wouldnt be saying goodbye to milney I'm curious. Why not? Are you seeing something that i'm not? I find him terribly inconsistent, slow, frustrating as all hell. It's not that he doesn't kicks goals, but some weeks it's 4 and the next 3 weeks it'll be 0... at least thats how I see it. Totally agree...

I don't think that our midfield is whats hurting us, it's the lack of forward pressure we apply. Too many times the midfielders and the backs work their arses off just to see their hard work undone by poor second and third efforts by our forwards, which results in the ball flying back out over their...

B: Baker, Hudghton, Birss HB: S. Fisher, Koschitzke, Montagna C: Goddard, Ball, Riewoldt HF: Schneider, Ferguson, Dal Santo F: Milne, Allen, Jones FOLL: M.Gardiner, Hayes, Harvey I/C: McEvoy, Armitage, Geary, McQualter EMG: Gram, King, Steven Please comment Not a bad side, I like BG and NR on the w...

Really Ben Johnson and Clint Jones can't see a whole lot of difference between the two, both quick, hard at it types with dodgy disposal.
Yet Malthouse would pick Johnson in the starting 18 most weeks, BECAUSE he is quick and hard at it it, just like Jones.

CJ has to be given more game time for his skills to improve under the constant pressure of AFL footy.

Great to see him put 4 very good quarters together on the weekend.

Ferguson - FF Riewoldt - Wing Kosi - CHB Goddard - Wing/On ball C.Gardiner - CHF Obviously the forward set up isn't working now, so lets find out if Fergie and Chuck CAN and WANT to play AFL. Make them the go to forwards with Blake as another marking option, with Montagna, Schiender, Harvey and the ...

I'm happy that Michael Gardiner is finally starting to deliver, his last 4 weeks have been very good. His ruck work especailly to Hayes and Ball has been first rate. Can't understand why when Kingy's in the side, Gardiner nearly always starts on the bench. Only negative is that awful kicking action ...

5. Brendan Goddard
4. Clint Jones
3. Sam Fisher
2. Michael Gardiner
1. Nick Dal Santo

Absolute joke!!!

Every club should have a video of the 3 incidents involving Goodes this year and use it as evidence when appealing a suspension.

Not even Jason Daniels averaged as many clangers as Milney per week.... Jack at least put his body on the line all the time. He actually got the football. Regularly and in tough situations. And he was a great tackler. I'll skip over his disposal skills :roll: Wasn't bagging Jack, as I'd prefer a pl...

Milney is and has been a passenger at this football club for 100 games too many, has kicked 1 bag per year for the last 5 years no where near good enough. GET RID OF HIM, NOW!!!! Because good small forwards grow on trees? So who replaces him? Schneider, who is not as good as Milne anyway? Please, t...

No, I think your a f****** complete imbecile. Harvs will make the call when its time, more than likely ernd of this year. Until now, he has been more than just a contributor, and sadly one of our best in the midfield. If you can call harvs selfish with your first post, take my advice and dont ever ...

Milney is and has been a passenger at this football club for 100 games too many, has kicked 1 bag per year for the last 5 years no where near good enough.

GET RID OF HIM, NOW!!!!

With poor old No.35 bowing out at the end of the year, and there's obviously no talent to come in and replace him I reckon Cousin's would be just what we need. Don't forget this bloke was an absolute superstar, and 12 months away will have done him the world of good. Just hope RL has a fair dinkum c...

When does the AFL triburnal go through the results from the weekend? Murphy looms as a pivotal player for the doggies and his absense could land a massive hole for the weekend. For mine, i think it should be a reprimand at worst, but you never know. He did get him high. Has he got a record? Thought...

SaintWodonga wrote:Saw his match against the crows kicked some vital goals... If David Minson can get get his fitness up and maybe a burst of speed, he could be really good for us.

WHO????

Just a spin off of your question, but who do you think will be given the 35 guernsey ????? IMO no one at this stage is worthy :wink: his son.....when he plays for stkilda, I agree, Lets just hope Mrs Harvey does the right thing by the club and lets the old champ go to stud and sire a few more colts...

Saint_Bronx wrote:Does anyone think dempster should be dropped for next week, he done nothing today other than a late goal with 15 seconds left in the fourth quarter.

Surely you couldn't have been watching the same game as everybody else, Dempster beat Wonermerri hands down and provided plenty of run out of defence.

Straight swap for Rooey, before he takes off to the GC

Cairnsman wrote:I reckon that if we don't kick a winning score then Melbourne will probably beat us.

Not only would Melbourne beat us, but I reckon all sides would if we didn't kick a WINNING score

OUTS

Fiora
Birss
L. Fisher
Milne

INS

Howard
Armitage
Ferguson
Baker

How Many coaches do we need to sack, before we realse what the rest of the footy world already knows and that is our list has been overated for the last 4yrs. Ross knows he needs to change the game plan, and I actually think he's capable of doing it. But what he first needs to do is what GT was able...

I think the time is right to face reality, Our side is going no where with this current list its time to make some drastic changes. Rooy - Needs to be traded, before its too late. His body is stuffed,hence the 10 rolls of elastoplast every week. Lets tade him while the rest of the league still rates...

Hows this for a line up

FB: SF MH SD
HB: BG JK JGram
C: ND LH LM
HF: DA NR RH
FF: CJ CG Ferguson

R: MG, LB, AS

Int: XC, SK, Howard SB or LF

The following players should never be picked again Raph Clarke - Simply not up to it, makes to many dumb decisions Milney - Played 100 games to many. Kicks around corners , hardly ever hits a target,makes to many dumb decisions. Should be playing with Casey Fiora - Sleeps with the light on Birss - S...