3/4

Abysmal

Goal kicking is farcical for pro athletes

He was good, especially defensively

20 touches
Not yet an "I told you so" game... so sorry Stoney

Imagine if Paddy got his numbers

We'd all be spoofing ourselves

Billings
Sinclair

He normally does

I thought I couldn't walk away from a win any flatter than last week

We took winning against garbage to a new low tonight

Thank god his son was playing tonight

I think Long will be ok

A lot of Browns were amazing courage or just collision from extreme attack on the pill Paddy has at least three times just been poor technique Yesterday was awful technique Also Brown was knocked out 3-5 times in his career Over 200 games Paddy 5 times in 20-30 Extrapolate That would be 30-40 times ...

It funny though

He has a terrible body shape, but is deceptively quick

In fact one of the fastest over medium distance (50-100) at the club

He is a bit like Petracca in that he's powerful I reckon.

I'd rather him back than Joey

What's wrong with the Brayshaw pick? He showed plenty in his first year to suggest he will be a gun. He is recovering from serious injury like many others do. Has paddy shown as much as him Good game vs Melb (9marks) Good quarter vs Richmond Two good marks vs Collingwood and Hawthorn 1 Good pre seas...

Sometimes what we want to happen and what will happen are not one and the same? Lots of people with their fingers crossed, convincing themselves not sure you should have to cross your fingers with a top 5 pick. BTW Shot at goal Is that a new stat, is there a reason we don't care about efficiency... ...

Hard to get a kick as a forward in that team

It's horrendous

Not if Luke gets a few kicks

McKenzie, McCartin, Coughlin, Minchinton, Hickey were all injured during the game

I think Rice can play, very well, he's a proper footballer who makes good decisions and reads the game well.

He surely has limitations with running capacity, but it doesn't seem so?

He would need an injury to Geary or Webster to get a look in though

Has past a disappointing DMac who I really rate!

Oh, and Goddard has missed over a year of footy and most of the training, so judging him is silly

So we turn our attention to the posters when we are trying to redirect, distraction is the tactic of people with no counter How about stay on topic?? Why do some posters think they can just belittle other posters because the have a different opinion? Is that not allowed???? Paddy is underwhelming, t...

McGovern didn't debut until 22

He was after all pick 44 in the rookie draft.... so not pick 1 overall

At 23 was in the AA squad of 40 playing his 20th game in the process

McGovern also dropped a sh*tload of weight and is pretty fit now

Lucky he's such a good player then?!

Not really Stonecold

I left home at 1:30ish and went to the footy.

I watched a bit of it before I left?

Do you want my movements for tomorrow also?

Ok Curley

Let's compare there numbers if you want, and ask some neutral supporters what they think?

Stone cold

Which player are we allowed to critique?
Hickey?
The ones you don't rate?
Are we allowed to have commentary on the biggest investment we've made since 2002

Well he certainly hasn't proven much otherwise?!

McGovern - can handle a fat player, if they can play... not sure how fat he is though?

Watched a half

Half a dozen real talents

2 stood out to me.... the powerful mid/fwd who is Dare I say it
Petracca Like

And the guy with three names

They rated him either best or second best and took him at #1 That makes no sense?! Surely they rated him the best??? Therein lies the problem... he was not the best prospect. Another problem is, the guy everyone else rated the best, has turned out as much... that's just what the evidence suggests Th...