The mention of a review and change of job titles is just a method to move on Toce` without the back lash. They are suggesting on BF that we have Simon Dalrymple lined up to replace him, hopefully that is the case.

Keeler is an exceptional talent and when he grows into a mans body will be capable of playing any where. I havent seen Max Heath training and rucking against Marshall or Campbell, but lets remember Campbell is a colossus of human and Marshall is in the top 3 ruckman in the AFL. People who are writin...

He is a handy player but I think at this time he will remain a back up player. For me he needs to drop 5-10kgs of bulk so he can improve his running to the next level. As hard as they train it is really hard for some individuals to drop weight. If he could get his aerobic fitness up he would be a go...

Ripping report thanks BM.

Thanks Mike - hopefully we have a better run with injuries this preseason.

Good luck to Jack hopefully he gets another chance. Obviously Collingwoood are looking for some back up inside types after losing Taylor Adams.

Bonner can run and can kick, there is beyond a doubt an undeniable pattern forming. I’m guessing RTB wants either NWM up on a wing or Sinclair more on ball, therefore looking at some options for run and delivery out of the back half. Time to get super fit Hunter Clark! I very much doubt we will see...

There are posters on BF suggesting Wilson might now slide through to us - that would be huge if we get a player like Darcy at our pick.

I would love to see the club produce a supporters/sponsors name collage with everyones names who donated more than a certain sum added to the board. I remember reading West Ham did something similar with pavers layed with their financial supporters names engraved in them. Something that wouldn't cos...

Stewart’s a very average footballer plus is in the wrong age demographic…much rather we had a look at Emerson Jeka I was hoping we would look at Stewart when he departed GWS but that was years ago. Now at 29/30 he is at the end of the road, surely we can find another backup key defender option rath...

Ross has very little to do with drafting - sits in on meetings and challenges scenarios But at the end of the day he barely knows the kids getting drafted Glad you have confidence Our head recruiter selected Matthew Allison with our first pick (26) in recent years - he was a reach at 26 and after a...

I dont think Gresham will take much replacing, but Henry or Zak Jones are the obvious. Then if we take mid/forwards at this years draft they could fit the bill eg Demattia, Johnston, Mannagh or Simpson would all be options, plus Olli Hotton.

Just saw Stewart from Essendon training over Summer. Was udner contract at Essendon and delisted - so gets paid by Essendon. If we were to pick him up , and obviously only if good enough, will basically cost nothing. Where did you see that? After delisting Adams & Highmore we obviously need ano...

The decision to give Campbell another year highlights how vulnerable we are in the ruck. Also suggests they aren’t too sure about Heath getting past next year We are stuffed if RoMa isn’t available. I cant see how you can make those assumptions regarding Max Heath? I think its the contrary, with th...

The decision to give Campbell another year highlights how vulnerable we are in the ruck. Also suggests they aren’t too sure about Heath getting past next year We are stuffed if RoMa isn’t available. I cant see how you can make those assumptions regarding Max Heath? I think its the contrary, with th...

Would love to get him but he will be well gone before our pick, unless we trade up of course.

66Iwasthere wrote: ↑Sat 21 Oct 2023 1:13pm Pity this thread drifted into the negative, once again, when all Tony was doing was highlighting a positive ie some players training at the club during their off season and in particular the very good news that one of those players was Tim Membrey.

100% agree!

You would think Campbell will only be on the list for 1 more year next season. Hayes is not a genuine ruckman. Heath is the future No 1 ruckman and Keeler is more the ideal tall forward 2nd string ruckman. If we lose Marshall to injury I doubt Heath is ready to step up and Campbell is not really AFL...

I’d expect nothing less from you Tony Imo Anyone who thinks it’s a positive that we are paying players to play at other clubs is a delusional sycophant Surely you can express your opinion without the drive bys? We get it you disagree with the list management decisions, but Tony is a poster of great...

Stocker for me looked like he was struggling for fitness by the end of the season - he looked like he had become too heavy and sluggish in his movement. I think he is a player that needs to be mindful of his weight and how much he does in the gym. Having said that he plays with a bit of aggression a...

The trade mantra at St Kilda is - trade in high and trade out when players are worth nothing.

I think the Saints wanted to trade Dougal, but as he is contracted he didnt want to leave as is his right. Be interested to see what changes next year if Cordy can improve his fitness and strength he might go past Dougal.

There are whispers over on the Dogs BF board that we are showing interest in Rory Lobb and he may become part of the Coffield trade. A lot on their board also want to target Billings, suggesting he has the game to compliment their forward line.

I believe if Membrey does retire we are a chance to offer McLaughlin a position, otherwise I doubt there will be sufficient list spots. Hopefully Members bounces back and gets his health sorted, he is an important link to our forward structures.