for reasons that everyone is aware of. Chronic Achilles problem and age, means that he will struggle to put consecutive games together. Marshall is better value if Paddy is not playing. Paddy will make a wonderful ruck coach.
8 is a good number to delist so would keep Byrnes.

[longtimesaint]

If we delist as many as 8 players where do we get 8 as good in the draft or trade?
Bytel, Byrnes and Highmore worth keeping

[Banger9798]

Yes to
Allison
Kent
Geary

Why would you delist Bytel and Byrnes, still developing.
Highmore a keeper, not sure about Joyce, but we haven't much in reserve for KPDs

[longtimesaint]

I think Allison is contracted for 2023

[cwrcyn]

Definitely

Geary
Kent
Joyce

Maybe

Allison (only because he's contracted)
Hannebery


Bytel has been injured for most of this year. Needs a clean run at it. I'm not convinced, but I think one more year to show his worth

Byrnes has shown a little bit and can improve

[Scollop]

Geary announced he’s retiring so that’s the obvious one. I will bombard the club with phone calls and emails if they don’t delist Hannebery

Bytel is a keeper. Needs to look after his body and just keep getting fitter and stronger. We know he has talent and he also has leadership credentials. He has the potential to be our best inside mid in 2-3 years time. Why wouldn’t you persevere?

Highmore unlucky not to have played a few more games this year. If Jimmy and Josh have injuries, I’d be happy to have him replace one of them in the team. Lienert to me, seems to be more of a winger rather than a defender. He’s handy if Wood or McKenzie or Hill are injured

[Waltzing St Kilda]

Kent
Hannebury
Geary
Finnis
Lethlean
Roughead
Lade
Ratten

[Scollop]

Kent
Hannebury
Geary
Finnis
Lethlean
Roughead
Lade
Ratten

So….you want them to lock the front door, padlock the gate, and put a sign saying ‘Business Closed’

[Impatient Sainter]

By all accounts from BF - Bytel is off to Essendon and NWM has asked to return to Adelaide this year or next.

[B.M]

Allison to Rookie

Geary
Kent
Connolly


Maybe Joyce

Not sure on Ryder or Hannebery
Need medical advice there


Definitely keep Campbell

[bangaulegend]

By all accounts from BF - Bytel is off to Essendon and NWM has asked to return to Adelaide this year or next.

If true that is very disappointing

[chook23]

Would pick 101 102 103 be better

[saintkev]

See if Freo would like seagull Hill back. He’d go well hovering at Kailis Fish Market. Perhaps they could handball Acres back if the Saints said that the coaches had their fingers crossed behind their backs when the swap was made.

[B.M]

It would have to be

Hill + first round draft pick for Acres

[bangaulegend]

It would have to be

Hill + first round draft pick for Acres

[SaintPav]

By all accounts from BF - Bytel is off to Essendon and NWM has asked to return to Adelaide this year or next.

Saints have dropped the ball if true.

My mate told me that Bytel’s old man told him that he could do better else where and that they were looking around.

[Kick-it-lace-out]

I don’t understand all this love for Byrnes & Bytel. BOG players who would not be best 22 in any of the top 6 teams.

[Banger9798]

Good sides maintain good depth, I'd hate to see another Essendon theft for sweet FA. They love picking us off

[bangaulegend]

I don’t understand all this love for Byrnes & Bytel. BOG players who would not be best 22 in any of the top 6 teams.

I think Bytel has something to offer & Brybes is a goer but average kicking skills & IMO don't think he will make it hope he proves me wrong

[1971]

We must persevere with Bytel. We aren't the best midfield in the world.

[saintsRrising]

and NWM has asked to return to Adelaide this year or next.

Is it just people repeating someone's initial thoughts as now fact.

Or is there a genuine source as to this actually being the case?

Previously the rumour with no source was that he was homesick. So what is the source of " NWM has asked to return to Adelaide this year or next."


I am not disputing it, but rather I am just curious as to whether it is just speculation, or whether there actually is a genuine source which makes it factual, rather than just a rumour.