Should we have Re Signed Ratt when we did ?

[bigred]

I voted yes because it was the right thing to do.
After the last six weeks however, it is easy to say that we should have waited.

I dont think this issue is the coach. But as per usual in this game he's a soft and easy target.

They need to work it out. Or he wont see out his contract. That's for sure and I'm loathe to see this club in the position of sacking another coach.

One thing on Thomas. Sure his list at the time had some incredibly talented kids... But he developed leaders. Absolute leaders.

[Teflon]

I was one who was against signing Ratt's before the end of the season because I actually thought he was out of ideas when we were challenged . Sure the list, injuries & the draw haven't helped but I don't think Ratt's is the man to lead us to glory , nice bloke but not sure has what it takes to get us to the level required to even challenge for a flag nether lone win one . I hope he proves me wrong

Me too
Was against signing his months ago and could see a win from a quarter here a quarter there
But apparently our Board watched different games ..
Of btw - Great thread Firey I like the discussion

[The Fireman]

I was one who was against signing Ratt's before the end of the season because I actually thought he was out of ideas when we were challenged . Sure the list, injuries & the draw haven't helped but I don't think Ratt's is the man to lead us to glory , nice bloke but not sure has what it takes to get us to the level required to even challenge for a flag nether lone win one . I hope he proves me wrong

Me too
Was against signing his months ago and could see a win from a quarter here a quarter there
But apparently our Board watched different games ..
Of btw - Great thread Firey I like the discussion

Thanks Teflon. It still managed to ruffle some feathers

[asiu]

.. But he developed leaders. Absolute leaders.

Keato said something along the lines of

... leaders create more leaders

[Vortex]

I was one who was against signing Ratt's before the end of the season because I actually thought he was out of ideas when we were challenged . Sure the list, injuries & the draw haven't helped but I don't think Ratt's is the man to lead us to glory , nice bloke but not sure has what it takes to get us to the level required to even challenge for a flag nether lone win one . I hope he proves me wrong

Me too
Was against signing his months ago and could see a win from a quarter here a quarter there
But apparently our Board watched different games ..
Of btw - Great thread Firey I like the discussion

Thanks Teflon. It still managed to ruffle some feathers

Anyone else hear that echo....echo...

[asiu]

SS is a bit like a game of footy

even where the ball is not
there's a game going on

[The Fireman]

I was one who was against signing Ratt's before the end of the season because I actually thought he was out of ideas when we were challenged . Sure the list, injuries & the draw haven't helped but I don't think Ratt's is the man to lead us to glory , nice bloke but not sure has what it takes to get us to the level required to even challenge for a flag nether lone win one . I hope he proves me wrong

Me too
Was against signing his months ago and could see a win from a quarter here a quarter there
But apparently our Board watched different games ..
Of btw - Great thread Firey I like the discussion

Thanks Teflon. It still managed to ruffle some feathers

Anyone else hear that echo....echo...

I seem to have upset you along the line. Hope you can get over it

[Vortex]

I was one who was against signing Ratt's before the end of the season because I actually thought he was out of ideas when we were challenged . Sure the list, injuries & the draw haven't helped but I don't think Ratt's is the man to lead us to glory , nice bloke but not sure has what it takes to get us to the level required to even challenge for a flag nether lone win one . I hope he proves me wrong

Me too
Was against signing his months ago and could see a win from a quarter here a quarter there
But apparently our Board watched different games ..
Of btw - Great thread Firey I like the discussion

Thanks Teflon. It still managed to ruffle some feathers

Anyone else hear that echo....echo...

I seem to have upset you along the line. Hope you can get over it

Not at all, I'm mainly interested in forums for discussion, not participating in SunnyErnie type yes or no type votes.

It makes me chuckle though, your voting thread reminds me of the notes we used to pass around under the table in primary school with a question like do you hate our teacher, tick yes or no.

[The Fireman]

I was one who was against signing Ratt's before the end of the season because I actually thought he was out of ideas when we were challenged . Sure the list, injuries & the draw haven't helped but I don't think Ratt's is the man to lead us to glory , nice bloke but not sure has what it takes to get us to the level required to even challenge for a flag nether lone win one . I hope he proves me wrong

Me too
Was against signing his months ago and could see a win from a quarter here a quarter there
But apparently our Board watched different games ..
Of btw - Great thread Firey I like the discussion

Thanks Teflon. It still managed to ruffle some feathers

Anyone else hear that echo....echo...

I seem to have upset you along the line. Hope you can get over it

Not at all, I'm mainly interested in forums for discussion, not participating in SunnyErnie type yes or no type votes.

It makes me chuckle though, your voting thread reminds me of the notes we used to pass around under the table in primary school with a question like do you hate our teacher, tick yes or no.

What did you tick ?

[Vortex]

I was one who was against signing Ratt's before the end of the season because I actually thought he was out of ideas when we were challenged . Sure the list, injuries & the draw haven't helped but I don't think Ratt's is the man to lead us to glory , nice bloke but not sure has what it takes to get us to the level required to even challenge for a flag nether lone win one . I hope he proves me wrong

Me too
Was against signing his months ago and could see a win from a quarter here a quarter there
But apparently our Board watched different games ..
Of btw - Great thread Firey I like the discussion

Thanks Teflon. It still managed to ruffle some feathers

Anyone else hear that echo....echo...

I seem to have upset you along the line. Hope you can get over it

Not at all, I'm mainly interested in forums for discussion, not participating in SunnyErnie type yes or no type votes.

It makes me chuckle though, your voting thread reminds me of the notes we used to pass around under the table in primary school with a question like do you hate our teacher, tick yes or no.

What did you tick ?

Depends, if it was grade 6 I would of ticked no and written I think our teacher is hot...Ahhh Mrs Topsianko, a very sexy blonde Russian.

[The Fireman]

I was one who was against signing Ratt's before the end of the season because I actually thought he was out of ideas when we were challenged . Sure the list, injuries & the draw haven't helped but I don't think Ratt's is the man to lead us to glory , nice bloke but not sure has what it takes to get us to the level required to even challenge for a flag nether lone win one . I hope he proves me wrong

Me too
Was against signing his months ago and could see a win from a quarter here a quarter there
But apparently our Board watched different games ..
Of btw - Great thread Firey I like the discussion

Thanks Teflon. It still managed to ruffle some feathers

Anyone else hear that echo....echo...

I seem to have upset you along the line. Hope you can get over it

Not at all, I'm mainly interested in forums for discussion, not participating in SunnyErnie type yes or no type votes.

It makes me chuckle though, your voting thread reminds me of the notes we used to pass around under the table in primary school with a question like do you hate our teacher, tick yes or no.

What did you tick ?

Depends, if it was grade 6 I would of ticked no and written I think our teacher is hot...Ahhh Mrs Topsianko, a very sexy blonde Russian.

Nice. So you should be happy that you have multiple options in this poll. What did she teach ?

[asiu]

we had ms sabine

art teacher

tiny well breasted dark haired goddess


she rattled me

loved art classes

[The Fireman]

we had ms sabine

art teacher

tiny well breasted dark haired goddess


she rattled me

loved art classes

You could have been PM if she had of taught political studies ?

my art teacher was a short chinaman with a big strap.

my art struggled for a bit.

[Vortex]

I was one who was against signing Ratt's before the end of the season because I actually thought he was out of ideas when we were challenged . Sure the list, injuries & the draw haven't helped but I don't think Ratt's is the man to lead us to glory , nice bloke but not sure has what it takes to get us to the level required to even challenge for a flag nether lone win one . I hope he proves me wrong

Me too
Was against signing his months ago and could see a win from a quarter here a quarter there
But apparently our Board watched different games ..
Of btw - Great thread Firey I like the discussion

Thanks Teflon. It still managed to ruffle some feathers

Anyone else hear that echo....echo...

I seem to have upset you along the line. Hope you can get over it

Not at all, I'm mainly interested in forums for discussion, not participating in SunnyErnie type yes or no type votes.

It makes me chuckle though, your voting thread reminds me of the notes we used to pass around under the table in primary school with a question like do you hate our teacher, tick yes or no.

What did you tick ?

Depends, if it was grade 6 I would of ticked no and written I think our teacher is hot...Ahhh Mrs Topsianko, a very sexy blonde Russian.

Nice. So you should be happy that you have multiple options in this poll. What did she teach ?

Forbidden love and algebra.

[asiu]

haha

i just learnt this last night

The word “algebra” originates from the Arabic al-jabr, which means "the reunion of broken parts"

[The Fireman]

haha

i just learnt this last night

The word “algebra” originates from the Arabic al-jabr, which means "the reunion of broken parts"

how apt

[Vortex]

haha

i just learnt this last night

The word “algebra” originates from the Arabic al-jabr, which means "the reunion of broken parts"

Make no mistake about it, my grade 6 teach broke hearts, maybe that's why she was good at algebra?

[The Fireman]

haha

i just learnt this last night

The word “algebra” originates from the Arabic al-jabr, which means "the reunion of broken parts"

Make no mistake about it, my grade 6 teach broke hearts, maybe that's why she was good at algebra?

Vortex a few on here seem happy with this multi choice poll , it has created some healthy discussion yet you find it moronic, do find those that participated moronic ?

[Vortex]

haha

i just learnt this last night

The word “algebra” originates from the Arabic al-jabr, which means "the reunion of broken parts"

Make no mistake about it, my grade 6 teach broke hearts, maybe that's why she was good at algebra?

Vortex a few on here seem happy with this multi choice poll , it has created some healthy discussion yet you find it moronic, do find those that participated moronic ?

An incredibly rigged voting system is dodgy. You're just trying to create a false narrative with binary decision making to validate a bias. I can train a pigeon to tick yes or no to the question if they would like their wings cut off. But even the pigeon won't like the question and might be smart enough to ask who set the question.

[The Fireman]

haha

i just learnt this last night

The word “algebra” originates from the Arabic al-jabr, which means "the reunion of broken parts"

Make no mistake about it, my grade 6 teach broke hearts, maybe that's why she was good at algebra?

Vortex a few on here seem happy with this multi choice poll , it has created some healthy discussion yet you find it moronic, do find those that participated moronic ?

An incredibly rigged voting system is dodgy. You're just trying to create a false narrative with binary decision making to validate a bias. I can train a pigeon to tick yes or no to the question if they would like their wings cut off. But even the pigeon won't like the question and might be smart enough to ask who set the question.

so those who participated are morons ?

[Vortex]

haha

i just learnt this last night

The word “algebra” originates from the Arabic al-jabr, which means "the reunion of broken parts"

Make no mistake about it, my grade 6 teach broke hearts, maybe that's why she was good at algebra?

Vortex a few on here seem happy with this multi choice poll , it has created some healthy discussion yet you find it moronic, do find those that participated moronic ?

An incredibly rigged voting system is dodgy. You're just trying to create a false narrative with binary decision making to validate a bias. I can train a pigeon to tick yes or no to the question if they would like their wings cut off. But even the pigeon won't like the question and might be smart enough to ask who set the question.

so those who participated are morons ?

Surely you are taking the pith now...I hope you are because if you didn't intend that then my sense of humour is way too wierd. However If binary chat is your thing then I apologise for laughing and say there is nothing wrong with framing a question to procure confirmation of your bias via yes/no voting.

[Yorkeys]

Dear Pollster,
Does the poll suggest 18 of the 58,000 members don't think Ratts is smoking hot or can teach algebra? Or neither.
Can't figure it out from the raw data.

Confused forward, of Moorabbin

[The Fireman]

Dear Pollster,
Does the poll suggest 18 of the 58,000 members don't think Ratts is smoking hot or can teach algebra? Or neither.
Can't figure it out from the raw data.

Confused forward, of Moorabbin

Wish I could help you yorkeys but my brain has been sucked into a vortex

[asiu]

+

the original 4 votes for ... Yes
were lost ie ... disappeared

following the edit

i re-voted
... so still could be short 3


conclusion .... blondes are more broken

[The Fireman]

Just thought I’d bump this in case someone missed out on the vote