we will never get an answer other than it was approved by the AFL

Martin
Fyfe
Bruest

Nothing was going to happen this year as soon as our first round draft pick was given away. :roll: So, we have 2 second round draft picks this year. BIG deal. But no 1st rounder this year which would have been a top 10 draft pick. :roll: pick 10 is overrated. More overrated than pick 23? Come on! Y...

a dusting of icing sugar on the top.

Jacks Back wrote:Nothing was going to happen this year as soon as our first round draft pick was given away.

So, we have 2 second round draft picks this year. BIG deal. But no 1st rounder this year which would have been a top 10 draft pick.

pick 10 is overrated.

is depth more harshly judged when you have more top end talent?

You want to follow the crap Hawks trading ? They traded picks 10,23,36,,48,66,70 from this year and 1st.and 2nd rounders next year for O,Meara dont get in the draft till 3rd. round next year. So now they have to trade more players out to get back in to the 2017 draft,they are going down the Freo pa...

Just been looking at the AFL trade tracker. They have the Koby Stevens deal now showing as deal 39 lodged at 1.58PM. The last deal lodged before 2:00PM dealine. One minute later would have been fine, two minutes later the deal gets rejected. The AFL indicative draft order still can't sort out Carlt...

stonecold wrote:

saintspremiers wrote:I'll back Jaxsons and Tone over Stonedcold any day!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Geez, that really hurts, or it would if I cared!!!!!

this thread clearly exists only because you care what others think.

Doesn't say anything about a big fish this year.

What if Lids had gone to Geelong?

ausfatcat wrote:Did he get anything close to right before it was in the papers?

Yes but he whispered it, no one heard it.

B: Geary - Brown - Dempster HB: Roberton - Carlisle - Newnes C: Acres - Armitage - Riewoldt HF: Billings - Bruce - Steele F: Weller - McCartin - Membrey R: Hickey - Steven - Ross INT: Dunstan, Montagna, Savage, K Stevens EMG: Sinclair, McKenzie, Lonie Very very tricky. I agreed with this until I no...

ForTUNAtely it wasn't JO'M.

mitchell was a good get. but they also lost hill with nothing to show, and next years first rounder, and two ageing B&F 1st & 2nd players. that's a draft plus a 1st plus a best 22 player for two elite mids (albeit with one under a cloud) with two seniors out the door. wouldn't want to be a h...

dragit wrote:

Playon wrote:

dragit wrote:Nothing like a good old fashioned SS pissing contest...

Its not a pissing contest i just dont like seeing someone being burnt

I'm actually trying to encourage you bro.


The family reunion would be the Weller brothers surely?

i'm assuming we were never going to get both brown brothers?

Possible late breaking news... St Kilda are about to offer picks 23, 36 and Hawthorn's 2017 first round pick to Freo for FYFE. My source is my brother's best man who has links with someone at the Saints. Let's see what happens in the next 90 minutes. What a load of nonsense. You didn't really expec...

NO to 13 or 15. Top 8 is elite. 9-30/35 is very even. Happy to keep 23 and get a very good player. Back our recruiters to find a nugget at 36 too. Next year start with 2 first rounders and hit FA hard. Will be in an excellent position post 2017 draft. (Roo, Joey and Dempster probably be finishing u...

Hawthrotn can't get a player to go to Gold Coast. Maybe they could get a player to go to St Kilda, and we give them back pick 36 for their troubles. They can then take the 36 to try to get O'Meara over the line. Otherwise, we could involve ourselves in a three way deal - Hawks, us, and another Melb...

Mav is the sexy choice.
Gears the nuggety choice.
Others are too young or not right, except maybe Armo.
Expect Armo for 2 years.

Just google the headline in an incognito tab in google chrome, other browsers might have something similar, you'll get in.

Goose is king wrote:Do 23 and 36 really add up to more points than 13? Otherwise why would GWS do it? Sounds like a great deal for the Saints

Yes, 1317 (815 + 502) which is more than 1212. Points table: http://www.afl.com.au/staticfile/AFL%20 ... -value.pdf

Gershwin wrote:Brett Anderson (twitter):
"If No.13 gets to GWS via CARL in Gibbs/Marchbank deals, don't rule out STK shipping 23 & 36 for 13. Would be cunning dealing by Saints."

Which would mean in effect we get 13 + Hawks 2017 1st for 10 + 68. The Hawks really stunk it up with that trade.

Well done by the Stevenses's