Disappointing to read about Hotton. He was one I have high hopes for

You’re labelling something as thuggery and admitting it’s ambiguous to find a charge. Thuggery shouldn’t be too hard to find a charge because thuggery, to my mind, is obvious and blatant

On the one hand you have people calling for calm because 'if' it was a Saints player we'd all feel different...as well as 'if' this and if that - basically all hypothetical and just deflecting from the evidence. Then you have Moods who sees the evidence and his interpretation is similar to the ex C...

Who's missing from the bombers team?

How's Pou going? Owens?

Well for a bloke who claims to have watched it in slow motion numerous times, you haven't been paying attention very closely. Brayshaw stumbles slightly after he kicks the ball, losing balance, causing him to veer ever so slightly to the right. There's no point even arguing it if you won't acknowled...

It baffles me that anyone could think that this was a deliberate act. Of course training would be different, just like he probably wouldn’t tackle as hard at training his own teammates as he would the opposition in a preliminary final. MB. If you watched this collision in slow motion numerous times...

Thank you for proving my point Yorkeys

So poor Brayshaw's career is stuffed and he is forced to retire. I have watched the video of the Brayshaw-Maynard incident several times again today, after umpteen times when it happened. The video seems crystal clear to me. Maynard jumped high in the air with his hands above his head trying to blo...

It baffles me that anyone could think that this was a deliberate act. Of course training would be different, just like he probably wouldn’t tackle as hard at training his own teammates as he would the opposition in a preliminary final. MB. If you watched this collision in slow motion numerous times....

Bungle renewal of coach that got you into grand finals; appoint Watters and Richardson; keep letting Richardson fail but hoping otherwise; hopelessly bungle #1 pick; recruit a banged up Hannebrey for big coin; history of folding when games were ours to lose; reappoint Ratts only to replace him mont...

Top 4 is our absolute best result. No way we can win the flag, this year I would have thought. Bottom part of the 8 most likely outcome. Wouldn’t surprise if we were anywhere from 4th to 12th though. So much luck with injuries involved. Keep King fit, Owens takes another step and members plays a ful...

We won 12 games when he won his first B&F he made the AA Squad go 14 Brownlow votes and averaged 29.8ppg Misnomer that we were ‘crap’ In 2009 and 10 Joey was not an inside mid Lenny and Dal were elite CJ was a tagger Ball was a solid player I think Seb makes the team as a secondary mid off the ...

If history is anything to go by He is clearly our second best mid Equal with Crouch imo Criminally underrated by ignorant supporters Who’s our best? Steele? I would hope that Pou, Wilson and Owens surpass him and would be disappointed if all didn’t have better careers. Obviously Sinclair is a bette...

not to mention us idiots running unto the ground after frazers 100 Not enough has ever been made of this point and for all the obvious reasons....but it doesn't get any more St Kilda. Our dumb faaaaaaark knuckle head supporters cost us a second flag...actual supporters impacting a game...you couldn...

B.M wrote: ↑Wed 14 Feb 2024 3:19pm Jones

Re-injured??

I hope you’re joking

When did I say that Coaches don’t matter? I have said they can’t succeed without the talent needed to win games. But Ultimately at the end of the day they are judged by how many premierships they have won. Do you think Ross has never coached a premiership list? Ross Lyon has never senior coached a ...

Roo is not responsible for the entire team - he is one player Coaches are responsible for results I don’t agree that premierships determine players greatness I somewhat agree that coaches success is measured by premierships Correct me if I’m wrong, but haven’t you been telling us for years that coa...

Yes or no Has he won a flag???? Not just came close Chris Fagan came close, Nathan Buckley came close… at the end of the day he’s had 14 seasons in the AFL - as Senior Coach and has coached 329 games without a premiership Winning 55% of games Ok record - doesn’t scream greatness Your argument is so...

Who is on the injury list at the moment Collard?? Haven’t seen him at training for a fortnight Crouch - still running laps Clark - Concussion Dow - Knee Butler - Ankle Hayes - Knee Van Es - Ankle Paton - Pec Sincs ???? Any others? Starting to mount up unfortunately. And practice matches haven’t eve...

All three were all excellent. Paton had a couple of major leg bones broken. Hayes was found out by the difference between SANFL and AFL. If we got him earlier could have been a world beater. McKenzie was in AA form before head planting off Rich and then his chronic leg muscle problems surfaced. All...

".....an average performer like Paton and Hayes or McKenzie" a bit harsh given the fact that, apart from injury, at least 2 out of the three would be PERMANENT members of our best 22, in my opinion!!!! Definitely a matter of opinion. McKenzie was a goer but in a strong team not necessaril...

And BM you posted or replied to my posts and I’m certain you didn’t even read what I wrote. I said that anyone with any longevity in the game will suffer bad injuries. Roo and Lenny no exceptions. But apart from a chronic knee which Roo handled superbly and Lenny suffering a couple of ACL’s and othe...

Lyon is the best coach in the AFL? Who thinks that?! He’s won zero premierships in 13 years of coaching which is almost a record Clarkson, Hardwick, McCrae and C Scott would easily be the best 3 coaches in the AFL Arguably Beveridge Longmire and Simpson next having succeeded Hinkley, Lyon and Fagan...

Vortex wrote: ↑Sat 10 Feb 2024 5:02pm

Moods wrote: ↑Sat 10 Feb 2024 4:33pm

drug ban

?

Genuine mistake. Thought he’d been banned for taking drugs. I’ve amended my original post. Poor by me