Sorry to bring up an old chestnut

But geez, he was handed his arse on a platter today by Coburgs ruckman - a physical beast of a man.

What's going on with him?

Of course I'm not all doom and gloom... I just say what I see? Isn't that what most do??? Or do they just see what they wanna see... like bagging the crap out of Geary, who has finished top 5 in an AFL team b&f 4 of the last 5 years?... or just refusing to see the obvious limitations of McCartin...

Played ok today, not one of his best games but he was good. He is a natural footballer, a good footballer. But a poor looking athlete, although his actual movement belies his body shap He's quite quick and very strong, tough Had he got the tank for league footy? I reckon he has as a nuggets back poc...

Paddy Like Kosi has had some bad luck But I have little evidence of this incredible vice like marking I hear about? I've seen him fumble and drop marks, and often two grabs them He can take a catch, although as a #1 I expect him to take most catches He did in Juniors, he was a heavy kid (relative) a...

Marshall is a beautiful kick

Top 10 on the list imo

And Brayshaw

Gilbee was disgusted, didn't seem like he was coaching to develop

Question is though If 17 other clubs had pick 1 as we did Would they have taken him??? Bernard, it happened on the HFF goalside of the Sandy coaches box about a handball distance from the boundary I was standing 5m to the side of the coaches box on the fence. Spud was on the hill behind the coaches ...

Yeah, Paddy kicked a bag on me... yep that's it

What am I lying about?

The fact I was there

That I was standing next to Spud

It happened right on front of the coaches box

Not sure why I'd lie, or why you'd accuse someone of that when you have no evidence of such a thing?

Connellan is on the bench, I'm on the left side of the pick against the fence... only metres from the play

Please don't mention Lockett and McCartin in the same sentence, post, thread, forum please

Lockett was 21 in 1987

Not sure Paddy will kick a hundred this season, win the b&f, the Brownlow or even play much more senior footy this year.

Lockett was fat, yes
But he wasn't slow!

If I heard the words

Sixth
Spitter
Round up/set up

One more time today I was going to spew up!!!

Information overload, too many rotations, players are confused and stressed!

I was there Hideous 3 positives (which all have negatives attached) Steele Freeman Marshall Steele is a mile above VFL but can't kick and he knows it so chooses not to Freeman had a real go, but can't kick and makes poor decisions but tried his guts out, used his wheels and found the pill Marshall l...

Has he ever played well for more than a half? He is still CLEARLY unfit!! I've never seen an AFL footballer in this decade look more like a suburban or country footballer! Today against inferior opposition, he was in 4 contests 3 times he was outpointed by a no name undersized VFL listed defender an...

Technique

You think it's funny when a player gets concussed?

Didn't come back on

Suggesting he failed the test

Was clearly knocked out

It happened 5m from me, it was his poor technique that caused the contact.

No idea how to pick the footy up in a contest without going head first

As Danny Frawley said, he only had to turn his body.

Knocked out

1st quarter

Ran head first into someone

Barry Hall

McClunken... really? One grab?? If he came in and kicked 4/5 soft goals then what... he's made it? Why does he deserve a game over anyone else?? Why not an opportunity for Rice or McKenzie or Freeman??? Because so desperately we want him to be good?? We want him to get a kick against a second rate o...

NZ would be great... a place where AFL Football is about as relevant as badminton Tassie, there is already a market to control. Everyone would jump on, as they are dying for a team to support. I'd suggest not 9 games, but at least 6 (3 north, 3 south) with 11 in Melbourne 1 in NZ and 4 interstate. T...

Says more about Hickey and his form