Tom Ledger must be picked this week, regardless of any of the suggestions otherwise on here, to prove that he's not good enough if not to give him a chance to be good enough! Selections of Sippos and Saad in the last 2 weeks devalue what it means to be selected by a 100+ year old footy club! So we ...

Comparing Goddard to Sipposs, please!!! Nice kicking action there only similarity. Retweeting re the club letting Lynch go, please!!! Surely the club can handle feedback from employees, either accept it or deal with it, don't hod a grudge though! Not selecting a guy averaging 30 in the feeder comp, ...

Tom Ledger must be picked this week, regardless of any of the suggestions otherwise on here, to prove that he's not good enough if not to give him a chance to be good enough!
Selections of Sippos and Saad in the last 2 weeks devalue what it means to be selected by a 100+ year old footy club!

Tom Ledger given a game!
Kosi's 200th

Hugh Goddard hey! Probably up and leave us! Have 2 family members ever been number 1 picks? Doubt it!

Oh yeah, Macevoy not on the table IMO!

Disappointed for Ledger, not sure what more he can do to stake a claim for senior selection! Has been great in the VFL! Sippos doesn't seem to have earnt selection to me!

Think pathetic is harsh, however I do believe that if Dal is interested in a move we should seriously consider looking for a trade at seasons end, would have great currency for a contender looking to add class and polish!

I love these threads! Don't imagine Mac is being dropped, easily our best ruck IMO. Over reaction to the rumblings of Darcy who was potting him for not working fwd hard enough! This could be fair criticism? An instruction from the coach to stay behind the ball as we already had a tall forward line! ...

I'd like go see both have a crack! Only play max of 2 small forwards! Not sure it would be fair to say coach hates Ledger but I think there is some animosity there, whether its just SW doesn't think he's good enough and TL does or there's more to it I don't know!

No - Mick will definitely want to lose........ It will be part of a complex, long-term double-pincer movement strategy, that will eventually deliver his ultimate goal of world domination. If it doesn't work, apparently he has a doomsday device in his shed at home........ Seriously, some of the thin...

If Scott Watters doesn't meet his and the clubs targets/expectations over the next 18 months then it wouldn't surprise me to see him get a go, possibly with a senior bloke as an assistant in the mould of the Hird Thompson arrangement!

Think Malthouse is well aware of what he has and where his deficiencies are with list, dropping one spot isn't going to impact DPs enough to tank, still a chance at finals anyway! Think most on here could have told him that they have to many rucks and not enough genuine forwards, there back line is ...

Think it depends on discussions he has had at club level, if the coach wants to blood White Staley Lever rather than give him games then he may retire! I would say Kosi more likely to stay on and retire after season so there is no fuss!

Haven't read the whole thread but in principal I agree with those saying that you have to give to get, currently we have to many medium defenders and small forwards who can't run through the middle, not enough mids and KP defenders. We must address this and we must be creative in the way we do it, w...

Were f***ed, lol
Puts it in reality a bit when you see that!

Get him to 200, then only pick him if form warrants it, good luck Kos, seem lie a top bloke!

Great player, been good to watch, beautiful skills! Well done NDS

Definitely in best 3 I've seen with Locket Harvey !
What about CHFs all time, I've got him above Brown Brereton easily and on a par with Carey!

Over reaction from Caro IMO, thought the club handled fairly well, not sure it's the end of the world if they changed their minds, took advice from AFL or surprised the players/coach. Nothing wrong with saying this is a tough situation and we took our time to come to an agreement!

Don't understand this site, so many people go the man not the ball! OP is entitled to his opinion, if you disagree then argue your point don't attack the man. I have a lot of love for Milne the footballer but OP may be right, not so much about sacking him but I'm not sure he can play until this is c...

Grant Thomas would be a great fit IMO. Laidley would be demanding but maybe a bit blunt from my memory of him as a senior coach?

Nice trip down memory lane!

Harvey Locket Burke Loewe Winmar Reiwoldt Hayes Frawley Goddard Milne, in no particular order.
Honourable mentions, Everitt Gherig DalSanto Hudghton Jones.

GC have come on stronger and quicker than I expected and should have a better idea of their best 22 now. This said they must have some good young footballers not getting a game due to the amount of players in same bracket. Would we be well served to try and trade a DalSanto type for a couple of 21 y...

chook23 wrote:

Middo wrote:Lee was named best for Sandy out of a poor bunch , Ledger surely offers more looking to the future as we all know what we get with Jones and now that's not a great deal. TDL in front if Saunders ?

Ledger is a SPUD

Ledgers VFL form is quite good, not sure what the issue is?