Beno88 wrote: ↑Wed 08 Nov 2023 3:28pm

cwrcyn wrote: ↑Wed 08 Nov 2023 3:20pm Not De Mattia. Can't kick for sh#t. No thanks

Yeah but have you seen his cover drive?

We need players who hit straight drives, instead of shanking it through the covers.

It's a tiny part of the TPP. They can use it anyway they see fit. Jack had an opportunity to demand his spot back by his actions. On the training track and in his games at Sandringham. Maybe Billings avoided one too many contests for Ross's liking If I was Ross Lyon and I had a guy like Billings wh...

Delisting of Tom Highmore Signing of Tom Campbell for one more year Dan McKenzie remaining unsigned Liam O'Connell joining as a rookie B Mason Wood must be upgraded from the rookie list to the senior list if he is to be retained is a given All results in the list having 32 senior players, 5 rookie A...

we also gained 2 more 3 round picks for next year so we have 3 third round picks. with pick 40 and 2 of our 3 rounders next year we should try and get a late 1st or early second round pick for this year The banks must love you. Unable to live within your means. Mortgaging your future. St Kilda gave...

Picks can be traded on the night but next years draft is rumoured to be stronger than this year so future picks wil be more valuable.

Now St Kilda has picks 13, 21, 40 & 92. Pick 13 will drift back few places and pick 21 probably back 5 places on the draft night. It has 4 vacancies that must be filled to reach a minimum 36 senior players but can have 2 more senior players at the expense of rookie A places. It has the maximum 6...

Silvagni just on trade radio. Said he hasn't even spoken to Melbourne yet about Billings, so whoever posted that a deal had been finalised is wrong. Silvagni also said that Shiel will be at Essendon next yesr Paul Connors is Billings agent, now who would be incentivised to suggest Billing to Melbou...

samuraisaint wrote: ↑Tue 17 Oct 2023 8:03pm Happy with Liam Henry and Paddy Dow so far.

Would be happy to take the rest of our picks to the draft now.

Agreed, get some quality for picks 13 and 21 then catch a slider with pick 40.

Now have picks 13, 21, 40

Have lost future 2nd & 4th round picks but gained future 3rd round pick (tied to Carlton).

That is all except for finding a home for Billings & McKenzie.
And can always volunteer to be banker in a multi way trade.

All that matters
St Kilda got Dow, lost Coffield
Got pick 40, (429 points) + future 3rd round tied to Carlton), lost pick 35 + pick 56, 522 + 194 = 716 points = pick 20)
St Kilda lost 287 point for Carlton future 3rd so less than 100 points
Basically St Kilda traded Dow for Coffield

Breaking it down Essendon plays banker Carlton got future 3rd round (tied to Essendon) + future 4th round (tied to Doggies) (won't get used)+ future 4th (tied to Fremantle) (probably won't get used) Carton lost future 3rd round (tied to Carlton) future 4th round (tied to Carlton) + Dow to St Kilda E...

So the 4th round exchange means Freo are confident they're gonna finish above the Saints next year? Amd effectively means we got Henry for a second-rounder. Meanwhile the Gresh trade lands up with pick 21. Is Henry an upgrade on Gresh? Or simply better-suited to our needs? If so, we've done very we...

Who is using 4th round picks anyway? St Kilda's 4th round pick this year is in the hands of Gold Coast It is presently pick 74, the first pick to be valued at ZERO points. It can't even be used to queue jump for Northern Academy or Father-Son selections. Exchanging 4th round picks is like the recru...

I cheered for Luke Ball when he played for St Kilda especially when he kicked a rare goal. I cheered for Jade Gresham when he played for St Kilda especially when he kicked a more frequent goal. Then I booed Luke Ball when he played for Collingwood. But am I allowed to boo Jade Gresham when he plays ...

FWIW I have no issue with any player chasing money. They have a limited time in the game and the opportunity to earn reasonable cash when at the top of their powers. Most AFL players don't make exorbitant money after they retire. But we studied ASX listed company Johns Lyng Group Ltd (JLG) in the l...

As I have contributed previously, I am aware that after a season in which Coffield finished in the Top 10, he lost influence the following season with the Coach "calling him in" to advise that more run and carry was required ("use your legs"). To his credit, Coffield improved th...

Pick 21 but that will slide out a few to mid 20s as there will be the odd father son but there are expected to be a number of Northern Zone academy picks that CAN be matched inside the top 20 (Brisbane, Gold Coast, Sydney & GWS). The rules are different for other club academies. Gold Coast poten...

At present compensation for Gresham would be Mid 1st round = pick14 End 1st round = pick21 Mid 2nd round = pick 35 End 2nd round = pick 41 Mid 3rd round = pick 56 End 3rd round = pick 62 Mid 4th round = pick 74 Saints have picks 13, 34, 55 not much currency without using future 2024 picks. But Coffi...

Make the Dogs coff up.
Late first round or their future 2024 first rounder.

Plenty of trade discussion going elsewhere - Threads on Gresham, Shiel, etc. but no general trade discussion thread. Currently we hold: Picks 12, 32, 51 The media has thrown the idea out there for a Clayton Oliver trade, and has stated "no clubs have shown interest, Oliver hasn't shown interes...

A chinese company based in

WUHU

Ratten loved him, but Ratten has left North and maybe is giving away coaching.
If Ratten goes elsewhere that is where JB may go because Lyon does not want him.

Had the talent but not the application and dedication of a Bontempelli.

We were linked to him but has picked Sydney. Is FA so therefore Gresham compensation isn't compromised Oh yes it would be. Only a delisted free agent does not compromise compensation that is because the former club no longer owns the player having delisted him. If St kilda wants a compensation pick...

I would much prefer to see St Kilda keep whatever compensation the league offers for Gresham Then swap picks 12 and 31 for Essendons first round pick 8 and Shiel Values Shiel around pick 47 mid 3rd round. He doesn't have many years left and he is beyond his best. Then see if St Kilda can grab Gold C...

I would much prefer to see St Kilda keep whatever compensation the league offers for Gresham Then swap picks 12 and 31 for Essendons first round pick 8 and Shiel Values Shiel around pick 35 Then see if St Kilda can grab Gold coast's pick 4 for by combining pick 8 with the Gresham compensation. St Ki...