Jarred Roughead has the athletisism and flexibility to play back, midfield, forward...

Paddy is a slow moving forward

We are StKilda are we? What percentage of our players are from StK What percentage of our supporters are from StK What percentage of our games are played at StK How often do we train at StK ????? Last I checked, we walked out on that suburb in 1964. It was the best move we ever made! We made a GF st...

I think you confuse anti stkilda with reality? I love barracking StK but am not blind to the reality of its history?... Fact is We are unsuccessful We do make poor decisions We need to evolve/change to create history, not look to hang on to a past which is actually rubbish. The good old days at Moor...

I don't live in Tassie?! There are supporters who aren't from Moorabbin Moorabbin was a sh*thole .... good for 70s/80s suburban VFL footy where 20-30k was acceptable. It was even redundant in the 90s Our switch to Waverley and the docklands both coincided with a period of relative success. Moving = ...

Soul... pfftt


We should be trying to divorce ourself from a history littered with disappointment, despair and at times disgrace.

A new beginning would get my vote.

Sinclair is an outside player in th AFL, in the VFL he's an inside mid, a few years ago he was a small forward. It really depends on the role of player in the team... we pigeon hole the at StK (apparently Wright and Weller are only fwds now?) Mitch does win inside footy, but few players in the game ...

Would do that deal in a heartbeat!!!

And we'd win a flag in 3 years!

If I'm a paddy whacker, aren't you a lonie whacker? Perhaps you are not a true loyal sainted if you dare criticise a young player?! Paddy missed what, 3 last week and kicked 0 as the main key forward? Paddy is a 194cm 95kg number 1 draft pick Lonie a 174cm 72kg number 41 draft pick I reckon the expe...

He's been ok... some good games, was poor vs Adel ... hasn't starred, but played a role

In other words both have deficiencies and are not up to it?

Longer is just a s*** footballer!

So let's get this right Lonie got 18 as a small forward and was poor Dunstan got 18 as a mid and was good Lonie never missed a set shot, and is a terrible set shot Dunstan never made the distance from 35m I thought Gresham was very poor with the footy and needs a rest bad... he got 19 but played a l...

Very good first quarter!

10 possessions after that... finished again with 18...

Overall an OK game. Midfield was belted in the last Q.

Are you really saying Dunstan is better than Ben Cousins? Even at Richmond, collection 20 per game he was a fair bit better than what Luke dishes up. Cousins is rated one of the best mids of this generation... Luke is in the VFL I reckon Benny would run circles around Luke right now... it'd have to ...

Are you really saying Dunstan is better than Ben Cousins? Even at Richmond, collection 20 per game he was a fair bit better than what Luke dishes up. Cousins is rated one of the best mids of this generation... Luke is in the VFL I reckon Benny would run circles around Luke right now... it'd have to ...

Why isn't McCartin fitter?

3 pre seasons... is clearly not AFL fit

He was excellent in the VFL in 09 along with Armo

Should have been developed quicker

Embarrassing

He's hopeless

He is playing AFL because he's big... not because he's good

He dropped a mark last week an U14 would have taken.

Cousins was better in two years at the tigers than Dunstan has been in 4 at StK I'd take 1 of Cousins disposals to 2 of Dunstan's ... and Cousins got more of the ball anyway! Dunstan, Cripps and Petracca All have been a roaring success!!! And the other guy I had to eat Humble Pie over last year... w...

Not gonna sugar coat it

Dunstan is rubbish

Slow

Can't kick

Is poor defensively

Doesn't win it much inside or outside

Cannot play anywhere else but midfield but doesn't win enough ball in the midfield

If he doesn't get a shitload fitter he should be delisted

Peter Nights, Jezza, Billy Picken, Paul Vander Haar, Shaun Smith, Barker, Capper, Russell Robertson, Winmar, Modra, Ablett Snr, Brett Burton, Wnston Abraham, Jeff Farmer, Jeremy Howe... and here's a strange one, but he took a lot of hangers...

Sean Dempster!

I think it was fairly obvious then and is fairly obvious now?! Thank god he did a knee, imagine if he was 20 games further advanced!!! Those spraining about the importance of a forward outweighing a mid Ablett, Judd , Danger, Selwood, Martin, Mitchell, Watson, Fyfe, Swan, Black, Hayes, Bartel, Hodge...

Lost by about 4/5 goals

Minch and Lonie dominant, Freezer had good numbers

Bruce does a power of off the ball running

At the end of the day, power forwards need to hit the scoreboard or provide a contest for the smells to hit the contest Bruce 4 McCartin 0 Billings 1 Gresham 0 Membrey 0 Not sure if Weller scored, think he missed 2? And Jake Lever, Brodie Smith, Rory Laird were 3 of the best 6 on the ground... so fo...