He is an ITK. Gets the inside word and is usually pretty close. Told BF two weeks before that Carlisle would select the Saints. First with the Rice nomination Look what was tweeted tonight is all unlikely to come off however I have heard from another ITK today that Essendon were sweating and Dodoro...

Is he legit?

Could cry of happiness just reading this.

If it comes true I'll be shouting beers at the local to no end

-Pick 5 & future second rounder to Adelaide for pick 9, 13 & 28
-Pick 24 & 28 to GWS for pick 8
-Pick 13 for Carlisle and Pick 23
-Pick 23 for Freeman


We lose pick 5, 24 and a future second rounder
We gain 8, 9, Carlisle & Freeman


Any takers?

CQ SAINT wrote:I will take it. Not sure GWS would though.

Pick 8 from GWS has been dubbed a sitting duck because they need to trade it to get enough points for the academy

-Pick 5 & future second rounder to Adelaide for pick 9, 13 & 28
-Pick 24 & 28 to GWS for pick 8
-Pick 13 for Carlisle and Pick 23
-Pick 23 for Freeman


We lose pick 5, 24 and a future second rounder
We gain 8, 9, Carlisle & Freeman


Any takers?

If we work on the theory that we are going to lose pick 5 and therefore miss out on Mathieson/Oliver then I think we should look at an outside indigenous player like Daniel Rioli or Aidyn Johnson with pick 24. The Bombers could end up with 4 top 25 picks to our 1. That is quite distressing. Sounds ...

Why don't we just take him PSD and keep 5?!? That may happen yet, the only thing I'm concerned about is that Carton have said that if Carlisle is in the PSD they will select him. We'd need to front end his contract up heavily, I don't know how their cap space is going with the movements theyve had ...

Why don't we just take him PSD and keep 5?!?

Just came third in the Stingrays Best and Fairest

you people do realise that we would have 23 24 and 25 sent to GWS for pick 8 if the drug cheats accepted the deal. We just down grade 5 to 8 and still get Mathesion. Get with the program you guys - sheesh. Exactly, well put mate. Even if we upped our offer for Carlisle to include our third pick (#4...

I personally think the Hawks have us by the balls and it is all over but if we pull this off via the PSD and screw Essendon I am going pants off for a week and sending Bains a long and perfumed love letter. You've posted in this thread and the Carlisle thread over a million times tonight and NOT ON...

On the AFL end of day trade wrap, they are saying that Carlisles manager has all but ruled out Carlisle defecting the the Hawks and he is more likely to try his luck in the PSD to get to us

You're all such crusty old sooks. Read between the lines. Again the club and Carlisle have come out and said I WANT TO PLAY FOR ST.KILDA. If Essendon don't accept the deal he puts a price on his head and walks to us. Doesn't take calls from anyone and says he only wants the Saints ala Luke Ball. Bef...

Perhaps St.Kilda is waiting on another trade before they make a decision on what to give for Jake, like Dixon from Gold Coast to Port Adelaide. Perhaps we're trading pick 5 to the Suns for 2 picks. Just an idea. How long can we wait? Trade period is almost over and we have already had weeks to work...

Bombers rejected the offer. The way I read the release.. It's very much one of those "read between the lines things" The offer we gave would not have been pick 5 and not something Essendon would like. But we've now offered something, that both the club and Carlisle believe is fair.. Paving...

For all this navel gazing - we STILL dont have an actual offer on the table for Essendon. We have had weeks to table an offer. We havent delivered. We needed to put up or shut up. It was obvious that we needed either a pick 10-15 OR a pick + a player to get it done. We never actually came up with a...

Shut up you grumpy old galoot^

Here's the thing. Jake could jump on to the over flowing bandwagon of Hawthorn and be a side kick to the greatest team ever. Before watch the wheels fall off right before his eyes as Mitchell, Hodge ect retire. Or he could join us, endure some short term pain, but work towards behind a key part in a...

Built not bought. Just look at LeBron v the Spurs. What does that even mean in a football context? LeBron keeps surrounding himself with a handful of stars who take all the cash and then are left with no depth and only role players at best. The Spurs drafted Duncan, Parker ect ect, they take pay cu...

Jaxsons... Dylan Shiel?...

Is he any good and he is what we need?

If he wasn't a father son would we be after him?

Built not bought.
Just look at LeBron v the Spurs.

Brisbane are angry at the compo they will get for Luey and might match it.

If that happens Essendon might reconsider the supposed Hickey and 24 offer

Trade-guy Ralph on SEN an hour ago reckons the Carlisle tug of war will go to the 11th. hour or 'late Thursday' as he put it. Essendon no doubt have the strategy of not budging from their demands to get Pick 5, assuming the Saints will cave-in to their feudal overlords in red & black @ the end ...